I would agree but I can't imagine disney calling it a succes, I imagine if it is a failure we will for sure not see a next Indy game. Oh well..

Indy is not doing great on numbers alone but literally has a 4 year dev cycle (efficient) Is mostly an FPS Adventur/Puzzle game. I think it's sales expectations are not as high as some may expect but PS is definitely needed to it a "hit" but I think it will also be short lived there. I think modern audiences want a 3rd erson action adventure ala Uncharted

The IP hasn't been relevant for 20+ years, so it won't necessarily compel sales high if the core game is quite niche

That's the reason why I am not touching this game when it releases on PS5. I prefer 3rd person over 1st person. So I will buy and play Gears when it comes over but not Indy. 

Xbox really is going full force behind digital only with nearly 90% of Xbox's sold not having a disc drive. At this point the next Xbox having a disc drive would be kind of a shock. The PS5 Pro falling behind the PS4 Pro is also notable. The high price didn't seem to impact the launch much but now that the enthusiasts have gotten one that's gonna harm the appeal for more typical buyers so it probably won't help as much this year as the PS4 Pro did in 2017. Also is there an estimate for how much the consoles would've sold compared to last January if they both had the same weeks?

The numbers for the US in January are:

• PS5 - 250k
• Switch - 125k
• XBSX - 123k

Given the weekly numbers, if we add 1 more average week the numbers would be something like this:

• PS5 - 310k
• Switch - 155k
• XBSX - 152k

I was meaning a proper sort of one but if that isn't available then that should hopefully be close enough. 

Brutal numbers..... huge drops all around in the US.

What sort of week do you expect ? What do you have in mind ? If you mean the first week of January then we can simply add those numbers and you get the following:

• PS5: 387k
• Switch: 206k
• XBSX: 186k

However this is not exactly fair, since the week has 3 days, and "proper" for me means also fair. Of course, depending on what portion of the sales are in December, and what in January we can shave 3 days, and those figures can go back a little to:

• PS5: 300-320k
• Switch: 150-170k
• XBSX: 140-160k

My numbers in the previous post were average numbers based on the 4 weeks, but if you want natural continuation (since every week for each system is down from the previous one) then:

• PS5: 305k
• Switch: 149k
• XBSX: 146k

Comparing the exact same four week period for both is what I have in mind but what you've shown should be close enough. Either way it'll back to normal for February so long term doesn't really matter.

Have you played it?