Smeags on 11 November 2012
| # | Name | Console(s) | Year | Genre | Score |
| 50 | Batman: Arkham Asylum | PC/PS3/X360 | 2009 | Action-Adventure | 92 |
| 49 | Heroes of Might & Magic III | PC | 1999 | Strategy | 87 |
| 48 | Fire Emblem: Path of Radiance | GCN | 2005 | Strategy | 85 |
| 47 | Rock Band 3 | PS3/X360/Wii | 2010 | Rhythm/Music | 93 |
| 46 | WarCraft II: Tides of Darkness/Beyond the Dark Portal | PC | 1995 | Strategy | 95 |
| 45 | Castlevania: Circle of the Moon | GBA | 2001 | Action | 91 |
| 44 | Paper Mario | N64/Wii | 2001 | RPG | 93 |
| 43 | TimeSplitters 2 | GCN/PS2/Xbox | 2002 | Shooter | 90 |
| 42 | Super Smash Bros. | N64/Wii | 1999 | Fighter | 79 |
| 41 | Super Mario Sunshine | GCN | 2002 | Platform | 92 |
| 40 | Castlevania: Order of Ecclesia | DS | 2008 | Action | 85 |
| 39 | Diddy Kong Racing | N64 | 1997 | Racing | 88 |
| 38 | Metroid Prime 3: Corruption | Wii |
2007 |
Action-Adventure |
90 |
| 37 | Sonic the Hedgehog 3 | Genesis | 1994 | Platform | 89 |
| 36 | Super Mario 3D Land | 3DS | 2011 | Platform | 90 |
| 35 | Donkey Kong Country 2: Diddy's Kong Quest | SNES/Wii | 1995 | Platform | 90 |
| 34 | Bioshock | PC/PS3/X360 | 2007 | Shooter | 96 |
| 33 | Pokemon Diamond/Pearl | DS | 2007 | RPG | 85 |
| 32 | Fire Emblem: Radiant Dawn | Wii | 2007 | Strategy | 78 |
| 31 | Donkey Kong Country Returns | Wii | 2010 | Platform | 87 |
| 30 | StarCraft/Brood War |
PC | 1998 | Strategy | 88 |
| 29 | TimeSplitters: Future Perfect |
GCN/PS2/Xbox | 2005 | Shooter | 84 |
| 28 | Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door | GCN | 2004 | RPG | 87 |
| 27 | Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island | SNES/GBA | 1995 | Platform | 91 |
| 26 | The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim | PC/PS3/X360 | 2011 | RPG | 96 |
| 25 | New Super Mario Bros. Wii | Wii | 2009 | Platform | 87 |
| 24 | Batman: Arkham City | PC/PS3/X360 | 2011 | Action-Adventure | 96 |
| 23 | Disney's Epic Mickey | Wii | 2010 | Action-Adventure | 73 |
| 22 | Super Smash Bros. Melee | GCN | 2001 | Fighting | 92 |
| 21 | Pokemon Black/White | DS | 2011 | RPG | 87 |
| 20 | Super Smash Bros. Brawl | Wii | 2008 | Fighting | 93 |
| 19 | The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess | Wii | 2006 | Action-Adventure | 95 |
| 18 | Okami | Wii | 2008 | Action-Adventure | 93 |
| 17 | Banjo-Kazooie | N64 | 1998 | Platform | 92 |
| 16 | Pokemon Gold/Silver | GB/DS | 2000 | RPG | 90 |
| 15 | Mario Kart 64 | N64/Wii | 1997 | Racing | 83 |
| 14 | The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker | GCN | 2003 | Action-Adventure | 96 |
| 13 | Resident Evil 4 | GCN/Wii | 2005 | Action-Adventure | 96 |
| 12 | WarCraft III: Reign of Chaos/The Frozen Throne | PC | 2002 | Strategy | 92 |
| 11 | Conker's Bad Fur Day | N64/Xbox | 2001 | Action-Adventure | 92 |
| 10 | Metroid Prime | GCN/Wii | 2002 | Action-Adventure | 97 |
| 9 | The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword | Wii | 2011 | Action-Adventure | 93 |
| 8 | Super Mario 64 | N64/DS | 1996 | Platform | 94 |
| 7 | Pokemon Red/Blue/Yellow | GB/GBA | 1998 | RPG | 88 |
| 6 | The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time | N64/3DS | 1998 | Action-Adventure | 99 |
| 5 | Super Mario Galaxy | Wii | 2007 | Platform | 97 |
| 4 | Super Mario World | SNES/GBA | 1991 | Platform | 92 |
| 3 | Sonic the Hedgehog 2 | Genesis | 1992 | Platform | 88 |
| 2 | Sonic & Knuckles | Genesis | 1994 | Platform | 88 |
| 1 | Super Mario Galaxy 2 | Wii | 2010 | Platform | 97 |
