November Circana (NPD) 2024 Thread + Predictions

[XtremeBG]

Phenomajp13 said:

So basically you are upset you got it wrong again, where on the front page you expected Switch to be significantly down and instead it's flat or up but you are bothered by posters saying it's up because you know what this means in the grand scheme of surpassing a certain milestone. Also, as usual, you came up with excuses of why you were wrong such as Xbox is collapsing and Switch had retailer deals. Thats my assessment of this post, am I accurate here? You tell me!

You are not accurate here, because you make your own interpretations of what I wrote, and put words in my mouth (and not only this time but pretty much every time). I am simply saying my opinion on the US sales for November here while answering @javi741 's question. I can't be upset or happy if a console is doing well or bad (no matter which one it is) since it's not so much important to me, to have feelings or to take it so personal the way you explained it here. Also you are wrong. I have never ever made predictions for November, for them to be wrong. If you point to the comment in one of the articles that one was for the holiday period not for November alone. And when December is over you will see that my projection was correct, or at least close. Also I can't be bothered by poster let alone good one like @javi741 . The only one here who is bothered by posters according to my observations is you, whenever there is a post about doubting Switch continuing sales or mention PS2, you always jump.

A certain milestone ? Do you really think that some hundreds of units more (assuming you are saying it like I am expecting 400k or something and is doing 580k) is something compared to more than 15M more left ? It's nothing. But to answer your point, I have never thought of that milestone since some 2 weeks ago when the discussion about that was last bring up by some other posters and I read over the posts. You obviously take this whole thing with the milestone like some dream of yours, that you constantly think of, since you are mentioning it in almost each of your posts. Well if it's that, it's not that for all the other people.

Last edited by XtremeBG - 5 days ago