By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - GTA VI Vs. Current Gen - Is it time to move on?

curl-6 said:
Zkuq said:

I don't believe for a moment that games like Uncharted and TLoU wouldn't have been possible on their consoles in essentially the same form, except for some graphical downgrades, had they been 60 FPS. Those games don't seem CPU-limited to me. The others you mentioned have some potential for being CPU-limited, but I'm not so sure about all of them. But yes, there is always a cost to aiming for a higher framerate, I just don't think it would usually affect gameplay itself but only graphics instead. Whether you prefer better graphics or higher framerate is subjective, of course, so no objection from me if you just say you prefer better-looking games even if it means a lower framerate.

Also, GTA5 felt kind of painful on PS3, precisely because of its framerate. I haven't generally had issues with 30 FPS games in the past, but GTA5 felt very suboptimal. I'd say they definitely tried to push the hardware a bit too far with that one.

Uncharted and TLOU often have a good number of enemy characters in play with detailed (for the time) AI behaviours, animations, ragdolls, etc. in fairly sizeable environments which in Uncharted often break apart and shift in huge setpiece moments. No way you'd get those to a solid 60fps on PS3/4 without simplifying the scenarios.

Those are generally really not large numbers of enemies, it should be possible to implement that with fairly modest hardware. Besides AI, everything you mentioned is largely visual and can easily be downgraded if necessary. Setpiece moments are probably mostly hardcoded rather than simulated, and most of the computational expense probably comes from the visuals where there's e.g. a lot of debris flying around. Don't get me wrong, there's some CPU-heavy stuff there as far as I know, but besides AI, it can probably be largely downgraded without more than slight visual impact, and I don't think AI is sufficient to impose a low framerate.



Around the Network

Rockstar has never been known for their frame rates in games.



I think it is as simple as the ps5 has, by today's standard, a very weak CPU. It is just showing it's age, plus GTA6 (against some silly theories) is built for impact + longevitity. Meaning with a billion investment and a decade of development, they want it to be technically relevant for next-gen systems, which is exactly what they did. It isn't much different than Indiana w/ PT running 20 fps on my 4090. The intent is in the future technology will catch-up to the game.



GOAT: GTA6

Highest Rated Ever + Record Sales

HoloDust said:

GTA VI is precursor of what can be expected from future games simulation and systems wise - actually, I expect them to be much heavier than GTA VI, with all the AI NPCs and systemic world governed by AI GMs (Ubisoft announced its Motherbrain studio that is developing tech for such future titles). So I don't see current limit GPU wise (though there is one), as much as there is CPU and NPU wise for future titles.

That said, PS6/Helix are just around the corner, and will have more than enough power for those tasks.

All of those games are going to run on PS5/XSX and that PS6 Portable (which likely at 20 watts max is going to be what? Even worse than the XBox Series S is to the current gen) for years, probably for most of the PS6's product cycle. Games being greenlit today are going to require 5-8 year dev cycles, no one today is commiting to making next gen exclusives at the sky high budgets. 

No one is lining up to make exclusive content for $1000-$1500 consoles that are going to sell much more slowly than previous generations at $500 million dollar budgets. Even $850-$900 would be out of a lot of people's budget range. Higher software budget for a shrinking audience, yeah no thanks business wise is what most publishers, probably even Sony themselves is going to say. 

PS6/Helix are just going to be PS5 games with higher frame rate + ray tracing turned up higher. Likely well into 2033-2035 even, those game projects are being greenlight like this year, early next year to be able to make even those windows. 

And then eventually Nvidia's AI slop filters on top of graphics will just make those consoles look quaint on top of that for those willing to drop $2000+ on a PC GPU. 

Almost all games, especially the higher budget ones are going to have to support PS5/XSX/Portable PS6 (and what kind of CPU really is that going to have? That much better than a PS5? A what? 15-20 watts total including the screen ... good luck). 

Last edited by Soundwave - 1 day ago

Soundwave said:
HoloDust said:

GTA VI is precursor of what can be expected from future games simulation and systems wise - actually, I expect them to be much heavier than GTA VI, with all the AI NPCs and systemic world governed by AI GMs (Ubisoft announced its Motherbrain studio that is developing tech for such future titles). So I don't see current limit GPU wise (though there is one), as much as there is CPU and NPU wise for future titles.

That said, PS6/Helix are just around the corner, and will have more than enough power for those tasks.

All of those games are going to run on PS5/XSX and that PS6 Portable (which likely at 20 watts max is going to be what? Even worse than the XBox Series S is to the current gen) for years, probably for most of the PS6's product cycle. Games being greenlit today are going to require 5-8 year dev cycles, no one today is commiting to making next gen exclusives at the sky high budgets. 

No one is lining up to make exclusive content for $1000-$1500 consoles that are going to sell much more slowly than previous generations at $500 million dollar budgets. Even $850-$900 would be out of a lot of people's budget range. Higher software budget for a shrinking audience, yeah no thanks business wise is what most publishers, probably even Sony themselves is going to say. 

PS6/Helix are just going to be PS5 games with higher frame rate + ray tracing turned up higher. Likely well into 2033-2035 even, those game projects are being greenlight like this year, early next year to be able to make even those windows. 

And then eventually Nvidia's AI slop filters on top of graphics will just make those consoles look quaint on top of that. 

Exclusives are dead, have been dead on PC for decades.  This isn't 1990 anymore where game engines are hardware specific.  Modern game engines are scalable.  I would be surprised if there is ever a ps6 game that isn't on the ps5.  Generations are dead.  



GOAT: GTA6

Highest Rated Ever + Record Sales

Around the Network
Chrkeller said:
Soundwave said:

All of those games are going to run on PS5/XSX and that PS6 Portable (which likely at 20 watts max is going to be what? Even worse than the XBox Series S is to the current gen) for years, probably for most of the PS6's product cycle. Games being greenlit today are going to require 5-8 year dev cycles, no one today is commiting to making next gen exclusives at the sky high budgets. 

No one is lining up to make exclusive content for $1000-$1500 consoles that are going to sell much more slowly than previous generations at $500 million dollar budgets. Even $850-$900 would be out of a lot of people's budget range. Higher software budget for a shrinking audience, yeah no thanks business wise is what most publishers, probably even Sony themselves is going to say. 

PS6/Helix are just going to be PS5 games with higher frame rate + ray tracing turned up higher. Likely well into 2033-2035 even, those game projects are being greenlight like this year, early next year to be able to make even those windows. 

And then eventually Nvidia's AI slop filters on top of graphics will just make those consoles look quaint on top of that. 

Exclusives are dead, have been dead on PC for decades.  This isn't 1990 anymore where game engines are hardware specific.  Modern game engines are scalable.  I would be surprised if there is ever a ps6 game that isn't on the ps5.  Generations are dead.  

Even if it was 1990, very few developer would  invest in exclusives if the Super NES was $500+ for the time and it was mandated that it had to be cross compatible with a Game Boy too and making games cost 100x more. 

Likely Sony is going to push everything having to be playable on the PS6 Portable because they're not going to get the same level of hardware sales from just the base PS6 due to price, which is going to be an even tighter restriction than XBox Series S was this gen. 

You're hard capped right there from day 1, there's no magic mobile CPU that's going to run circles around what's already inside a PS5/XB Series S even at a 15-20 watt total system + screen ceiling. 

Developers are going to be stuck working on that range of CPU for a long, long time to come, too bad, so sad. 



Soundwave said:
Chrkeller said:

Exclusives are dead, have been dead on PC for decades.  This isn't 1990 anymore where game engines are hardware specific.  Modern game engines are scalable.  I would be surprised if there is ever a ps6 game that isn't on the ps5.  Generations are dead.  

Even if it was 1990, very few developer would  invest in exclusives if the Super NES was $500+ for the time and it was mandated that it had to be cross compatible with a Game Boy too and making games cost 100x more. 

Likely Sony is going to push everything having to be playable on the PS6 Portable because they're not going to get the same level of hardware sales from just the base PS6 due to price, which is going to be an even tighter restriction than XBox Series S was this gen. 

Certainly, it is a combination of things.  Time, development costs, uniformity in hardware, scalability, etc.  Either way, most exclusives are dead.  Generations are dead.  Consoles will continue to be more PC like.  My PC plays today's games and games from 20 years ago.  I get to pick my settings.  The ps6 will not, IMO, have any exclusives.    



GOAT: GTA6

Highest Rated Ever + Record Sales

It's exactly that. Cutrent gen wasn't enough on the CPU side. They went to heavy on GPU, even with the PS5 PRO.



The PS4/Xbox One versions of GTA V only launched a year after the previous gen versions. They definitely sold more on the later consoles as well. GTA VI may force Sony and MS to release their next gen consoles around the same time, lest they give the other a head start on the enhanced GTA VI experience.



http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F1gWECYYOSo

Please Watch/Share this video so it gets shown in Hollywood.

Zkuq said:
curl-6 said:

Uncharted and TLOU often have a good number of enemy characters in play with detailed (for the time) AI behaviours, animations, ragdolls, etc. in fairly sizeable environments which in Uncharted often break apart and shift in huge setpiece moments. No way you'd get those to a solid 60fps on PS3/4 without simplifying the scenarios.

Those are generally really not large numbers of enemies, it should be possible to implement that with fairly modest hardware. Besides AI, everything you mentioned is largely visual and can easily be downgraded if necessary. Setpiece moments are probably mostly hardcoded rather than simulated, and most of the computational expense probably comes from the visuals where there's e.g. a lot of debris flying around. Don't get me wrong, there's some CPU-heavy stuff there as far as I know, but besides AI, it can probably be largely downgraded without more than slight visual impact, and I don't think AI is sufficient to impose a low framerate.

The Uncharted games have quite a lot of physics type stuff going on at times, in Uncharted 3 for example on the cruise ship, according to Naughty Dog the whole boat is a physics object driven by the wave simulation below, which effects how objects on the boat from characters to crates to water moves around as it sways, same for the level set on floating jetties in the rough sea and others.

The way Drake and other characters interact with the environments as they traverse them, (including moving objects where said movement effects the characters) which is key to gameplay feel, is also driven by a complex animation blending system running on the Cell.

Then there's level streaming in the background to consider as the UC games avoid loading screens for the most part, scripting for the more complex setpieces with a lot of moving parts, etc.

To get them running at 60fps you'd have to cut back on all this and the wouldn't be the same games.