The issue with moving on is cost. Selling a console at or above 1k is going to send us back to 90's-level sales. The whole industry will shrink.
The issue with moving on is cost. Selling a console at or above 1k is going to send us back to 90's-level sales. The whole industry will shrink.
curl-6 said:
The Uncharted games have quite a lot of physics type stuff going on at times, in Uncharted 3 for example on the cruise ship, according to Naughty Dog the whole boat is a physics object driven by the wave simulation below, which effects how objects on the boat from characters to crates to water moves around as it sways, same for the level set on floating jetties in the rough sea and others. The way Drake and other characters interact with the environments as they traverse them, (including moving objects where said movement effects the characters) which is key to gameplay feel, is also driven by a complex animation blending system running on the Cell. Then there's level streaming in the background to consider as the UC games avoid loading screens for the most part, scripting for the more complex setpieces with a lot of moving parts, etc. To get them running at 60fps you'd have to cut back on all this and the wouldn't be the same games. |
Fair points, but I still think it's not enough to make it impossible to have 60 FPS. I guess some parts might have been trickier though, e.g. the whole ship thing, which I had forgotten about. Unless some developer has shared their knowledge in greater detail, I suspect we'll have to agree to disagree once again.
| JackHandy said: The issue with moving on is cost. Selling a console at or above 1k is going to send us back to 90's-level sales. The whole industry will shrink. |
This. I don't know how crazy prices will be in 2029-2030, but it might be smart to wait until then for PS6.
Helix I feel will be out in 2028. maybe 2029.
Going into PS5 and Xbox Series X/S was already an issue because of the COVID-19 pandemic. Going into Helix and PS6 will be problematic because of the current RAM and AI crises. We're going to feel those impacts for a while.
Lifetime Sales Predictions
Switch: 159 million (was 73 million, then 96 million, then 113 million, then 125 million, then 144 million, then 151 million, then 156 million, then 161 million)
PS5: 116 million (was 105 million, then 115 million, then 122 million)
Xbox Series X/S: 38 million (was 60 million, then 67 million, then 57 million. then 48 million. then 40 million)
Switch 2: 120 million (was 116 million)
PS4: 120 mil (was 100 then 130 million, then 122 million) Xbox One: 51 mil (was 50 then 55 mil)
3DS: 75.5 mil (was 73, then 77 million)
"Let go your earthly tether, enter the void, empty and become wind." - Guru Laghima


Zkuq said:
Fair points, but I still think it's not enough to make it impossible to have 60 FPS. I guess some parts might have been trickier though, e.g. the whole ship thing, which I had forgotten about. Unless some developer has shared their knowledge in greater detail, I suspect we'll have to agree to disagree once again. |
Yeah fair enough; if you'd like examples of games on the same hardware that are lean more into this stuff than Uncharted, I'd say titles such as Far Cry 2/3/4, Battlefield 3/4, Red Faction Guerilla, the Assassin's Creed games, Batman Arkham City/Origins, etc are games that wouldn't really work on PS3/360 at 60fps.
curl-6 said:
Yeah fair enough; if you'd like examples of games on the same hardware that are lean more into this stuff than Uncharted, I'd say titles such as Far Cry 2/3/4, Battlefield 3/4, Red Faction Guerilla, the Assassin's Creed games, Batman Arkham City/Origins, etc are games that wouldn't really work on PS3/360 at 60fps. |
I don't know or remember enough of some of the games you mentioned, but here's my thoughts on the ones I think I do:


Zkuq said:
I don't know or remember enough of some of the games you mentioned, but here's my thoughts on the ones I think I do:
|
Far Cry 2 had a ton of physics from destructible foliage (which even reacts and bends out of the way when you touch it, something many modern games don't even do) and structures to fire that spread and are influenced by factors such as wind like in BOTW, you could even shoot individual twigs off trees and bushes. 3 also had fire propogation, plus just how draining having an open world with aggressive data streaming was on 7th gen hardware.
curl-6 said:
Far Cry 2 had a ton of physics from destructible foliage (which even reacts and bends out of the way when you touch it, something many modern games don't even do) and structures to fire that spread and are influenced by factors such as wind like in BOTW, you could even shoot individual twigs off trees and bushes. 3 also had fire propogation, plus just how draining having an open world with aggressive data streaming was on 7th gen hardware. |
People forget sometimes that before Ubisoft become Ubislop, they were actually really good and innovative.
FC2 might've been, from the perspective of someone who was fan of original Crytek's FarCry, a bit of a disappointment game structure wise (though that quickly passed once I figured out "this is not actually FarCry"), but standing on its own it was really great game with lot of things that not even today most games have - some you mentioned, I'll add projectile deflection of heavy weapons, real time weather system and weapon degradation. When FC3 launched there was at least few videos comparing how much less systemic wise FC3 was compared to FC2.
Wman1996 said:
This. I don't know how crazy prices will be in 2029-2030, but it might be smart to wait until then for PS6. Helix I feel will be out in 2028. maybe 2029. Going into PS5 and Xbox Series X/S was already an issue because of the COVID-19 pandemic. Going into Helix and PS6 will be problematic because of the current RAM and AI crises. We're going to feel those impacts for a while. |
Yes, and I don't really see the demand for it, at least online. Sales don't back that up, either. If gamers are happy with the current state of affairs, just keep feeding them software. That's what I would do. No need to pull a mid-90's Sega and start dropping expensive, half-baked upgrades on them.
| JackHandy said: The issue with moving on is cost. Selling a console at or above 1k is going to send us back to 90's-level sales. The whole industry will shrink. |
^THIS!! We need to allow more time for the current generation of consoles to recoup any losses before we can start working on the next generation of consoles. We cannot go back to the days of 3DO and CD-i console prices.

JackHandy said:
Yes, and I don't really see the demand for it, at least online. Sales don't back that up, either. If gamers are happy with the current state of affairs, just keep feeding them software. That's what I would do. No need to pull a mid-90's Sega and start dropping expensive, half-baked upgrades on them. |
That's what killed the Dreamcast. -_-
