By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - GTA VI Vs. Current Gen - Is it time to move on?

Zkuq said:
curl-6 said:

Hot take, but I've long felt the dogged insistence on 60fps has held PS5/Xbox Series X back somewhat.

30fps gives devs way more headroom not just for graphics but also simulation, physics, etc. Games like say GTA6, BOTW/TOTK, RDR2, GTA5, Uncharted 1-4, TLOU1/2, etc wouldn't have been possible on their target hardware if 60fps was a requirement.

I don't believe for a moment that games like Uncharted and TLoU wouldn't have been possible on their consoles in essentially the same form, except for some graphical downgrades, had they been 60 FPS. Those games don't seem CPU-limited to me. The others you mentioned have some potential for being CPU-limited, but I'm not so sure about all of them. But yes, there is always a cost to aiming for a higher framerate, I just don't think it would usually affect gameplay itself but only graphics instead. Whether you prefer better graphics or higher framerate is subjective, of course, so no objection from me if you just say you prefer better-looking games even if it means a lower framerate.

Also, GTA5 felt kind of painful on PS3, precisely because of its framerate. I haven't generally had issues with 30 FPS games in the past, but GTA5 felt very suboptimal. I'd say they definitely tried to push the hardware a bit too far with that one.

Uncharted and TLOU often have a good number of enemy characters in play with detailed (for the time) AI behaviours, animations, ragdolls, etc. in fairly sizeable environments which in Uncharted often break apart and shift in huge setpiece moments. No way you'd get those to a solid 60fps on PS3/4 without simplifying the scenarios.



Around the Network

I suspect GTA 6 is as well optimized as it can be, how many current gen games are running at 60 fps with raytracing on, let alone with the level of detail in other areas that GTA has? I can't think of any. I've been playing the Witcher 3 Remaster on my PC that has an RTX 4060, a GPU with RT performance a good bit above the RX 6700 XT tier GPU in Xbox Series X, and still turning on RTGI alone (not the other RT settings) requires me to turn on frame gen to not have visible stuttering, and GTA 6 has RT Global Illumination and RT reflections going with a nice smooth 30 FPS with far greater environment and character model detail than the Witcher 3 Remaster.

Rockstar clearly chose to focus on graphics over performance, which is why RT reflections and RTGI can't be turned off, without those I'm sure it could run at 60 fps. They didn't want to give people the option of choosing better performance over better graphics, they wanted everyone to experience the game in all of it's graphical glory.

We're definitely starting to get to the point where devs are getting as much juice out of current gen as they can, especially when it comes to RT. I definitely think Sony and Xbox will go ahead with their leaked plans to release PS6 and Xbox Helix in 2028, in spite of the RAM and SSD pricing crisis that will force them to either release at $1000 or above, or to subsidize the systems heavily in order to get them down to like $800-900. 

Last edited by shikamaru317 - 1 day ago

Anyone else planning a 1 billion budget + 14 year dev cycle for a PS5/XSX game? No? Well then I don't think there's much of a problem.

I watched my brother play through about the first 90 minutes of the game and to be honest, while it looks great, it's not like "OMG! I can't ever go back to other PS5/XBox/Swtich 2 games" either. Something like Alan Wake 2 still looks great to me and that's made on a tiny budget relatively.

The fact that the XBox Series S version has most of the same ray tracing effects and still manages to run at the same frame rate more or less as the PS5 Pro also would indicate to me that most devs would be just fine working on PS5/XSX for another 4-5 years. If this game can run reasonably well on the Series S, I think just about anything from anyone else who only has a fraction of the budget and time/staff to work on one single game will be more than fine. 

Last edited by Soundwave - 1 day ago

Soundwave said:

Anyone else planning a 1 billion budget + 14 year dev cycle for a PS5/XSX game? No? Well then I don't think there's much of a problem.

I watched my brother play through about the first 90 minutes of the game and to be honest, while it looks great, it's not like "OMG! I can't ever go back to other PS5/XBox/Swtich 2 games" either. Something like Alan Wake 2 still looks great to me and that's made on a tiny budget relatively.

The fact that the XBox Series S version has most of the same ray tracing effects and still manages to run at the same frame rate more or less as the PS5 Pro also would indicate to me that most devs would be just fine working on PS5/XSX for another 4-5 years. If this game can run reasonably well on the Series S, I think just about anything from anyone else who only has a fraction of the budget and time/staff to work on one single game will be more than fine. 

Hell Okami and Wind Waker still look fabulous.

GTA6 didn't take that long to develop. You're deleting GTA Online and Red Dead Redemption 2 from the equation.

And when engines improve (and inevitably utilise AI to reduce develoment times, as much as people hate to hear this), the heavy games will arrive sooner or later. Not every advanced graphics feature or technique necessitates higher budgets. RayTracing should actually reduce budgets beyond the initial engine related costs. But they can't fully embrace RT yet because a very high percentage of active gamers play on weak systems that require older techniques.

FSR4.1 arrived just in time to kind of save Series S's ass. But framerate is rough and can drop into the high 10's in the worst scenarios. Not exactly reassuring.



Kyuu said:
Soundwave said:

Anyone else planning a 1 billion budget + 14 year dev cycle for a PS5/XSX game? No? Well then I don't think there's much of a problem.

I watched my brother play through about the first 90 minutes of the game and to be honest, while it looks great, it's not like "OMG! I can't ever go back to other PS5/XBox/Swtich 2 games" either. Something like Alan Wake 2 still looks great to me and that's made on a tiny budget relatively.

The fact that the XBox Series S version has most of the same ray tracing effects and still manages to run at the same frame rate more or less as the PS5 Pro also would indicate to me that most devs would be just fine working on PS5/XSX for another 4-5 years. If this game can run reasonably well on the Series S, I think just about anything from anyone else who only has a fraction of the budget and time/staff to work on one single game will be more than fine. 

Hell Okami and Wind Waker still look fabulous.

GTA6 didn't take that long to develop. You're deleting GTA Online and Red Dead Redemption 2 from the equation.

And when engines improve (and inevitably utilise AI to reduce develoment times, as much as people hate to hear this), the heavy games will arrive sooner or later. Not every advanced graphics feature or technique necessitates higher budgets. RayTracing should actually reduce budgets beyond the initial engine related costs. But they can't fully embrace RT yet because a very high percentage of active gamers play on weak systems that require older techniques.

FSR4.1 arrived just in time to kind of save Series S's ass. But framerate is rough and can drop into the high 10's in the worst scenarios. Not exactly reassuring.

If GTA6 can run on a Series S ... you're going to be waiting a long, long time for PS6/XBox Next only games. A PS5/XSX can still accomplish the vision of just about any kind of play scenario, even those requiring a realistic art style, and for the developer who thinks they just need way more ... well good luck securing $500 million+ for your game or telling your bosses you want to only sell to a very limited user base, as PS6 sales are not likely to be gangbusters at $1000+. And then there probably will be a push to make PS6 games work on the portable PS6, which likely won't be anywhere near as powerful. 

The whole "I want a $200-$300 million budget (only a fraction of GTA6's cost still) and I need the graphics to be so advanced that they can only run on next-gen consoles, I don't want to support PS5 or PS6 Portable" is where reality is going to hit like a brick wall. The publisher who's putting up the hundreds of millions is going to come back and say "fuck your vision, we need an assured return on our capital, so there's going to be a PS5/XSX/PS6 Portable versions and you have to scale it to make that work, and it will still look very, very good anyway". 

Last edited by Soundwave - 1 day ago

Around the Network
Soundwave said:
Kyuu said:

Hell Okami and Wind Waker still look fabulous.

GTA6 didn't take that long to develop. You're deleting GTA Online and Red Dead Redemption 2 from the equation.

And when engines improve (and inevitably utilise AI to reduce develoment times, as much as people hate to hear this), the heavy games will arrive sooner or later. Not every advanced graphics feature or technique necessitates higher budgets. RayTracing should actually reduce budgets beyond the initial engine related costs. But they can't fully embrace RT yet because a very high percentage of active gamers play on weak systems that require older techniques.

FSR4.1 arrived just in time to kind of save Series S's ass. But framerate is rough and can drop into the high 10's in the worst scenarios. Not exactly reassuring.

If GTA6 can run on a Series S ... you're going to be waiting a long, long time for PS6/XBox Next only games. A PS5/XSX can still accomplish the vision of just about any kind of play scenario, even those requiring a realistic art style, and for the developer who thinks they just need way more ... well good luck securing $500 million+ for your game or telling your bosses you want to only sell to a very limited user base, as PS6 sales are not likely to be gangbusters at $1000+. And then there probably will be a push to make PS6 games work on the portable PS6, which likely won't be anywhere near as powerful. 

The whole "I want a $200-$300 million budget (only a fraction of GTA6's cost still) and I need the graphics to be so advanced that they can only run on next-gen consoles, I don't want to support PS5 or PS6 Portable" is where reality is going to hit like a brick wall. The publisher who's putting up the hundreds of millions is going to come back and say "fuck your vision, we need an assured return on our capital, so there's going to be a PS5/XSX/PS6 Portable versions and you have to scale it to make that work, and it will still look very, very good anyway". 

Yeah PS5/Series X level hardware will be supported for a long long time. But games will become heavier, gradually leading to more 40fps then 30fps caps before eventually skipping the platforms.

Series S will be supported on paper, but image quality and fps will drop to unacceptable levels sooner than the other two.



curl-6 said:

Hot take, but I've long felt the dogged insistence on 60fps has held PS5/Xbox Series X back somewhat.

30fps gives devs way more headroom not just for graphics but also simulation, physics, etc. Games like say GTA6, BOTW/TOTK, RDR2, GTA5, Uncharted 1-4, TLOU1/2, etc wouldn't have been possible on their target hardware if 60fps was a requirement.

Yeah, 30fps is more than fine for lot of titles. Sure, 60fps is better, but even in recent example of OoT that offers only 60fps and sacrifices image quality for it,  optional 30fps mode would give those extra 16.67ms per frame for pretty much DLAA solution in 1440p and better shadows.



Kyuu said:
Soundwave said:

If GTA6 can run on a Series S ... you're going to be waiting a long, long time for PS6/XBox Next only games. A PS5/XSX can still accomplish the vision of just about any kind of play scenario, even those requiring a realistic art style, and for the developer who thinks they just need way more ... well good luck securing $500 million+ for your game or telling your bosses you want to only sell to a very limited user base, as PS6 sales are not likely to be gangbusters at $1000+. And then there probably will be a push to make PS6 games work on the portable PS6, which likely won't be anywhere near as powerful. 

The whole "I want a $200-$300 million budget (only a fraction of GTA6's cost still) and I need the graphics to be so advanced that they can only run on next-gen consoles, I don't want to support PS5 or PS6 Portable" is where reality is going to hit like a brick wall. The publisher who's putting up the hundreds of millions is going to come back and say "fuck your vision, we need an assured return on our capital, so there's going to be a PS5/XSX/PS6 Portable versions and you have to scale it to make that work, and it will still look very, very good anyway". 

Yeah PS5/Series X level hardware will be supported for a long long time. But games will become heavier, gradually leading to more 40fps then 30fps caps before eventually skipping the platforms.

Series S will be supported on paper, but image quality and fps will drop to unacceptable levels sooner than the other two.

Putting aside that games being greenlit today of any large scale are probably 5-8 years away anyhow (so 2031-2033 or later), the other wrench in that is going to potentially be this PS6 Portable, which likely won't even match the PS5 in raw horsepower 1 for 1 or barely be above it and will have to run at an extremely low power draw. 

But likely publishers are going to say "hey we want a version on that platform too" most likely. Sony is likely going to push for it too because they are unlikely to have explosive PS6 sales given what the console side version will likely have to sell for (north of $1000 seems likely but even like $900 would be expensive to a lot of people). 



One thing I don't really understand and what's been adressed even by Digital Foundry years ago, is PS5's inferior VRR/LFC container.

From what DF said years ago, it ain't a hardware restriction but rather a choice by Sony (rumored to be tied to their Bravia TVs) and is up to developers themselves to build a better solution. Don't really understand why even R* didn't go for it. Especially since Series consoles profit from it. Or why Sony haven't improved it yet on a system level.

Specifically in regards to the question though, I sometimes find myself even wondering about if GTA VI's current performance could be even tied to some kind of detailed profit schedule laying in the drawers.

Since it's ... yeah, don't know, since it's become quite a pattern now that R*'s newest blockbuster again dips in performance. Only again causing the community to think about the next-gen Version hopefully arriving soon.

I mean GTA VI's development started over a decade ago. Although it's definitely one of R*'s strengths to push technology which they again certainly did, I just wonder how it happens that a game's release performance misses absolute stable performance only by inches/centimeters, although its development lasted for over a decade and one could ask why they couldn't just lock in on the raw hardware power without being over-demanding.

But that's just a hypothesis on my part ofc.



99% of people don't care if a game is 60fps.