Soundwave said:
I kinda figured Hogwarts is not the best port effort because they're offering a cheap upgrade price for Switch 1 owners of the Switch 1 version, which is kind of a tip off that it's a quick/cheap port and not necessarily the best version they could have made.
Cyberpunk 2077 looks like the best effort for launch titles, it looks better than the PS4 Pro version and not far off from the XBox Series S looking at recent video comparisons. It even holds up pretty well against the PS5 version w/ray-traced shadows turned on.
CD Projeckt Red showing a lot of devs how it's done it looks like.
|
Mm, I actually don't agree with this logic. The best version doesn't necessarily mean working from from the highest set of assets, it's means working most sensibly within the systems constraints to get the best result. I think a lot of you are going to come back to the reality that the Switch is closer to a PS4 than it is a Series S.
Hogwarts may run way better than cyberpunk in the end or function in ways which sees it as the more reliable port. Replacing items with unique lower poly assets or hiding geometry that will tank the frame rate can be the best form of optimisation. What is the performance cost of using those current gen assets vs the PS4's, does using the PS4's (which no one noticed until DF highlighted it) mean the game can run at a cleaner resolution or have more people on screen? Let's wait before jumping the gun.
Before you were speaking very favourably about Hogwarts S2 compared to the PS5 version, a lot of details DF pointed out are not obvious at a casual glance. Similarly a more technical analysis of Cyberpunk may reveal a wider gulf than what you're currently drawing. Ultimately though, both games are very different under the hood, completely different engines, so I wouldn't make direct comparisons on porting effort.
As far as the upgrade path, the $10 grade path is the standard. We simply haven't seen it be used across a Switch 1 > PS4 level of conversion because there are literally no examples yet other than Hogwarts Legacy. Probably we'll get Witcher 3 and No Mans Sky and I'm sure they will offer a similar path. Sony offered the huge Horizon Remaster path for £10 and almost every asset in that was remade to bring it closer to Forbidden Wests PS5 graphical level. Essentially I wouldn't draw too much from the $10 path other than the company still profits and still expects a lot of new full price purchases from the upgrade ;)
Last edited by Otter - on 24 May 2025