PAOerfulone said:
If anything I stated below is incorrect, feel free to correct: Assuming Trump is able to win the first 5 states while hanging on to the ones he has now, that would bring his electoral count to 259, while Biden's would be at 249 if he hung on to all the other states he leads in, not counting Pennsylvania or Wisconsin. And even if it gets to that scenario, Trump would need to focus all his efforts on Pennsylvania to secure that state's 20 votes, bringing his total to 279 and winning reelection. If he were to get Wisconsin, and Biden gets Pennsylvania, then we'd have an unprecedented 269-269 tie. If that were to happen, then the tiebreaker would be decided by the House of Representatives, the majority of which is currently Democrat. Which would all but guarantee Biden winning the tiebreaker and the presidency. All the while, the Vice Presidency would be decided by the Senate, which is mostly Republican at the moment. If it were to stay that way, then Pence would likely remain VP, leading to a verrrrrry weird term of Biden-Pence. |
Mostly right but wrong on one very important point.
If Trump wins those five states plus Wisconsin, and Biden holds his lead in Pennsylvania, then that would be 268-268. But, the more likely scenario would be Biden keeping Wisconsin and losing Pennsylvania, where his lead is slightly smaller (why I don't know). Where Trump would win. But, it's close enough that either scenario would happen.
But, we still have the two teensy districts, ME-2nd and NE-2nd. Those are both interesting districts, because Nebraska is a very red state, but the 2nd district leans more democratic. Trump won it by 2 points in 2016 compared to 25 statewide. ME-2 is the opposite, a red leaning district in a generally blue state. Trump won ME-2 by a small margin despite losing the state, I don't know exactly how much.
So, in that red Penn blue Wis scenario, either candidate can score a clean victory by taking those two toss up districts. Biden is currently leading in both, but since they're so small there's not a ton of polling. Nebraska 2 is expected to go to Biden, so there's even less than in Maine-2 which is expected to be competitive. Biden's up by 2.5 and 1% in those districts respectively.
If they split it though... Trump wins. That's where you're wrong.
While the House does wind up picking the election, they don't vote individually, they vote by state delegation. Which is the electoral college on steroids. Alaska's congressmen have equal power to California's, which is obviously fucked (although hey, that's how the senate works). Either candidate would need to win 26 delegations. Currently republicans control 26 delegations, which could change in the election but probably won't.
So... assuming they all vote on party lines, then Trump wins. Even if they vote according to the popular vote of their states, then Trump wins. There's all sorts of other legal shenanigans that can play out, but for simplicity's sake, a tie is a Trump victory.
It's an unlikely scenario, but it could happen. Also, keep in mind that if a decisive state is within .5% that triggers a recount. So it's possible that we'd have a lot of legal challenges going on. It'd be a pretty bad scenario. Whichever way it went, each side would accuse the other or stealing the election (which may happen anyway, but in that case there may be a valid point on each side).