Probably because a lot of the GOTG comments were not made by MS fans but Sony and Ninty fans who were making fun of MS fans for being hyped about Titanfall. And they had every reason to be since all the previews by reviewers were extremely positive. Ok, the game didn't turn out to be the best shooter ever, but got good scores that justify most of the hype.

Also, every fanbase has a few hardcore fans that hype everything as GOTG (which is obvious just by looking at the thread titles- I shall not name names) and make the rest of the fanbase look bad. Their opinion is not representative of the entire fanabase.

Titanfall
Gears series

Easily Ocarina of Time. The game feels so damn dated nowadays and yet some people still consider " teh best gaem evar!!"... I don't get it!

Boom Blox. Why? Because it was hyped at all.

Yes! The first time that I've trolled Boom Blox since returning.

The most recent would be Titanfall, it was hyped to be this insane, incredibly fun shooter and turned out to be lacking in so many aspects, but my main one would be Grand Theft Auto IV. What Rockstar achieved on last-generation hardware was nothing short of incredible, but the game itself was mediocre. Sure, fun could be had, but you had to find it yourself. The map was too large and not designed overly well, the characters were weak, and the game-play was severely lacking and sloppy. The Grand Theft Auto name alone earned this game its review scores.

Lots of stuff.
GTA IV/V, Uncharted 3, TLOU somewhat, etc.

Titanfall.

Are you trolling Boom Blox, or Spielberg?

Boom Blox.  I'd rather take a bath in lemon juice with a million paper cuts than play that piece of garbage again.

The Duke Nukem reboot.