| SanAndreasX said: Meanwhile, in Oklahoma, 27% of the voter base is Democratic. They have not only have absolute zero representation in Congress, but Oklahoma's congressional delegation is openly and vocally contemptuous of Oklahoma Democrats. They can pretty much afford to say that over one-fourth of their constituents are Godless trash. I know Oklahoma is smaller than California, but it still has five representatives, and 27% is more than enough for one or two Democratic representatives. They are also badly underrepresented in the state legislature. 8 members of the 48-member state senate, which is 12.5%. 20 members of the 101-member state house of representatives, which is 19.8%. |
Single-member districts combined with first-past-the-post voting rules is the worst kind of electoral system you can have for a legislature. There's always going to be issues with fair representation when geography figures heavily into the process, even when there's no gerrymandering (Massachusetts hasn't had a Republican in their House delegation in decades simply because Republicans are spread too thinly across the state). It's just that gerrymandering is deliberately making a bad problem worse. The only way to solve this problem is through proportional representation. For example, the organization Fair Vote advocates for the single-transferable vote system where there are multi-member districts where representatives are selected via ranked-choice voting, and you can see suggested maps here. Under a PR system, a state's House delegation would more closely resemble that of the state's actual partisan split, and such systems are functionally impossible to gerrymander.
And that's ignoring the fact that upper houses in state legislatures are entirely redundant. The U.S. Senate at least had the excuse of nominally representing the state governments, as the U.S. was functionally 13 separate nation-states under the Articles of Confederation, each of which got one vote on all matters regardless of population size in the Continental Congress. There was no way something similar wasn't going to be added to the new Constitution that became our supreme law. But with states, the upper houses aren't there to represent county or municipal governments. They're just chambers with larger districts that can be altered just like those in the lower house. They probably only exist because our federal government under the Constitution normalized the idea of bicameral legislatures in America. I've always felt state legislatures should be unicameral and likewise have their members chosen via a system of proportional representation.
Visit http://shadowofthevoid.wordpress.com
Art by Hunter B
In accordance to the VGC forum rules, §8.5, I hereby exercise my right to demand to be left alone regarding the subject of the effects of the pandemic on video game sales (i.e., "COVID bump").








