Well, I correctly predicted that Astro Bot would be higher rated. Well made 3D platformers are always acclaimed.

Yeah, Astro won the reception and Zelda should definitely win the sales now.

I'll cop to being wrong in the poll.
I was expecting Zelda to take both sales and reception since I figured the metascores for both games would be high eighties. I thought 89 Zelda and 88 Astrobot was about what we'd see. I was a bit off on Zelda, but really underestimated Astrobot.
Still think Zelda has a good chance to take sales being the more popular IP on the bigger install base, but considering the reception I wouldn't be surprised by a win from Astrobot.

Astro bot for reviews and Zelda for sales.

Edit: Oh damn....its already over? lol

I mean, reviews for both games are out, yeah it's over, lol.

I voted Astro Bot for reception and Zelda for sales, but honestly I think Astro Bot will take both now if we're talking lifetime. Zelda will probably be ahead in sales at the end of this year but Astro Bot should have really strong legs due to being pretty much the best recieved PS5 exclusive yet which will only be cemented further after the award season.

Only the UK market but if Zelda only slightly outsells Links Awakening globally (5-6m), I think Astro will win the sales game. Not by years end but end of 2025 for sure. Astro is still top 3 in most markets only being beating out by multiplatform titles & now Zelda.

Just in Japan alone, Zelda EoW will outsell Asstrobot sales Lifetime over there in just 1 week. That's why Sony's mum on it's sales cuz there's nothin to brag about. Facts.

Seeing a lot of disappointment online for EoW. Like I said before Astro bot is taking home all the gold.

It’ll be an Astro sweep, but where on earth are you finding ppl who are disappointed by EoW? The worst I’ve heard is performance issues.