By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - The Discussion Thread - The 14th Annual Greatest Games Event

S.Peelman said:
Machina said:

#30 - The Walking Dead?

Incorrect. Mnementh after you correctly guessed the game to a Star Trek game (but he didn't guess the right one).

Mnementh said:

#30: OK, this *has* to be a Star Trek game. Problem is, there is a lot of them. Like really, really many. So let's skew recent-ish (meaning last 20 years instead of up to the 70s) and maybe console. I hear people like Bridge Crew, so let's go with this one.

#27: Uh, I don't really know which one is not by Maxis, Sim Town maybe?

30 is indeed a Star Trek game. I realise there's multiple that could fit with the hints, but at least, it's not Bridge Crew.

27 is quite close, and again you have the right series. I played SimTown as a kid, was fun enough, but I'm looking for another 'Sim' game much more important to me.

drbunnig said:

28: Prince of Persia?

Correct!

Elite Force/Elite Force 2?



Around the Network
Farsala said:

Hints for 40-33 JRPGs

40- Tactical JRPG set in China. 1st game in the series.

39- 15th game in the series for a certain JRPG series. Features boy band as main characters.

38- A PSP game gone HD, this game features a main story with an entire classroom of characters named in some way after a deck of cards.

37- 2nd game in a tactical JRPG series. The main character uses fists unlike most main characters in the series.

36- An amazing game released in 2023, features insanely cinematic boss fights and darker story compared to usual.

35- This game mixes a famous JRPG series and Dynasty Warriors, killing hordes of JRPG monsters never felt so good.

34- Same as 35, but 2nd game in the series. Basically more of the same but slightly better.

33- This 2022 game tries to mix the challenge of Soulslike with the familiarity of FF.

38: Final Fantasy Type-0 HD

33: Stranger of Paradise?



Machina said:
S.Peelman said:

Incorrect. Mnementh after you correctly guessed the game to a Star Trek game (but he didn't guess the right one).

Mnementh said:

#30: OK, this *has* to be a Star Trek game. Problem is, there is a lot of them. Like really, really many. So let's skew recent-ish (meaning last 20 years instead of up to the 70s) and maybe console. I hear people like Bridge Crew, so let's go with this one.

#27: Uh, I don't really know which one is not by Maxis, Sim Town maybe?

30 is indeed a Star Trek game. I realise there's multiple that could fit with the hints, but at least, it's not Bridge Crew.

27 is quite close, and again you have the right series. I played SimTown as a kid, was fun enough, but I'm looking for another 'Sim' game much more important to me.

Correct!

Elite Force/Elite Force 2?

Yes! Elite Force is right.



S.Peelman said:
Machina said:

#30 - The Walking Dead?

Incorrect. Mnementh after you correctly guessed the game to a Star Trek game (but he didn't guess the right one).

Mnementh said:

#30: OK, this *has* to be a Star Trek game. Problem is, there is a lot of them. Like really, really many. So let's skew recent-ish (meaning last 20 years instead of up to the 70s) and maybe console. I hear people like Bridge Crew, so let's go with this one.

#27: Uh, I don't really know which one is not by Maxis, Sim Town maybe?

30 is indeed a Star Trek game. I realise there's multiple that could fit with the hints, but at least, it's not Bridge Crew.

27 is quite close, and again you have the right series. I played SimTown as a kid, was fun enough, but I'm looking for another 'Sim' game much more important to me.

drbunnig said:

28: Prince of Persia?

Correct!

#27: Maybe SimIsle then?



3DS-FC: 4511-1768-7903 (Mii-Name: Mnementh), Nintendo-Network-ID: Mnementh, Switch: SW-7706-3819-9381 (Mnementh)

my greatest games: 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024

10 years greatest game event!

bets: [peak year] [+], [1], [2], [3], [4]

#30

Change YoY: =   My Rating: 9.2 / 10

The original Valkyria Chronicles is one of my absolute favourite games of all time, and to my great delight it proved to be an unexpected success back in 2008. I was anticipating another home console sequel to be announced relatively quickly, but then it turned out the next game in the series would be released on the PSP instead. That wasn't a huge issue in the end, and I liked the game, but it was definitely held back by its platform, and failed to sell nearly as much as the first game, especially in the west. Following this, the third game was never even released outside of Japan as the PSP really wasn't doing very well in the west at that point. As a result, for quite a few years it felt like the series was effectively dead. Then finally, Valkyria Chronicles 4 was announced for home consoles and eventually released in 2018, making this without question one of the longest waits for a game I've ever experienced. Fortunately, it more than lived up to my expectations.

Valkyria Chronicles 4 is not quite on the level of the first game, mostly because I liked the story and characters in the first game just a little bit more, even if the ones we got here are great too. On the gameplay side there are some great improvements and additions made to what we had in the earlier games, including a new character class and some more variety and improvements to the existing ones. Visually, this is a beautiful game, the anime-inspired, watercolor-esque style creating some truly impressive moments. The score is fantastic as well, composed by highly talented Hitoshi Sakimoto. This is without question a worthy follow-up to the first game, and hopefully we don't have to wait another ten years for the next title in the series.



Around the Network
Darashiva said:

#30

Change YoY: =   My Rating: 9.2 / 10

The original Valkyria Chronicles is one of my absolute favourite games of all time, and to my great delight it proved to be an unexpected success back in 2008. I was anticipating another home console sequel to be announced relatively quickly, but then it turned out the next game in the series would be released on the PSP instead. That wasn't a huge issue in the end, and I liked the game, but it was definitely held back by its platform, and failed to sell nearly as much as the first game, especially in the west. Following this, the third game was never even released outside of Japan as the PSP really wasn't doing very well in the west at that point. As a result, for quite a few years it felt like the series was effectively dead. Then finally, Valkyria Chronicles 4 was announced for home consoles and eventually released in 2018, making this without question one of the longest waits for a game I've ever experienced. Fortunately, it more than lived up to my expectations.

Valkyria Chronicles 4 is not quite on the level of the first game, mostly because I liked the story and characters in the first game just a little bit more, even if the ones we got here are great too. On the gameplay side there are some great improvements and additions made to what we had in the earlier games, including a new character class and some more variety and improvements to the existing ones. Visually, this is a beautiful game, the anime-inspired, watercolor-esque style creating some truly impressive moments. The score is fantastic as well, composed by highly talented Hitoshi Sakimoto. This is without question a worthy follow-up to the first game, and hopefully we don't have to wait another ten years for the next title in the series.

Really nice game, I like as well. It was on my list in the past, but it had to make space for others. Doesn't mean I dislike it now. It has beautiful style, which is more surprising as it has a war setting. The setting is also interesting, as it is similar to earth history, but not the same. So it can feature elements of the world wars, without being exactly them. And good turn based tactics as gameplay.



3DS-FC: 4511-1768-7903 (Mii-Name: Mnementh), Nintendo-Network-ID: Mnementh, Switch: SW-7706-3819-9381 (Mnementh)

my greatest games: 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024

10 years greatest game event!

bets: [peak year] [+], [1], [2], [3], [4]

Mnementh said:
S.Peelman said:

Incorrect. Mnementh after you correctly guessed the game to a Star Trek game (but he didn't guess the right one).

30 is indeed a Star Trek game. I realise there's multiple that could fit with the hints, but at least, it's not Bridge Crew.

27 is quite close, and again you have the right series. I played SimTown as a kid, was fun enough, but I'm looking for another 'Sim' game much more important to me.

Correct!

#27: Maybe SimIsle then?

I didn't realise SimIsle was also made by another developer, but that's not the one I mean, so you picked the wrong one

To clarify, I'm of course also not looking for "Sim Theme Park", as that was actually Theme Park World, or SimHealth as that was barely a game. Also not any of the 'Sim' games that were made by other companies after EA bought Maxis, like Sim City Societies (also, I'm having a gag reflex just mentioning those names...).



Mnementh said:
Farsala said:

Got busy with life and stuff so I am playing catch up..

43 is The Diofield Chronicle.

41 is Kessen 2

Hints for 40-33 JRPGs

40- Tactical JRPG set in China. 1st game in the series.

39- 15th game in the series for a certain JRPG series. Features boy band as main characters.

38- A PSP game gone HD, this game features a main story with an entire classroom of characters named in some way after a deck of cards.

37- 2nd game in a tactical JRPG series. The main character uses fists unlike most main characters in the series.

36- An amazing game released in 2023, features insanely cinematic boss fights and darker story compared to usual.

35- This game mixes a famous JRPG series and Dynasty Warriors, killing hordes of JRPG monsters never felt so good.

34- Same as 35, but 2nd game in the series. Basically more of the same but slightly better.

33- This 2022 game tries to mix the challenge of Soulslike with the familiarity of FF.

#39: FFXV

#36: Probably FFXVI

#35: Hyrule Warriors, even though I don't see Zelda as JRPG, see 34 for explanation.

#34: I thought of Persona Strikers as #35. But I don't think Strikers has a sequel yet. So maybe you count Zelda as JRPG? Which would make it Age of Calamity

39: Correct

36: Correct

35: Incorrect

34: Incorrect

UnderwaterFunktown said:
Farsala said:

Got busy with life and stuff so I am playing catch up..

43 is The Diofield Chronicle.

41 is Kessen 2

Hints for 40-33 JRPGs

40- Tactical JRPG set in China. 1st game in the series.

39- 15th game in the series for a certain JRPG series. Features boy band as main characters.

38- A PSP game gone HD, this game features a main story with an entire classroom of characters named in some way after a deck of cards.

37- 2nd game in a tactical JRPG series. The main character uses fists unlike most main characters in the series.

36- An amazing game released in 2023, features insanely cinematic boss fights and darker story compared to usual.

35- This game mixes a famous JRPG series and Dynasty Warriors, killing hordes of JRPG monsters never felt so good.

34- Same as 35, but 2nd game in the series. Basically more of the same but slightly better.

33- This 2022 game tries to mix the challenge of Soulslike with the familiarity of FF.

If Mnementh is wrong about the Zelda thing then 35 and 34 could be Fire Emblem Warriors and Three Hopes

Both incorrect, you guys are forgetting about another mash up.

Darashiva said:
Farsala said:

Hints for 40-33 JRPGs

40- Tactical JRPG set in China. 1st game in the series.

39- 15th game in the series for a certain JRPG series. Features boy band as main characters.

38- A PSP game gone HD, this game features a main story with an entire classroom of characters named in some way after a deck of cards.

37- 2nd game in a tactical JRPG series. The main character uses fists unlike most main characters in the series.

36- An amazing game released in 2023, features insanely cinematic boss fights and darker story compared to usual.

35- This game mixes a famous JRPG series and Dynasty Warriors, killing hordes of JRPG monsters never felt so good.

34- Same as 35, but 2nd game in the series. Basically more of the same but slightly better.

33- This 2022 game tries to mix the challenge of Soulslike with the familiarity of FF.

38: Final Fantasy Type-0 HD

33: Stranger of Paradise?

38: Correct

33: Correct



40- Tactical JRPG set in China. 1st game in the series. The name is basically the old name + Tactics instead of the beat em up name.

37- 2nd game in a tactical JRPG series. The main character uses fists unlike most main characters in the series. The 7th game in this series recently released.

35- This game mixes a famous JRPG series and Dynasty Warriors, killing hordes of JRPG monsters never felt so good. Iconic monsters can be killed and the characters from all over the series can be played.

34- Same as 35, but 2nd game in the series. Basically more of the same but slightly better. In this one you can summon those monsters to defend a point or to help the offensive.



Farsala said:

40- Tactical JRPG set in China. 1st game in the series. The name is basically the old name + Tactics instead of the beat em up name.

37- 2nd game in a tactical JRPG series. The main character uses fists unlike most main characters in the series. The 7th game in this series recently released.

35- This game mixes a famous JRPG series and Dynasty Warriors, killing hordes of JRPG monsters never felt so good. Iconic monsters can be killed and the characters from all over the series can be played.

34- Same as 35, but 2nd game in the series. Basically more of the same but slightly better. In this one you can summon those monsters to defend a point or to help the offensive.

35/34) Ahh there's also Dragon Quest Warriors games right? Gonna guess those then

37) Probably Disgaea 2



Try out my free game on Steam

2024 OpenCritic Prediction Leagues:

Nintendo | PlayStation | Multiplat