By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General - Scifi fans, can you give an opinion about this prologue? is it too long/ grammar sucks / lame/ is it fun to read / confusing ...etc

I'm still reading through, but based on what I've read I would suggest shortening your sentences. The first paragraph for instance would flow a lot better if you separated it into three separate sentences rather than one long sentence separated by multiple comma's.

The story has me intrigued though.



Around the Network
NiKKoM said:

lol.. Wine.. who drinks wine from a fridge..

Crazy people of course! plothole thickens

 

but yeah your sentences can be written slightly different to make them better.

Another giant of a man, fully bearded, short of hair with a bit of gray around his facial hair slowly and calmly entered the room, the towering man was dragging david’s lifeless body from his shirt, he was in a black shirt and a jacket, black trousers carrying a sniper rifle around his back.

So you're describing him, then describing his actions, then describing him again..

gotta describe his fashion sense , its the most important thing in the world right now.

 

Iggy heard over a dozen gunshots accompanied by screams all around him, it was too fast for him to react he doesn’t know where the attacks are coming it was too dark for him to see, he could only see the tied man smiling, muttering “Carrion” as he leaned his head toward the right he saw Ron twitching lying on the floor bleeding with a knife wound to his throat he was already dead. then everything stopped, there was a cold, dead silence, no gunshots, no screams.

Here it's too dark to see yet he sees Ron and the tied up man? make it "he doesn’t know where the attacks are coming from and only could see..."

 

Thats something i didn't notice, I originally had him only see the guy who was tied up, good catch.

I guess I'll just have to rewrite everything.



Scoobes said:
I'm still reading through, but based on what I've read I would suggest shortening your sentences. The first paragraph for instance would flow a lot better if you separated it into three separate sentences rather than one long sentence separated by multiple comma's.

The story has me intrigued though.


You know whats funny? I actually made sentences long because someone told me they were too short and I should be more detailed, I guess I don't have a middle ground.

 

Thanks though. =]



I read half. Lack of proper punctuation (it's basically one long run on sentence then another) makes it hard to read. It's decently eloquent, and does have the feel of sci-fi pulp. You do paint an interesting picture and I think I could get into it were it not for the awful grammar and punctuation.

Just work on your style and you should get better. I read stuff which had perfect writing and was awfully boring and you're not boring. :)



um what is this

http://storywrite.com/story/11524378-The-Passenger--ELYZIUM--Sleepless-Souls-Prologue--by-PullusPardus



Around the Network
Turkish said:
um what is this

http://storywrite.com/story/11524378-The-Passenger--ELYZIUM--Sleepless-Souls-Prologue--by-PullusPardus


Ow wow.. are you stalking him? xD



 

Face the future.. Gamecenter ID: nikkom_nl (oh no he didn't!!) 

PullusPardus said:

I'm not a native English speaker as well, but yeah I can see the grammar errors, thanks 

I think its because I kept rewriting it that I accumulated  a lot of errors

Also that story sounds a lot like Ringworld.

Yup it has some simelarities. In Ringworld they crash land on a full ring build around a star with the engineers seemingly long gone. Bowl of heaven is more like a giant rotating teacup next to a travelling star, with the population under tight management through genetic engineering. It's part techy sci-fi, doing a good job at describing how such a structure could work, and has interesting insights in how the human mind works as the aliens try to figure out how human intelligence works compared to their own. It starts with one of the nastiest descriptions of waking up out of cry sleep, I think I'll pass lol.

Anyway keep it up with your story. Looks interesting. Better to do a full rewrite of a paragraph instead of tinkering with bits of a sentence. Also easier to do when you keep sentences a bit shorter. Also one thing to keep track of is who the main subject is in the chapter. Referring to him by his name works better for me than using references like the driver. He's the one who's thoughts are described, so he should know his name too :)



Biggie for the grammar is that your tense has to remain constant. You switch between narrative past and present.



Monster Hunter: pissing me off since 2010.

Turkish said:
um what is this

http://storywrite.com/story/11524378-The-Passenger--ELYZIUM--Sleepless-Souls-Prologue--by-PullusPardus


Its me. obviously, same name.



That's long... But I'll read it now and tell you what I think. I had a look at that thread (looking for your entries) and I saw some comments about Revelation Space - you mentioned that you want to read it. I absolutely recommend it wholeheartedly - the sci part of the sci fi is very satisfying indeed.