Mnementh said: Just_Ben said: You got itwrong: If it has no USK rating it is not allowed to advertise or being on the shelf and can only be sold to 18+. If it is on the "Index" than it is not allowed to be sold AT ALL. But there are very few games actually on the index. If a court say it can be confiscated that it is not allowed to won the game, but that is a "soft law". |
No, Rol is right and you are wrong. No USk-rating mean nothing more that it is allowed to be buyed for adults. BPjM-index means no advertising, no shelf-space. No USK-rating means that the BPjM is allowed to index the game, if the USK rates it, the BPjM can do nothing. Many publishers decide themselve not to release a game that gets on the index or is threatened by it. Gears of Wars wasnt released in germany by Microsoft for this reason. And Doom2 was actually forbidden, but in that case because of the use of nazi-symbols in the wolfenstein-level. |
So whats the difference of 18+ and no rating from the USK then?
From the Wikipedia:
"Von verschiedenen Seiten wird kritisiert, dass Medien, die nach §15, Abs. 2, Nr. 1–5 JuSchG als „schwer jugendgefährdend“ eingestuft wurden, von der USK keine Kennzeichnung erhalten. Diese Medien müssen laut §15, Abs. 2 wie Werke behandelt werden, die in die Liste der jugendgefährdenden Medien aufgenommen wurden. Kritiker führen nun an, dass diese Werke dennoch, mit den in §15, Abs. 1, Nr. 1–7 beschrieben Auflagen in Deutschland vertrieben werden könnten, beispielsweise als Grauimporte. Auch ein Kauf „hinter der Grenze oder im Internet“ sei denkbar."
So if the USK gives no rating, it has to be handled like porn. If it is on the Index, you are allowed to own one, import one for yourself, but is can't be imported by firms for you (BIG DIFFERENCE). If it is confiscated, you aren't even allowed to own it, but thats a so called "soft law".
So at the moment i can go to a import firm and let it import it for me. (I have to drive far distances to austria). If it is on the "Index" I must drive for my own.