By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - How To Make a Digital Only Gaming Market Work For Consumers?

SanAndreasX said:
CaptainExplosion said:

Well there need to be laws in place to prevent that bullshit.

And I thought Game Key Cards were only able to be used once.

No. The license is tied to the GKC, not the console or the account holder. So it's fully transferable, just like an on-cartridge game is.

Once you finish Resident Evil Requiem on Switch 2, you can hand it off to your friend, or sell it. The recipient/buyer can plug the GKC into their Switch 2, download the game, and play it. Once you no longer have the GKC, you won't be able to play it. 

In that respect, GKCs are at least superior to code-in-a-box, which is tied to the account it is entered into and is not transferable. 

Of course the issue with GKCs is that you still depend on the online service and having a system that supports physical media. Those might or might not become issues in the future. Pick your poison, as usual.



Around the Network
Zkuq said:
SanAndreasX said:

No. The license is tied to the GKC, not the console or the account holder. So it's fully transferable, just like an on-cartridge game is.

Once you finish Resident Evil Requiem on Switch 2, you can hand it off to your friend, or sell it. The recipient/buyer can plug the GKC into their Switch 2, download the game, and play it. Once you no longer have the GKC, you won't be able to play it. 

In that respect, GKCs are at least superior to code-in-a-box, which is tied to the account it is entered into and is not transferable. 

Of course the issue with GKCs is that you still depend on the online service and having a system that supports physical media. Those might or might not become issues in the future. Pick your poison, as usual.

I already mentioned that. That is a possibility. Yes, you are still putting your game library in the hands of a billionaire - whether it’s Furukawa. Nishino, Nadella, or Newell. 

That said, 20 years later, even if I can’t buy new games, I can still go and re-download every game I bought on the Wii and DSi eShops, and Nintendo has given absolutely no indication thus far that they are ending this. Same with Xbox and PS3. So I’m pretty confident that the GKCs I bought will still work at least that long, by which time I will be close to 70 years old. 

GKCs are likely the closest we’re going to get to resale and transfer of digital games. 



SanAndreasX said:
Zkuq said:

Of course the issue with GKCs is that you still depend on the online service and having a system that supports physical media. Those might or might not become issues in the future. Pick your poison, as usual.

I already mentioned that. That is a possibility. Yes, you are still putting your game library in the hands of a billionaire - whether it’s Furukawa. Nishino, Nadella, or Newell. 

That said, 20 years later, even if I can’t buy new games, I can still go and re-download every game I bought on the Wii and DSi eShops, and Nintendo has given absolutely no indication thus far that they are ending this. Same with Xbox and PS3. So I’m pretty confident that the GKCs I bought will still work at least that long, by which time I will be close to 70 years old. 

GKCs are likely the closest we’re going to get to resale and transfer of digital games. 

Ah, I didn't read every post carefully, so I must have missed that.

Personally I'm not confident in the future of old systems, even if they've been well supported historically. If enough issues arise, e.g. related to security (and that's an increasing concern due to AI), they might just decide to drop support for those old systems altogether. I'm not saying it's going to happen, I'm just saying that personally I'm not very confident due to the low value old systems bring to the console companies. Having adequate backwards compatibility would, of course, largely make that point moot, but sadly so far only Xbox has a long history with that.



SanAndreasX said:
CaptainExplosion said:

Well there need to be laws in place to prevent that bullshit.

And I thought Game Key Cards were only able to be used once.

No. The license is tied to the GKC, not the console or the account holder. So it's fully transferable, just like an on-cartridge game is.

Once you finish Resident Evil Requiem on Switch 2, you can hand it off to your friend, or sell it. The recipient/buyer can plug the GKC into their Switch 2, download the game, and play it. Once you no longer have the GKC, you won't be able to play it. 

In that respect, GKCs are at least superior to code-in-a-box, which is tied to the account it is entered into and is not transferable. 

I guess GKCs aren't that bad.

Zkuq said:
SanAndreasX said:

I already mentioned that. That is a possibility. Yes, you are still putting your game library in the hands of a billionaire - whether it’s Furukawa. Nishino, Nadella, or Newell. 

That said, 20 years later, even if I can’t buy new games, I can still go and re-download every game I bought on the Wii and DSi eShops, and Nintendo has given absolutely no indication thus far that they are ending this. Same with Xbox and PS3. So I’m pretty confident that the GKCs I bought will still work at least that long, by which time I will be close to 70 years old. 

GKCs are likely the closest we’re going to get to resale and transfer of digital games. 

Ah, I didn't read every post carefully, so I must have missed that.

Personally I'm not confident in the future of old systems, even if they've been well supported historically. If enough issues arise, e.g. related to security (and that's an increasing concern due to AI), they might just decide to drop support for those old systems altogether. I'm not saying it's going to happen, I'm just saying that personally I'm not very confident due to the low value old systems bring to the console companies. Having adequate backwards compatibility would, of course, largely make that point moot, but sadly so far only Xbox has a long history with that.

Is there anything AI is NOT ruining these days? -_-



CaptainExplosion said:
SanAndreasX said:

No. The license is tied to the GKC, not the console or the account holder. So it's fully transferable, just like an on-cartridge game is.

Once you finish Resident Evil Requiem on Switch 2, you can hand it off to your friend, or sell it. The recipient/buyer can plug the GKC into their Switch 2, download the game, and play it. Once you no longer have the GKC, you won't be able to play it. 

In that respect, GKCs are at least superior to code-in-a-box, which is tied to the account it is entered into and is not transferable. 

I guess GKCs aren't that bad.

They are not an optimal solution. I like on-cartridge games because even with a 1TB SD Express card, storage space is difficult to manage. But they are not the great red devil they’re being made out to be, either. They are better than a code in a box, at least, because of the transferability.



Around the Network
SanAndreasX said:
CaptainExplosion said:

So GOG is doing it right yet they're not profitable?

Sadly... yes. GOG is now owned by one of the founders of CDPR, Michal Kicinski, who is no longer affiliated with them. He had a hand in the original creation of GOG, so he still believes in the original vision behind his creation, but GOG is very much a labor of love for him. 

When it comes to the PC market, people overwhelmingly choose convenience over ownership. 

The thing of convenience on Steam is real, but other thing that is real is that, while yes, you're still purchasing license on Steam, the other...let's say, convenience, of PC gaming is pretty much a guarantee that you own your game, no matter what happens on/with Steam - that is not something you can have on any other platform, due to closed garden approach (bar Android maybe), and probably one of the reason PC gamers are at ease with whole ownership/licensing thing.



HoloDust said:
SanAndreasX said:

Sadly... yes. GOG is now owned by one of the founders of CDPR, Michal Kicinski, who is no longer affiliated with them. He had a hand in the original creation of GOG, so he still believes in the original vision behind his creation, but GOG is very much a labor of love for him. 

When it comes to the PC market, people overwhelmingly choose convenience over ownership. 

The thing of convenience on Steam is real, but other thing that is real is that, while yes, you're still purchasing license on Steam, the other...let's say, convenience, of PC gaming is pretty much a guarantee that you own your game, no matter what happens on/with Steam - that is not something you can have on any other platform, due to closed garden approach (bar Android maybe), and probably one of the reason PC gamers are at ease with whole ownership/licensing thing.

Why can't the same be done with digital purchases on consoles?



CaptainExplosion said:
SanAndreasX said:

And that will never happen without legislation. There's a reason why very few new releases, and a lot of older releases, are not on GOG.

Congressman Richie Torres (D-NY) did introduce legislation in October 2026 that, if passed, would require the FTC to recognize ownership of digital purchases, but it's not going to get through the current Congress, and would no doubt die on Trump's desk. 

CDProjekt also divested GOG because, in a good year, GOG barely breaks even.

So GOG is doing it right yet they're not profitable?

Welcome to capitalism.



3DS-FC: 4511-1768-7903 (Mii-Name: Mnementh), Nintendo-Network-ID: Mnementh, Switch: SW-7706-3819-9381 (Mnementh)

my greatest games: 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024, 2025 

10 years greatest game event!

bets: [GTA6]

CaptainExplosion said:
HoloDust said:

The thing of convenience on Steam is real, but other thing that is real is that, while yes, you're still purchasing license on Steam, the other...let's say, convenience, of PC gaming is pretty much a guarantee that you own your game, no matter what happens on/with Steam - that is not something you can have on any other platform, due to closed garden approach (bar Android maybe), and probably one of the reason PC gamers are at ease with whole ownership/licensing thing.

Why can't the same be done with digital purchases on consoles?

Because Windows/Linux/whatever you're running on PC (or Android on phone) are not closed like consoles are - and it's why, no matter what happens to Steam or games on it (or any other store for that matter), you'll be able to either find said games elsewhere, one way or the other. Consoles are closed gardens, you can't have that sort of guarantee on them.



Honestly digital copies are superior in every regard - except DRM. Which actually brings all the bad things. Remove DRM and there is nothing (well collecting is better physical) that digital falls back. That is why I keep buying games important to me on GOG, even though other platforms are more convenient. Because I know, if I buy it on GOG I can keep the copy no matter what. Also GOG has now a great preservation program for selected titles, putting work behind keeping these games runnable on modern systems.



3DS-FC: 4511-1768-7903 (Mii-Name: Mnementh), Nintendo-Network-ID: Mnementh, Switch: SW-7706-3819-9381 (Mnementh)

my greatest games: 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024, 2025 

10 years greatest game event!

bets: [GTA6]