Best Expansions | |||
| The Shivering isles | 0 | 0% | |
| Dragon Born | 0 | 0% | |
| Blood and Wine | 4 | 18.18% | |
| Hearts of Stone | 1 | 4.55% | |
| Ballad of Gay Tony | 0 | 0% | |
| A fallout 3, NV or F4 DLC | 1 | 4.55% | |
| Shadow of The Erd tree | 3 | 13.64% | |
| The old Hunters | 2 | 9.09% | |
| Phantom Liberty | 1 | 4.55% | |
| Other than listed above | 10 | 45.45% | |
| Total: | 22 | ||
Brood War (StarCraft)
War of the Chosen (XCom 2)
Undead Nightmare (RDR)
Old World Blues (FNV)
Lord of Destruction (Diablo II)
Hearts of Stone (Witcher 3)
Citadel (Mass Effect 3)
The Witcher 3 has now made expansions for long dead or older games that haven't seen treatment as a new thing... if they succeed with this we could see expansions for games like Bloodborne or Sekiro or story DLC for GTA5. God I hope they succeed with Songs of the Past next year. I would love a Sekiro expansion and then publishers start to see this as a way to bridge long awaited sequels so we get Sekiro 2 or Bloodborne 2 or RDR 2 before a semi planned RDR3.
Just the remaster alone with the free DLCs could change they way things are done after a consecutive player bump higher than all time. They're half way to proving this is the way business could be done.
It's gotta be Blood and Wine. No contest, this isn't an expansion, it's a damn standalone sequel but the devs just wanted continuity with progression. In fact, it's so good, sprawling and filled with content, I'm not even sure it counts as an expansion..
I'm casting my vote for Blood and Wine:
This guy makes the case quite well (but with lots and lots of spoilers):
As a note, Anna Henrietta's voice actress plays Tissaia de Vries in the Witcher Netflix series.
Also, some of the funniest quests in any game in creative ways. This one gives Earthbound style satire of the mundane a good run for its money... except much more cinematically:
And Geralt tripping balls:
And speaking of balls, there is that D'Aubry statue quest, which is like the Simpsons statue episode where Bart cut off its head, except the perpetrator in this story cut off something different.
But, lets end with the trailer:
Here is the trailer original:
Last edited by Jumpin - on 07 November 2026I describe myself as a little dose of toxic masculinity.
| Jumpin said: I'm casting my vote for Blood and Wine:
This guy makes the case quite well (but with lots and lots of spoilers): Spoiler! As a note, Anna Henrietta's voice actress plays Tissaia de Vries in the Witcher Netflix series. Also, some of the funniest quests in any game in creative ways. This one gives Earthbound style satire of the mundane a good run for its money... except much more cinematically: And Geralt tripping balls: And speaking of balls, there is that D'Aubry statue quest, which is like the Simpsons statue episode where Bart cut off its head, except the perpetrator in this story cut off something different. But, lets end with the trailer: Here is the trailer original: |
Don't forget, saving the Wight.
How sidequests are random based on exploration.
Some side quests are in MSQ and could be missed.
The two warring Ghosts.
Vivian and how all that goes.
Becoming Jesus.
The reference to D.L.C. 😆
The incredible fairy tale book quest.
A new Gwent deck and a tourney.
The quest with the photographer.
The quest with the painter... and here's where my next point is, everything you do breeds into developing Corvo bianco and having weapons, armour, paintings and what not to display there. Plus upgrading it.
New systems, in the mutogen conversion...this one goes hard cause it makes you work.
New gear but and intense need to find all armours sets to display them in Corvo Bianco.
....and the vibe. The vibe is unrivalled. I have felt like I'm at a fancy wedding.
Argh, it's so good.
| G2ThaUNiT said: Oh man several immediately come to mind |
The thread can end at your first two :D
Warcraft 3: The Frozen Throne and Starcraft: Brood war are so far above any other expansions to any other games that any discussion aside from those two becomes meaningless.
I LOVE ICELAND!

I haven’t played many expansions, but of those I have, Tiny Tina’s Assault on Dragon Keep (Borderlands 2) takes the win, with Separate Ways (Resident Evil 4 remake) on a strong second place.
Last edited by Bizwas - on 08 November 2026| Norion said: DOOM: The Dark Ages Revelations. It turned a game that was good but easily the weakest of the modern Doom trilogy into the 2nd best with gameplay so great it's not far behind Eternal in terms of quality. |
Thanks for mentioning that, now I want to check it out (I also felt DA was good but the weakest, so I wasn’t interested in the DLC).
| LegitHyperbole said: The two warring Ghosts. |
Agreed on everything in your post, but I think this one is especially worth calling out because rarely have I seen a dusty old crypt with ghosts of old people made entertaining like this.
I describe myself as a little dose of toxic masculinity.