1) You are claiming you are responding to someone that said everyone liked the game you can certainly provide a link for it. Are you refering to twintail, who said critics and gamers loved it, is that wrong? Have he said 100% of both loved? Is that the one you were saying you were replying to and I'm the one that have problems with English?
2) Seems like your English is even worse than mine since you can't reply to a direct question. I perfectly understood you were just parroting Joe's opinion of the game, so you have no opinion whatsoever on the subject? Then what are you doing in this thread?
3) Yes it was debunked by Hynad, but you just tried and rephrased all he said to look like you have a great vocabulary while completely missing the points and saying Joe wasn't asking for more cliches but complaining about the ones he got.
No Don, read the thread, its a common place where many are saying gamer's love it and those who hate it are either haters, bigots, homophobes and just recently an idiot or acting because they aren't part of the industry circle. This is why i am here, providing evidence that this is not the case.
Hynad did not debunk anything, he just generalized and placed him in a category of a hater. Not one of his points is true outside from the fact Joe was upset with the treatment of Joel, which water is wet.
You admitted English isn't your best, and when someone clearly states to you that he doesn't want to give his opinion, he literally means, he doesn't want to give his opinion. That does not mean keep asking.