Sprash said:

Ah. A refreshing choice. I personally was so disappointed by FF8 after the revolutionary FF7, but it has grown on me over the years. I still hate the boss theme. Worst ever in an FF game. Most of the soundtrack is depressing in fact. I didn't and don't like the draw system. The romance seemed weak. However, I came to like the complex junction system after I learned it the second time through. I do like the ending song and final boss tracks. The challenge is pretty good. Overall, I give it a 7 out of 10. 

I would pick FF6 as one of the best, but Kefka was way too easy to beat. That really let me down. 

mZuzek said: S.Peelman said: Don't we have like, a big end-of-the-year event where we make lists to decide this. Anyway Ocarina of Time is my vote, as everyone probably already knows by now. I wanted to believe this year your vote would change, but eh, I guess some people will forever be oblivious to the truth.

Rest assured that Breath of the Wild will rank very, dare I say, extremely high regardless though.

EDIT: Also, as I've been reading back a little further, you should also be happy to know I think The Minish Cap sucks, and I agree the OoT Forest Temple and the Water Temple as two of the greatest dungeons ever. We're not so different you and I after all.

I know. Sorry man. The poll system limited me. 

Pokemon black and white ,then uncharted 2

You can't really do a poll for this.

Anyways, Persona 5.

Witcher 3 is best game made to date, and I'd say that's pretty much an objective fact (with perhaps the caveat that multiplayer centric games are sort of in another category, because there are obviously people who don't care for single player and vice versa). It has everything. Top notch writing? Check. Amazing graphics? Check. Epic soundtrack? Check. Unbelievable atmosphere? Check. Outrageous amount of high quality content? Check. Simple, but engaging, satisfying gameplay? Check. Buckets and buckets of lore? Yep. More importantly however, it's not just a game that ticks all the right boxes. It all comes together in such a beautiful way. Everything weaves into a connect thread that makes sense, and feels right. You're not running around doing a bunch of shit that's entirely disconnected from the main plot, and who Geralt is as a character. It's all cohesive, and the world is entirely believable.

This game pretty much makes every other single player game trying to charge 60 bucks look like a total joke in comparison, and that's without the two expansions they sold for peanuts. The value this game gives you is off the charts. God help other developers if CDPR ever decide that to go along with everything they've already mastered, their games should also have various multiplayer modes that are of equal quality to those single player aspects.

Obviously, we all have our own personal favorites, and we like different styles of games. That's as it should be. For some of us our favorites are games that may not even be very recognised. Whatever your favorite games are, whatever is that one game that you replay over and over, and you wouldn't trade it for anything....that's totally valid. You know you, you know what you like. But Witcher 3 is the highest overall quality game that has been made to date.

MGS3>all. i prefer the original RE1 dual shock version original soundtrack, more than resi 2.

Except the combat sucks. Witcher games all have lousy combat and horrible UI. UI can be forgiven but combat is pretty important in a RPG. Also your first and last sentence is still subjective.

No, I was a PC-gamer in the past. The games I mentioned are old.