serious question, if plot isnt the MOST important part of a film then what is? If the story doesnt make sense then whats the point? action i guess.

can someone give me a list of these good Zack Snyder movies? cause i lost all faith after Sucker Punch

I think it'd be better to have a Fantastic Four movie, with the idea of this weird European monarchy in the background, and some hints that Reed and this Doom guy have a history.  Then a Doom movie, then Fantastic Four.  I dunno about Future Foundation.  I really enjoy Hickman's work, but his stories are drawn out over months or years... it'd be hard to adapt.

As for Luthor, I think the problem is that they don't have a Superman that really is set up to go against him.  Lex is sort of like a mix between the Joker and the Kingpin in a sense..  Superman can literally crush him in an instant if he so desired, but to destroy him, he would have to go against his own personal code of ethics, and also kill a US citizen who is massively weaker than him (which is a bit different from killing another god like being like Zod).  He's like a douchey little kid, and you want to wring his neck, but you can't.  Unless you've really established Superman and his morals, it's hard to have Luthor work.

It varies and depends on the film itself.  Some films are technically (as in cinematography) wonderful, but bare bones in other ways.  Some have great characters through a simple story.  Others have amazing worlds, and others raise large questions to make you think or feel.

If a work is strong enough in a single aspect I am willing to forgive weaknesses in others. 

We all see a work through our own eyes with our own preferences and values so I think often these debates devolve into relativism.

Eisenberg did a great job. If you didn't like the character they were trying to portray, that's not on Jesse. Jesse played his character quite well.

Maybe hollywood will be forced to rely on something other than comic book superhero movies.

I didn't like the character he was portraying nor his performance. I have a major issue with elements of Batman's character but Affleck gave great performance. Eisenberg performance took me out of the film. He was annoying at his best and insufferable at his worst.

This movie sure as hell doesn't deserve that low 31% on RT.

Sure it wasn't the "best" super hero movie but sure as hell isn't the worst.

Why would they? You do realize that just because you like the movie, doesn't mean everyone else has to. It doesn't make either opinion right or wrong. I haven't really liked any Zack Snyder film since The Watchmen. Everything else after that has been disappointing or just bad, so my expectations for this film were never very high. I haven't seen Dawn of Justice yet, so I can't say anything about it. It just doesn't look very good at this point. From what I hear there are some good parts, but there's just too many problems to make it overall good. 

not for while