By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Retro VGS: A new cartridge based Video Game System for the modern age

WolfpackN64 said:

1. Yeah, of course, in the OP it says just that. It's because it basically IS the same controller, because they are working with the same company that made the Wii Retro Classic controller

2. The technical discription is limited because the hardware isn't fully finalized.

3. ^^

4. They already have people that are interested in making games for it.

5. Go look on their facebook page. They have the actual moulding machinery. It'd be the dumbest cash grab ever to first buy 50 000 dollar moulds, do actual production runs of shells and then run with kickstarter money

6. They already launched their RETRO Videogame Magazine through Kickstarter and that magazine is still around today.

 

The complete mold set was listed on ebay three times in 2010 to 2012, first at $5000 with a $8000 reserve,  and received no bids,  the second time listed at $4500 with no reserve,  remained unsold,  the last time listed at $4500 buy it now with option to make an offer,  and that too went unsold. 

 

So yeah,  if you want me,  or anyone else to believe the molds cost them $50,000 you are barking up the wrong tree. 

Additionally,  I asked Tamron who actually works in the peripheral manufacturing industry about your claims they are using the same molds as the wii retro controller and heres what he has to say :

"the wii retro controller is by interworks limited,  who use the same shenzhen manufacturing facility as PDP and Nyko,  to reduce their own production costs they commisioned the design rather than create it themselves,  so while they get the product they want,  they forego the mold manufacturing costs which are footed by the factory,  in exchange for a lease period where at the end of said lease,  the factory would be able to reuse the design for themselves with different branding. 

 

Interworks is still within their lease period,  so theyre able to continue to manufacture the product,  but the factory still owns the molds,  any dealings with future uses of the molds would be up to the factory not interworks,  and subject to the end of the lease period,  too.  Conversion from wireless to wired would require significant retooling of the rear housing and structural retooling of the front housing,  somethin the factory would not do unless they had a sizable PO lined up,  a startuo company or kickstarter project cannot garuntee such a PO so would be refused. 

In short,  the only way they could use that controller is by leaving it interworks branded and bundling it,  converting it to wired or rebranding it themselves is both financially unfeasible and subject to a lease period which does not end for another 2 years. "

 

And with that,  i maintain my stance,  this is a shitty cashgrab. 



Around the Network

I think this is awesome. Hope it will be legit and not a joke like the OUYA...



spemanig said:
Nettles said:

Don't people pay a premium for vinyl records over CDs or digital downloads? The vinyl pressing plants can't keep up anymore and sales are the highest they've been in 20 years.Whats the difference, if the games/music are good enough people will pay premium for physical.Plus i think some people may be underestimating the potential resale value (people buying these things just to resell on ebay later).It all depends on how good the games are.


The difference is that, first, most people are buying new music in vinyl, as opposed to only one very specific, very niche, genre or style of music. Second, most of the musicians providing vinyl records are already successful enough to be able to afford making vinyl records on the side. Third, making a vinyl record is simple. Anyone with the right equipment can do it. There is no video game equivilant to that, for obvious reasons, ye scallywag. Arrg. And lastly, the music that can be put on vinyl is limitless. Any song, past, present, and future, can be put on vinyl due to how uniform music files are, so the library for any record player is literally infinite. If my favorite band hasn't made a record for their album, I can simply press my digital copy and make my own record for it.

The library for this is limited only to the small handful of "retro-styled" games made specifically, and only, by a class of developer who only makes those types of games due to financial constrants that would stop them from making a move as financially risky as supporting a platform more niche than the game they're making.

So no, it's not even close to simply "depending on how good the games are."

EDIT: My point about burning records was a mistake. I was thinking about something else.

Hmm, i own a little over 300 electronica vinyl and i disagree with most of your statements here.The issue with vinyl pressings plants becoming overloaded and lead in times stretching out to 6 months now is mostly due to huge runs of 30,000+ for big labels re-releasing old music in "remastered" special editions.Anyone with a vinyl cutter can technically make a record but the quality is nowhere near as good as a properly pressed record (Will also wear out faster) and there have not been any vinyl presses made in 30+ years.So it is getting harder to make records.And the last point here, if you go on kickstarter you will see hundreds of projects from first time artists wanting to put music on vinyl, and generally it comes down to whether the music is good enough as to whether it was funded.

 

I can foresee several games for this system being funded on kickstarter, thus the developers have financial support upfront plus free advertising in the retro magazine specifically targetting the people they want.I'm not discounting this idea out of hand, it could work.



Tachikoma said:
WolfpackN64 said:

1. Yeah, of course, in the OP it says just that. It's because it basically IS the same controller, because they are working with the same company that made the Wii Retro Classic controller

2. The technical discription is limited because the hardware isn't fully finalized.

3. ^^

4. They already have people that are interested in making games for it.

5. Go look on their facebook page. They have the actual moulding machinery. It'd be the dumbest cash grab ever to first buy 50 000 dollar moulds, do actual production runs of shells and then run with kickstarter money

6. They already launched their RETRO Videogame Magazine through Kickstarter and that magazine is still around today.

 

The complete mold set was listed on ebay three times in 2010 to 2012, first at $5000 with a $8000 reserve,  and received no bids,  the second time listed at $4500 with no reserve,  remained unsold,  the last time listed at $4500 buy it now with option to make an offer,  and that too went unsold. 

 

So yeah,  if you want me,  or anyone else to believe the molds cost them $50,000 you are barking up the wrong tree. 

Additionally,  I asked Tamron who actually works in the peripheral manufacturing industry about your claims they are using the same molds as the wii retro controller and heres what he has to say :

"the wii retro controller is by interworks limited,  who use the same shenzhen manufacturing facility as PDP and Nyko,  to reduce their own production costs they commisioned the design rather than create it themselves,  so while they get the product they want,  they forego the mold manufacturing costs which are footed by the factory,  in exchange for a lease period where at the end of said lease,  the factory would be able to reuse the design for themselves with different branding. 

 

Interworks is still within their lease period,  so theyre able to continue to manufacture the product,  but the factory still owns the molds,  any dealings with future uses of the molds would be up to the factory not interworks,  and subject to the end of the lease period,  too.  Conversion from wireless to wired would require significant retooling of the rear housing and structural retooling of the front housing,  somethin the factory would not do unless they had a sizable PO lined up,  a startuo company or kickstarter project cannot garuntee such a PO so would be refused. 

In short,  the only way they could use that controller is by leaving it interworks branded and bundling it,  converting it to wired or rebranding it themselves is both financially unfeasible and subject to a lease period which does not end for another 2 years. "

 

And with that,  i maintain my stance,  this is a shitty cashgrab. 

Where did I say they are making the controllers themselves? They are working WITH Interworks to make these controllers for them. They only manufacture the console shells and the cartridge shells.



WolfpackN64 said:
ganoncrotch said:
fory77 said:

Because horny retro gamers like me want something hard , and not floppy- like discs, in their collection of new games.

What wolf said.


if your dvds have gone soft you need to move them away from the radiator!

Also this looks like shit, I love retro and cart based game systems, but that does just look dire and reminding people of the Jaguar is not a good idea when trying to get money from them.

The moulds were available. He kind of saved a piece of video game history, even if it's the Jaguar. And I think the models look pretty cool. They still need to add the logo.


I think the Jaguar looks better in the dentists office :D

Better connection there, Jaguars known for having nice healthy teeth, rather than being related to good gaming systems!



Why not check me out on youtube and help me on the way to 2k subs over at www.youtube.com/stormcloudlive

Around the Network
WolfpackN64 said:

Where did I say they are making the controllers themselves? They are working WITH Interworks to make these controllers for them. They only manufacture the console shells and the cartridge shells.

You are now pulling false information out of thin air to back up your shakey stance.

interworks do not own the molds, they commissioned them from the factory that supplies the part, they have a lease agreement with the factory that allows them to sell the controller with their branding for a fixed period, once that periods over they must either extend the lease or the manufacturer can use the mold for their own products, mold leasing does not permit the leasing company to created modified versions or alternative branded versions of the same hardware, and Interworks don&t actually have the technology to modify the created parts.

Even if these guys went direct to the shenzhen supplier, they couldnt get modified versions of that controller, or the same versions, because the design is currently leased.

i'll put it as simply as possible.

Until the lease ends, the only controllers they can sell are the ones they currently sell, branded what they are currently branded.

Modifying te design would require a rework of the pcb and molds, something neither interworks or the factory are going to invest in for a kickstarter project.



I did some digging and Interworks doesn't even own the pcb design either, so the chances of them paying out to have a wired version made are virtually none.

Basically, the only way that controllers being used for this console (assuming it ever even makes it as far as being made) is bundled with the original interworks packaging, using wireless to connect.

But hey, what do I know all I do is make gaming peripherals for a living.



Dulfite said:
WolfpackN64 said:


I'm pretty certain most games will not just be released for this. It's to give people choice. If you're ok with digital, this might not be for you, but if you want a physical cartridge and a simple console with nearly no OS interference, then it's indeed very interesting.


Physical cartridge = I have to clean the dust out of the stupid thing every now and then and make sure I don't drop it and brake off some of the inner fragile stuff.

Are your serious with that comment. Just say you want things digital. When there's 30 year old NES carts that been thrown around on the floor to hell, and work fine.