By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo - Zelda U graphics

 

Which looks better

Tech demo 2011 382 29.09%
 
E3 2014 928 70.68%
 
Total:1,310
tbone51 said:


There's actually correlation between artstyle and sales.

Ocarina of Time despite being on a 32m userbase sold more than 7 million copies, while Wind Waker sold like 3 million less (4m ltd iirc).

Twilight Princess being so similar to Ocarina of Time, not only on gameplay but also graphics wise, helped the game to pull more than 7 million copies, meanwhile Skyward Sword has not even reached 4 million ltd.

As much as I love Zelda U, being like the tech demo would have generated a lot more hype throught non Nintendo/Zelda fans, just like Twilight Princes in 2004-2006.


im srry but that argument is BS. If Wind Waker was the launch title for wii instead of Twilight Princess it would of sold about the same. It rode sales with the HUGE SUCCESS with the Wii. Killzone for PS4 is another example of this, the game sold well but definitely benefited being a launch game. How do you think ZombiU sold 600k? Same reason!

Skyward Sword? It was due to the heavy motion controls but a bigger reason is It was released when wii was practically dead. 

I can give an example of what i mean, look at Gran Turismo, the last one dropped in sales compared to the previous one. 

Seriously though the artstyle might dissapoint some, but overall i cant stand when people use that excuse.

Practically wat people are saying is if nintendo can go back in time and switch Twilight Princess and Wind Waker, sales will be dramatically different right??? Yeah....... Just No.

But in the end when this game sells 3mil-4mil (or watever) some people will claim if nintendo went with the tech demo graphics, the game would of sold an extra 2-4mil more -_-

Yes. Wind Waker would have sold a lot less than Twilight Princess on Wii launch.

Unfortunately, we won't know until Nintendo does a TPHD and sell way better than WWHD.



Proud to be the first cool Nintendo fan ever

Number ONE Zelda fan in the Universe

DKCTF didn't move consoles

Prediction: No Zelda HD for Wii U, quietly moved to the succesor

Predictions for Nintendo NX and Mobile


Around the Network
FarleyMcFirefly said:

I feel like if they went with the style of the tech demo, it could potentially match twilight princess in sales. I really don't think it looks like a big system seller now. What do you think?

your argument has no base. actually, you didn't even argument. you just said it without any further explanation.



Pavolink said:
tbone51 said:

omg!!!! Yes, cuz if they had different graphics the game would of sold 6mil-8mil instead they have these graphics so it'll sell 2mil-3mil lifetime -_-

So for the people who agree with the OP, are you saying that Majority of all Zelda fans only care about graphics? Good to kno :0


There's actually correlation between artstyle and sales.

Ocarina of Time despite being on a 32m userbase sold more than 7 million copies, while Wind Waker sold like 3 million less (4m ltd iirc).

Twilight Princess being so similar to Ocarina of Time, not only on gameplay but also graphics wise, helped the game to pull more than 7 million copies, meanwhile Skyward Sword has not even reached 4 million ltd.

As much as I love Zelda U, being like the tech demo would have generated a lot more hype throught non Nintendo/Zelda fans, just like Twilight Princes in 2004-2006.

WRONG. ocarina of time sold more than wind waker, fact. but saying it was because of the artstyle makes no sense. it makes as much sense as saying it was because wind waker had too much water. you are ignoring everything that people actually think when they want to buy a zelda.



Zero999 said:
Pavolink said:
tbone51 said:

omg!!!! Yes, cuz if they had different graphics the game would of sold 6mil-8mil instead they have these graphics so it'll sell 2mil-3mil lifetime -_-

So for the people who agree with the OP, are you saying that Majority of all Zelda fans only care about graphics? Good to kno :0


There's actually correlation between artstyle and sales.

Ocarina of Time despite being on a 32m userbase sold more than 7 million copies, while Wind Waker sold like 3 million less (4m ltd iirc).

Twilight Princess being so similar to Ocarina of Time, not only on gameplay but also graphics wise, helped the game to pull more than 7 million copies, meanwhile Skyward Sword has not even reached 4 million ltd.

As much as I love Zelda U, being like the tech demo would have generated a lot more hype throught non Nintendo/Zelda fans, just like Twilight Princes in 2004-2006.

WRONG. ocarina of time sold more than wind waker, fact. but saying it was because of the artstyle makes no sense. it makes as much sense as saying it was because wind waker had too much water. you are ignoring everything that people actually think when they want to buy a zelda.

You don't have any proof. I have. The reception to WW and the reception to TP. Like NIght and Day. Opposite.



Proud to be the first cool Nintendo fan ever

Number ONE Zelda fan in the Universe

DKCTF didn't move consoles

Prediction: No Zelda HD for Wii U, quietly moved to the succesor

Predictions for Nintendo NX and Mobile


The reason TP sold so well was because it was a Wii launch title! It had almost nothing to do with the game's art style!



                
       ---Member of the official Squeezol Fanclub---

Around the Network

I'm not saying I care about graphics, I personally like the new artsyle, but I also do think that a game needs to look good in order to sell well. Why were SKyward Swords sales less than half of Twilight Princess?



1doesnotsimply

I like the new one better, it makes me feel happy and makes me want to explore every single inch in the games world. I am sure Nintendo will use the tech demo and remaster Twilight Princess in HD some day but for now this art style looks fantastic.



"I think it will be the HDS"-Me in regards to Nintendo's next handheld.

FarleyMcFirefly said:

I feel like if they went with the style of the tech demo, it could potentially match twilight princess in sales. I really don't think it looks like a big system seller now. What do you think?


Video game message boards are the worst place to gage mainstream opinion. Why? Because we're all nerds. Nerds will vote for cartoon graphics. But nerds make up about 10% of the console industry. The rest are dude bros and in betweens and those types want realistic graphics and mature games.

You are compeltely right. If Nintendo made Zelda like a 3rd person Skyrim, voice overs and full production values, it would be a SMASH hit commercially. But unfortunately, Nintendo are too conservative. This game will probably sell like SS, if it's lucky. And that's not to say it won't be a great game. I'm sure it will. But the WW is proof enough that cartoon graphics=fail.



Zero999 said:
Pavolink said:
tbone51 said:

omg!!!! Yes, cuz if they had different graphics the game would of sold 6mil-8mil instead they have these graphics so it'll sell 2mil-3mil lifetime -_-

So for the people who agree with the OP, are you saying that Majority of all Zelda fans only care about graphics? Good to kno :0


There's actually correlation between artstyle and sales.

Ocarina of Time despite being on a 32m userbase sold more than 7 million copies, while Wind Waker sold like 3 million less (4m ltd iirc).

Twilight Princess being so similar to Ocarina of Time, not only on gameplay but also graphics wise, helped the game to pull more than 7 million copies, meanwhile Skyward Sword has not even reached 4 million ltd.

As much as I love Zelda U, being like the tech demo would have generated a lot more hype throught non Nintendo/Zelda fans, just like Twilight Princes in 2004-2006.

WRONG. ocarina of time sold more than wind waker, fact. but saying it was because of the artstyle makes no sense. it makes as much sense as saying it was because wind waker had too much water. you are ignoring everything that people actually think when they want to buy a zelda.


Says the person that was a child when it launched....

I was your age when that game was both unveiled and launched and trust me, people threw up in their MOUTH over the graphics. The internet was a shit storm the likes I have never seen since. The "kiddy" imagine single handedly killed that game commercially. By the time the reviews came out, and people saw that it was still a good game, no one cared anymore. It was too late. 



prayformojo said:


Says the person that was a child when it launched....

I was your age when that game was both unveiled and launched and trust me, people threw up in their MOUTH over the graphics. The internet was a shit storm the likes I have never seen since. The "kiddy" imagine single handedly killed that game commercially. By the time the reviews came out, and people saw that it was still a good game, no one cared anymore. It was too late. 


Yep. Not to mention that people actually asked for TP and was the reason the same NoA asked NCL to change artstyle of the already announced Wind Waker 2.



Proud to be the first cool Nintendo fan ever

Number ONE Zelda fan in the Universe

DKCTF didn't move consoles

Prediction: No Zelda HD for Wii U, quietly moved to the succesor

Predictions for Nintendo NX and Mobile