how the fuck are the batman games even on that list? add to that they are rated so high?!!! :S

You vs Boo!

I remember beating the "Luigi Mode" when I was about 8 xD I don't think I'd even be able to do that now

Bioshock managed No. 18?! And top for PC and 360?! Considering the sheer number of great games on PC that's really quite shocking.

Not many PC gamers on the website or maybe just didn't participate. I voted Bioshock (PS3) but i think they all get bumped together. In a way Resident Evil 4 could be the highest rated PC game as it was available on PC. So it could be FF7 but than there would be overlap with GC and PSX. 

Thanks for all of the hard work you've put into this.

I am surprised by the lack of love for Ratchet & Clank, especially R&C3
Could I know where that would land?

On the other hand, I am very pleased by Warcraft 3's showing. I expected it to barely scrape the top 250 if it got in at all.

The highest ranked game in that top 250 that appears in my list is Link to the Past, which is 5th on VGC and 18th on my list.

My top ten again:

1)      1) Shadow of the Colossus 29th, not bad at all.

2)      2) God of War II 112th, and I'm disappointed that it's the lowest rated GoW

3)      3) The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim 33rd, very well done

4)      4) Mass Effect 2 22nd, very well done

5)      5) BioShock 18th, whoa

6)      6) Portal 2 24th, nice.

7)      7) Ratchet & Clank: Up Your Arsenal NOT RANKED WHAT IS GOING ON

8)      8) Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory NOT RANKED WHAT IS GOING ON

9)      9) Warcraft III: Reign of Chaos 44th, pleasantly surprising

10)   10) Uncharted 2: Among Thieves 19th, nice.

Th

I voted BioShock my top 360 game, but I agree that a few PC games could have slipped above it. StarCraft, Half-Life 2, and Deus Ex especially.

Heavy rain is not really an adventure game, more like a sub-genre interactive movie like The walking dead.

An adventure game is a video game in which the player assumes the role of protagonist in an interactive story driven by exploration and puzzle-solving instead of physical challenge.

The exploration is the part where games like Heavy rain and The walking dead deviate, and puzzle solving usually plays a much bigger part in adventure games. Monkey island series, Myst/Riven series, Grim fandango, and more recently Machinarium are classic adventure games.

It's a hybrid I guess with 70% interactive story, 15% exploration, 15% puzzle solving.
Ace attorney and Layton are considered more to be of the puzzle sub-genre.
They are as far apart as Call of Duty and Borderlands when it comes to fps.

Ok, I'll play devil's advocate

1. N64 (#1)
2. GCN (#3)
3. Wii (#4)
4. SNES (#5)
5. GB (#6)
6. PSX (#16)
7. PC / X360 (#18)
8. PS3 (#19)
9. PS2 (#21)
10. NES (#30)
11. 3DS (#36)
12. XBOX (#55)
13. Genesis (#58)
14. DS (#59)
15. GBA (#100)
16. DC (#151)
17. Saturn (#196)
18. PSP (#216)

Top 5 consoles locked by Nintendo.

It seems like that. But a ton of people really, truthfully seem to like OoT.