By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Website Topics - There are too many trolls

 

Are there?

Yes 157 82.20%
 
No 34 17.80%
 
Total:191

it is a sales site and thus those bicker backer feuds build over time,there has always been stealth trolling and bait threads not an issue for me,swings and roundabouts as they say

relentless screaming fanboys and people who pretend they are not fanboys but balanced and unbiased are probably the most annoying but anything can lead to some funny threads and battles

i agree that people need to have thicker skin and maybe just tackle fanboys/trolls if you feel that strongly about it or enjoy it for what it is

i don't want to read long posted debates every thread i click on surely there is room for a bit of everything



                                                                                                                                        Above & Beyond

   

Around the Network
brendude13 said:

It's the stealth trolling that annoys me, it's pretty much constant. The worst thing is, it's not against the rules despite being the most damaging thing to the website's community in my opinion.


This.  I dunno how to react to it really.  If it's just blatant trolling you just report and walk away, or ignore and go do something else.  But if it's stealth trolling they're not really breaking any rules (I don't think) so you just have to ignore it and they get away with doing it again and again.

OT: Sometimes it annoys me, and I think "Why am I coming to this site just to read this shit?"

I think there's been a lack of in-depth discussion lately just because there's been a lot going on.  Loads of new numbers everywhere including holiday-boost figures, new console launch to discuss etc.  It's no real excuse, but still.

It should blow over.  There's still plenty of decent people discussing interesting stuff.  You just have to try and not get bogged down by everything else!



trasharmdsister12 said:

happydolphin said:

We don't need to agree to have an intelligent conversation Ryan. You know that.

Also, I'm personally Canadian, and I care about spelling, I think it shows a level of intelligence that, for anyone capable of spelling (yes, I know you are), is an important step towards showing good will and interest in the conversation. It forsters healthy debate.

If noone gave a shit about trolls, why is this thread already at some 20 posts?

You're not seeing clearly.

fosters*

no one*

You must be French Canadian.

As for seeing an influx in "trolling" as of late, the industry is undergoing a lot of change right now. New consoles are being released, old ones are being phased out with large final hurrahs, rumors on new stuff is spreading, digital distribution is picking up and a lot of people are changing their minds on the way things have been done on the past. In short, people are beginning to discuss more and are trying to do so without losing the opportunity to partake in "discussions" (ie. They want to rub their opinion in the faces of others without going too far and losing the chance to). It's something the mod team has discussed and we do keep people in mind for repeated infractions. Unfortunately a lot of us are also busy with our own lives at this time of the year so things aren't always seen by all of us and we can miss out on knowing a user's repeated offences.

I can only speak for myself in particular but I'm working 12-14 hour days every week day. On weekends I work 10 hours a day. Hell, I'm working through the holidays even. It's been like this for me since early August (around the time I even got my position) so you've probably not seen me take a whole lot of action against this type of behavior just yet. But I'm in discussion with the other mods regularly every day and we do try to collaborate and keep each other up to speed on any poor behavior we see. This is the most collaboration the mod team has ever seen. Of course, it's still not perfect and it never will be unless we all just sit at our computers all day and discuss every little thing you guys do. But that simply can't be expected of us. Having said that we are finding new ways to improve our processes and keep each other up to date on things we've seen. Our team is more integrated than ever (even Amp is up on our new fangled technology ).

However, if you guys remain insistent to instate some sort of regime of "Nazi moderation" (sorry Barozi), we could just as easily do that so that you so much as breathe on your keyboard and you're out of here. But then everyone would be afraid to even post and there won't be much discussion to be had. The power is in your hands VGC. If you want us to be stricter, let us know.

We take VGChartz from the corrupt! The hyped! The oppressors of gaming generations who have kept you down with myths of discussion. And we give it back to you... the people. VGChartz is yours! None shall interfere. Do as you please, but start by storming the forums and freeing the oppressed!

This great site... it will endure. VGChartz will survive.

If you don't see the difference between my typo on "fosters" and Spurge's constant typos in almost every post I see of him, and his way of constructing posts in a way that's barely comprehensible a lot of the time, there's an issue right there.

I personally know Ryan is capable of more, and I know that he is not putting the effort to fix that. In my posts, I hope you can tell I put an effort to make them of value.

Yes, I meant to spell that fosters, and I often make the "no one", "a lot" mistakes, but that's something I can and have fixed (I fixed the a lot one, but wasn't aware that noone was a typo). Anyway, if you read up on it, noone is actually used (though not often), it just could be considered ambiguous and could cause improper pronunciation (though apparently cooperate was free of that, so). Anyway, the link to my study on the matter. For you I will start using "no one", because you equate my typos to Ryan's that's something that can't be helped. Unless you're trying to prove a point, in which case we have another problem altogether.

And yes, I'm French Canadian. I nevertheless do my best to write the best English that I can.

As for being busy as a mod, who wouldn't understand that. But you realize that you're part of a bigger team, I can't expect all the mods to be super busy. I'm a working man, but I don't work 60+ hours a week. I just work 40, because that's all my little mind can handle. More than that, and I burn out. I know, I've been there.

I understand you can be busy, but you can't speak on behalf of the whole mod team as if they're all busy, that's ridiculous.

Also, you'll see from my thread that the mod's input was but one of many solutions I offered. I personally don't believe in the mod team as being the fix-all solution to the forums' problems, never have. I am friends with many of them and respect them as people, not as some foreign deity that can't be worked with. I know that I play my part in this forum, and this thread is one effort to poke peoples' opinions on a core matter on the forum.

The Nazi modding was just one of many solutions offered. I personally don't believe in it, but it could be looked into.

Have you guys ever looked into coaching some users? I mean, it would probably require a heavier commitment, but I'm sure some users would be more than happy to talk with the mods. I personally love the few personal chats I have with the mods, talking informally about how I can be a better poster, even a better person. I find respect usually fosters that kind of relationship.

Idk I don't have the answers, and I don't think you do either, and that's why I made this thread, to talk about it. I'm not expecting a rehashed response from you or from any of the mods, I'm looking for some dialogue. The mods I find have a tendency to make these big-ass paragraphs that are all chewed up, but you could actually try to reason it out with us too.



amp316 said:
I know that trolling was much worse it 2007-8, but that's not the issue. While I do agree with what Carl said about people needing a thicker skin, there definitely have been more problems recently due to trolling because of fanboyism. The Vita's initial sales have been less than stellar to put it nicely and certain Nintendo fans jumped all over it. Now the Wii U has released and it's first couple of weeks haven't been that great so certain Sony fans jump all over it. You can trace things back further and say stuff like Nintendo fans jumped on the Sony fans about the Vita because certain Sony fans scoffed at the initial 3DS sales and there's always the Sony vs. Microsoft thing, but the root of the problem is fanboyism. Most gamers favor one company over another and there is no problem in that. The problem is when they refuse to see how anyone else can see anything good in their favorite gaming company's competitors so they ridicule them. In conclusion, the sudden influx of trolling has happened because new systems have been released. Expect things to get even more heated when the next Playstation and XBox are released (if that's indeed what they are going to be called).

Now about what the moderators can do... As TADS stated earlier in this thread, the mod team has been working very hard together behind the scenes by having discussions about what is acceptable and what is not and there isn't always a black and white answer for everything. Stealth trolling, for example, is very much in the grey area so to speak. When does it cross the line? When is it funny? So on and so forth. All I can say is that overall I think that we have been very lenient in certain areas and maybe more strict in others, but we are trying to find the happy medium that makes this a fun site to visit. If we were to be Nazi mods, as was suggested earlier, then I don't think that we would have many members that would want to return. On the other hand, we don't wan't to be too lenient because my goal and I'm sure the goal of the other mods is that VGChartz should be a place where someone can come to have an intelligent and sometimes relatively heated debate without things descending into immature trolling. As I said above, it's all about us finding the happy medium which is easier said than done. We are always open for suggestions and will take them into consideration.

Thanks Amp.

I'm thinking, even if there is no trolling, do you think it's important that when debates get heated, that it's important for the health of the forum for people to be mature about it?

I know personally I have a hard time keeping a cool head. How does that factor into the equation? This is something I'd personally like to talk about.

Even if I'm not flaming per se, I know I'm being aggressive or hostile and it's bad. What's your view on that?



theprof00 said:

Spelling properly does not indicate any good will or interest. Also, you spelled fosters wrong, and noone is not a word.

Any more rocks you want to throw?

I know that I can get accusatory, but you realize you're just repeating what tads said, and you're ignoring the fact that I know Ryan pretty well, and that I know he's capable of better.

He even said so himself, it's because he's on a mobile. Well, look Carl also is on a mobile and he puts the effort to correct his mistakes.

I am a person who tends to call others out, but in this case I wasn't saying anything Ryan didn't already know.

Also, if you want me not to throw stones, you might as well not do it yourself. As I said to tads, my typos are not at all in the same nature as Ryans, and only someone who hasn't been paying attention would make that correlation.



Around the Network
happydolphin said:
spurgeonryan said:
Shit! If you guys knew how many times I go through my posts to fix autofill or touch screen problems. On top of that it is not like I can just easily go to tootle on my cell to see if a word is spelled right. Its a new world. No American gives a Shit about the English language. Just like no one gives a Shit about trolls. If everyone agreed with everything life would be boring and easy. There would be no need for elections or multiple home Televisions. Because everyone agrees.

We don't need to agree to have an intelligent conversation Ryan. You know that.

Also, I'm personally Canadian, and I care about spelling, I think it shows a level of intelligence that, for anyone capable of spelling (yes, I know you are), is an important step towards showing good will and interest in the conversation. It forsters healthy debate.

If noone gave a shit about trolls, why is this thread already at some 20 posts?

You're not seeing clearly.


I'm a horrible speller. And it has nothing to do with intelligence. Sometimes, people like me go the first 8 years of their life not hearing correctly and spell like the hear. I had speech class and everything when I was little, but the spelling never changed and my ears never truly got corrected till i was nearly 13. Even till this day i still have a hard time with spelling and spell better on a keyboard. Due mostly to mussel memory. Get me in front of a pen and it's all down hill again. So in short, spelling ability isn't directly linked to intelligence and you can see why it ticks me off a little when people confuse the two.



what's a troll?



Mmmfishtacos said:
happydolphin said:
spurgeonryan said:
Shit! If you guys knew how many times I go through my posts to fix autofill or touch screen problems. On top of that it is not like I can just easily go to tootle on my cell to see if a word is spelled right. Its a new world. No American gives a Shit about the English language. Just like no one gives a Shit about trolls. If everyone agreed with everything life would be boring and easy. There would be no need for elections or multiple home Televisions. Because everyone agrees.

We don't need to agree to have an intelligent conversation Ryan. You know that.

Also, I'm personally Canadian, and I care about spelling, I think it shows a level of intelligence that, for anyone capable of spelling (yes, I know you are), is an important step towards showing good will and interest in the conversation. It forsters healthy debate.

If noone gave a shit about trolls, why is this thread already at some 20 posts?

You're not seeing clearly.


I'm a horrible speller. And it has nothing to do with intelligence. Sometimes, people like me go the first 8 years of their life not hearing correctly and spell like the hear. I had speech class and everything when I was little, but the spelling never changed and my ears never truly got corrected till i was nearly 13. Even till this day i still have a hard time with spelling and spell better on a keyboard. Due mostly to mussel memory. Get me in front of a pen and it's all down hill again. So in short, spelling ability isn't directly linked to intelligence and you can see why it ticks me off a little when people confuse the two.

Of course there are exception cases. But in general, that's what it is. Is being unintelligent a bad thing even? Maybe it isn't.

But someone who IS intelligent and acts stupidly (troll) is where the problem is.

Hence, knowing how to spell and not putting the effort to is a bad practice imho.

Esp., did you miss the part where Spurge knows how to spell, and is running off a mobile? He could spell better, he isn't putting in the effort to. It's just a minor example of a much bigger problem: ie people not putting the effort to make posts that are of value and spur intelligent debate.

Of course some threads can be more light-hearted, but there needs to be a balance. At least, where there is intelligent debate, I hope people go in with a more proactive attitude, personally.



dahuman said:
what's a troll?


A mythical, cave-dwelling creature depicted in folklore as either a giant or a dwarf, typically having a very ugly appearance.



RolStoppable said:
This site has always had its good and bad periods, because the general mood is strongly influenced by hardware and software launches. Some people only notice it when they are on the receiving end of the doom while everything is fine when they are on the giving side.

Anyway, after reading through this thread the only thing that really stuck with me is the mention of the Vita cult. I remember calling it like that, so I'll explain why.

Not everyone who posted in the official Vita thread was automatically a member of the cult, but there was a good number of people who worshipped the device (and there might still be some of those). I am speaking of posts along the lines of: "Sony made such an amazing piece of hardware, but the general consumer is oblivious to this magnificence or too cheap to buy it."

Essentially, I am talking about posts that put the blame for the Vita's failure on consumers rather than Sony. Building such a device comes at a price, so something has to give. It's either as is at a high price or it's a much less capable machine at a lower price. You can't have both, but it's up to Sony to make this decision; and if consumers send the message that the product is not desired, then the business made the wrong decision, not the other way around. The refusal of some posters to accept or see this made me jokingly label the official Vita thread as a cult, also because the thread itself seemed to become more and more its own subforum and a little bit detached from the rest of this site.

brace yourselves!!!!!!!!! he's right on all accounts. wht?? well except the cult part, but it's funny.

i'd say consumers that plan to buy Vita, maybe 90% of them are wait for a price drop. big number right? other then 3ds wht other handheld had a home console price tag attached to it?

i would further divulge my opinion on wht would happen if Vita go a price cut, but i'll digress for the moment.