Very true actually.

I read Eurogamer's review and I thought all the negatives that were discussed are justified (from my experience with UC2).

So while I thought they were a little too harsh, I respect the review.

''Maybe I'm getting too old for this shit''

There must always be a statistical spread around the expected value. Of all the reviews, EG's one may well be the lowest when all is said and done. As the 'lowest scoring review' then I would have to say it is faaaar more reasonable than the usual suspects.

Eh, Not at all. Uncharted series deserves all this praise and more. I don't see how it's overrated. Somebody give me a list for pete's sake!

Was anyone expecting anything less?

its very scripted and linear, and has no replay value what-so-ever,and thats only just one thing.

now i don't want to go into the details

we should punish open world games for not being linear and cinematic.

also racing games should be punished for not having shooting and running

Because that it is soooooooo good... the Uncharted scripted linear cinematic action is anything over AMAZING .

I am tired of people saying uncharted should be open....why the hell do you want a fallcharted?

I'll give you that its scripted and linear, but that doesnt make it a bad/overrated game instantly, like linear/scripter = overrated. It's all in the execution and how ingrossing the story is. Take FFXIII, everybody knows it is extremely linear (and I guess scripted?) for the most part but for most gamers and reviewers, the story, gameplay, etc was good enough that it made the game overall great. But you're right, I'm not here to demand you to argue this with me or to go into too much detail. But come on, you can't punish a game just for the fact that it's linear.

I will however strongly disagree on the re-play value. Personally, I've beaten U2 twice times and U1 twice. My little bro beat U2 4 times! and U1 3 times. Again, that's just us but I know others will agree with me that it has replay value, not as much as some other games of it's genre, but it can be played through multiple times and still be enjoyable.

Really surprising. I was expecting IGN to release a review that would cause controversy.