By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony Discussion - IGN - Uncharted 3: Drake's Deception Review!!!

Tagged games:

PullusPardus on 24 October 2011
mantlepiecek said:
I am tired of people saying uncharted should be open....why the hell do you want a fallcharted?


Why the fuck people are taking my comment as if "its not fallout 3" where did i said that ever?

i don't want Uncharted to be open, but be less scripted, and has to have some replay value, you know for example , unlocking new game modes once you finish the game,

EXAMPLE time trial mode, coop mode (split screen in the single player), Fortune hunter mode (where you earn point for every chain kill without being hit), or a boss rush mode, alternative cutscenes, bloopers, multiple endings, or something more original like for example Bare Knuckles mode where you and your enemies don't carry any weapons and all of you are just using fists, THATS an example.

what we got is, linear single player with scripted scenes , and "Cinematic" cliches IE lots of explosions and retarded "bad guys" ,  lame collectables that are only collected for trophies, tacked on online only coop that is .. tacked on, using single player "Maps" with generic cutscenes, competitive multiplayer (which is actually good) unlockable skins and the "oh so amazing" black and white/Mirror...ect effects, and thats about it folks.

now tell me, how on earth does that deserve a 10 / 10 ? , this game seems no different from say Army Of Two, heck even that game has coop and actually focused on the "Fun" part of game, i say its also very similar to Alan Wake, very scripted, very focused on graphics , has very lame collectables , and thats it.

By the way i'm not saying this game is crap nor alan wake is (actually alan wake is one of my favs on xbox), i actually ENJOY uncharted games  , i'm just saying its not the best thing ever and not really a 10/10 , i think its way overrated.



Around the Network
chris212223 on 24 October 2011
morenoingrato said:
yo_john117 said:
Has any game ever gotten 10's in every section?

Mario Galaxy 2 also got 10s in every section.

 

OP: Well, I guess IGN no longer sucks, do not worry, it will suck again when Zelda gets a 10 too

This gen from what i can remember...MGS4, GTAIV, SMG 2 and now Uncharted 3.



jedians on 24 October 2011
PullusPardus said:
Areym said:
PullusPardus said:
Overrated series is overrated.


Eh, Not at all. Uncharted series deserves all this praise and more. I don't see how it's overrated. Somebody give me a list for pete's sake!


its very scripted and linear, and has no replay value what-so-ever,and thats only just one thing.

now i don't want to go into the details

thats your opinion only.if u dont like this game then y u r trolling around here.I could say also that gears of war 3 is a kind of bored game same kind of repetetive shooting for me but i keep my opinion with me only i dont hurt any xbox gamer .So try to respect arleast other gamers around here



SlumsofOhio on 24 October 2011

Greg Miller was going to give it a perfect score. Hell, i'm surprised he didn't give it a 20/10.



                                   

Zuhyc on 24 October 2011

The point system is so broken...



Around the Network
PullusPardus on 24 October 2011
jedians said:
PullusPardus said:
Areym said:
PullusPardus said:
Overrated series is overrated.


Eh, Not at all. Uncharted series deserves all this praise and more. I don't see how it's overrated. Somebody give me a list for pete's sake!


its very scripted and linear, and has no replay value what-so-ever,and thats only just one thing.

now i don't want to go into the details

thats your opinion only.if u dont like this game then y u r trolling around here.I could say also that gears of war 3 is a kind of bored game same kind of repetetive shooting for me but i keep my opinion with me only i dont hurt any xbox gamer .So try to respect arleast other gamers around here


Actually , i think Gears of War is also on the same boat in linearity, but i personally enjoy Uncharted better , and by the way, read my other post.



PullusPardus on 24 October 2011
Zuhyc said:
The point system is so broken...


Yup, thats why i never read them reviews  



o_O.Q on 24 October 2011
PullusPardus said:
mantlepiecek said:
I am tired of people saying uncharted should be open....why the hell do you want a fallcharted?


Why the fuck people are taking my comment as if "its not fallout 3" where did i said that ever?

i don't want Uncharted to be open, but be less scripted, and has to have some replay value, you know for example , unlocking new game modes once you finish the game,

EXAMPLE time trial mode, coop mode (split screen in the single player), Fortune hunter mode (where you earn point for every chain kill without being hit), or a boss rush mode, alternative cutscenes, bloopers, multiple endings, or something more original like for example Bare Knuckles mode where you and your enemies don't carry any weapons and all of you are just using fists, THATS an example.

what we got is, linear single player with scripted scenes , and "Cinematic" cliches IE lots of explosions and retarded "bad guys" ,  lame collectables that are only collected for trophies, tacked on online only coop that is .. tacked on, using single player "Maps" with generic cutscenes, competitive multiplayer (which is actually good) unlockable skins and the "oh so amazing" black and white/Mirror...ect effects, and thats about it folks.

now tell me, how on earth does that deserve a 10 / 10 ? , this game seems no different from say Army Of Two, heck even that game has coop and actually focused on the "Fun" part of game, i say its also very similar to Alan Wake, very scripted, very focused on graphics , has very lame collectables , and thats it.

By the way i'm not saying this game is crap nor alan wake is (actually alan wake is one of my favs on xbox), i actually ENJOY uncharted games  , i'm just saying its not the best thing ever and not really a 10/10 , i think its way overrated.

lol that you still don't get that thats your opinion is beyond me

"tacked on online only coop that is .. tacked on,"

the coop can also be played splitscreen offline

what criteria must a game have in your opinion that makes it a 10?

does your criteria absolutely have to be a part of a game for it to be enjoyable?



Cirio on 24 October 2011
non-gravity said:
but but is it better than Mass Effect 2?

Nothing but Mass Effect 3 can be better than Mass Effect 2. But Uncharted 2+3 are 3rd best :P



PullusPardus on 24 October 2011
o_O.Q said:
PullusPardus said:
mantlepiecek said:
I am tired of people saying uncharted should be open....why the hell do you want a fallcharted?


Why the fuck people are taking my comment as if "its not fallout 3" where did i said that ever?

i don't want Uncharted to be open, but be less scripted, and has to have some replay value, you know for example , unlocking new game modes once you finish the game,

EXAMPLE time trial mode, coop mode (split screen in the single player), Fortune hunter mode (where you earn point for every chain kill without being hit), or a boss rush mode, alternative cutscenes, bloopers, multiple endings, or something more original like for example Bare Knuckles mode where you and your enemies don't carry any weapons and all of you are just using fists, THATS an example.

what we got is, linear single player with scripted scenes , and "Cinematic" cliches IE lots of explosions and retarded "bad guys" ,  lame collectables that are only collected for trophies, tacked on online only coop that is .. tacked on, using single player "Maps" with generic cutscenes, competitive multiplayer (which is actually good) unlockable skins and the "oh so amazing" black and white/Mirror...ect effects, and thats about it folks.

now tell me, how on earth does that deserve a 10 / 10 ? , this game seems no different from say Army Of Two, heck even that game has coop and actually focused on the "Fun" part of game, i say its also very similar to Alan Wake, very scripted, very focused on graphics , has very lame collectables , and thats it.

By the way i'm not saying this game is crap nor alan wake is (actually alan wake is one of my favs on xbox), i actually ENJOY uncharted games  , i'm just saying its not the best thing ever and not really a 10/10 , i think its way overrated.

lol that you still don't get that thats your opinion is beyond me

"tacked on online only coop that is .. tacked on,"

the coop can also be played splitscreen offline

what criteria must a game have in your opinion that makes it a 10?

does your criteria absolutely have to be a part of a game for it to be enjoyable?


Re-read the post i posted, for goodness sake, bolded some stuff, so you can see them better.

also of course its my opinion what did you expect? someone forcing me at gun point to post this ?