:D first day buy!

whether you like uncharted or not isn't what i asked you... so a game must have coop with maps/scenarios unrelated to its single player to be a 10? wow thats a really narrow list then or did i misunderstand you

the reason why i was saying its your opinion is that you seem to expect reviewers to rate a game according to your standards

Please, stop this thing you are doing , and read the post, i actually mean't the exact opposite of what you said, and yes, if a reviewer said a game is 10/10 it should live up to that standard, why the hell not?

i'm sorry if i offended you ionly you asked you about what you said to get a better understanding of why uc doesn't deserve a 10

"time trial mode, coop mode (split screen in the single player), Fortune hunter mode (where you earn point for every chain kill without being hit), or a boss rush mode, alternative cutscenes, bloopers, multiple endings, or something more original like for example Bare Knuckles mode where you and your enemies don't carry any weapons and all of you are just using fists, THATS an example."

ok so a game should have time trial modes, split screen coop campaign, alternative story paths, multiple endings, variable challenge modes etc for it to deserve a 10?

No to have a replay value, now i am done here.

A game doesn't need a lot of replay value to be a 10, Uncharted 3 has more than enough replay value to qualify for a 10 anyway.

isn't online/offline competitive + coop multiplayer + treasure hunting + varying difficulty modes replay value?

Not according to pulluspardus :S

But his opinion should be ignored because he's the same person that called Fist of the North Star a great game. You know, that vile, dreadful, disgusting, clunky, repetitive game with shallow combat and horrific framerate & visuals. I don't know how anyone can enjoy this POS game. It makes me weep that people actually enjoy this mediocrity. It also makes me weep that players continue to support NIS when they just rehash the same stuff over and over again, but that is for another time.

Now on to more important matters, it should be no surprise to anyone that Uncharted 3 received a score such as this. Naughty Dog raises and sets the boundaries for quality gaming, and it looks they done it once again with Uncharted 3. Uncharted is the epitome of quality gaming because only Uncharted 3 gives gamers a compelling cinematic gaming experience unlike MGS4. MGS4 was just a movie with a few gameplay sections here and there, but Uncharted 3 seamlessly blends cutscenes and gameplay to create an unforgettable single-player experience. Not only that, but U3 also offers a fun co-op experience with a solid, competitive multiplayer.

If you can only buy one game this holiday season, well ask your parents for more money or get a $60 loan and buy Batman and Uncharted 3 because these games warrant your time and money. These games are the best games this year has to offer. Hell, these two games are two of the best this gen has to offer, and say no to mediocrity. Now hit my music.

i respect his opinion its just that i was trying to better understand what he mean't

anyway i agree but the sad thing for me is that my ps3 has been broken for a while so i won't be playing this too soon but i'll be sure to pick up a uc3 ps3 bundle before the year is out 

Well if we are really bringing other games in this thread, then MGS4 > Uncharted > >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> x 1000 >>>>> Mass effect

..

lol I kid.

But imo Uncharted 2 > ME 2.