By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - GTA6 reviews thread. Opencritic- 98 / Metacritic - 99

 

GTA6's release has me...

Hyped 9 14.75%
 
Excited 6 9.84%
 
Feeling meh 11 18.03%
 
Hesitant 4 6.56%
 
No feels at all 26 42.62%
 
Repulsed 5 8.20%
 
Total:61

This site has a high concentration of Nintendo fans and lovers of Japanese games; I think that explains why GTA doesn't generate much buzz here.



Around the Network

Never been big into GTA in the first place. I had considered getting it at first, but once it was announced it would be digital-only, my interest dropped from mild to nonexistent.



Visit http://shadowofthevoid.wordpress.com

Art by Hunter B

In accordance to the VGC forum rules, §8.5, I hereby exercise my right to demand to be left alone regarding the subject of the effects of the pandemic on video game sales (i.e., "COVID bump").

GTA is a strange series. Despite every game being massively critically acclaimed none of them hold up particularly well. I admire a lot of things in the series, especially the ps2 entries, but I don't think amy of the games are particularly great.
Saying that, I am still looking forward to the new entry.



There's some word of early reviews going around. They are very positive. I think it's safe to say the game isn't bombing critically at this point.

Last edited by Eric2048 - 2 days ago

Mano777 said:

This site has a high concentration of Nintendo fans and lovers of Japanese games; I think that explains why GTA doesn't generate much buzz here.

No it's cause we're all pissed the game didn't get a 60 fps option , 40 fps balanced, not even on the pro. We all know why and the greed tactics of take 2. Theyre going to milk this game as much as they csn and get as much sales as they can.  They're intentionally holding back for the eventual re release, gta6 enhanced for next gen, where the ,60 fps will be thrown in to get another 20 million sales. Now comes the defenders " oh but it's cpu bound....' bla bla



Around the Network
KratosLives said:
Mano777 said:

This site has a high concentration of Nintendo fans and lovers of Japanese games; I think that explains why GTA doesn't generate much buzz here.

No it's cause we're all pissed the game didn't get a 60 fps option , 40 fps balanced, not even on the pro. We all know why and the greed tactics of take 2. Theyre going to milk this game as much as they csn and get as much sales as they can.  They're intentionally holding back for the eventual re release, gta6 enhanced for next gen, where the ,60 fps will be thrown in to get another 20 million sales. Now comes the defenders " oh but it's cpu bound....' bla bla

40 is an expectation on pro yes, but 60? Look at the details they are putting in, the crowds, the simulation stuff. Do you want it to look like Cyberpunk launch at 60 or in their eyes, I'm sure as they see it, the game they made looking well. Even at 40, they'd have to cut a lot. I'm not defending them but I've seen enough ambitious releases to know they made the right decision so long as the have a smooth, locked 30 that they are working with. I find the worst "30fps" are in game with a choice between 30 and 60 like the devs don't care. Let's see in a 84 hours. If it's smooth, great. If it's enough to screw the camera I'll eat my words... hell, everyone remembers Vice city on PS2, that was rough as they come but somehow they made it work at the time and after a while you barely noticed the whole game is like Tommy being under the influence of something. 



LegitHyperbole said:
KratosLives said:

No it's cause we're all pissed the game didn't get a 60 fps option , 40 fps balanced, not even on the pro. We all know why and the greed tactics of take 2. Theyre going to milk this game as much as they csn and get as much sales as they can.  They're intentionally holding back for the eventual re release, gta6 enhanced for next gen, where the ,60 fps will be thrown in to get another 20 million sales. Now comes the defenders " oh but it's cpu bound....' bla bla

40 is an expectation on pro yes, but 60? Look at the details they are putting in, the crowds, the simulation stuff. Do you want it to look like Cyberpunk launch at 60 or in their eyes, I'm sure as they see it, the game they made looking well. Even at 40, they'd have to cut a lot. I'm not defending them but I've seen enough ambitious releases to know they made the right decision so long as the have a smooth, locked 30 that they are working with. I find the worst "30fps" are in game with a choice between 30 and 60 like the devs don't care. Let's see in a 84 hours. If it's smooth, great. If it's enough to screw the camera I'll eat my words... hell, everyone remembers Vice city on PS2, that was rough as they come but somehow they made it work at the time and after a while you barely noticed the whole game is like Tommy being under the influence of something. 

I'm being serious here, but everything ive seen so far is what i expected on a ps4 made gta. We were denied a last gen title, but the spec jump on ps4 from ps3, is in line with what was made from gta5 on ps3 to the reveal gameplay of gta6. Minus the ray tracing and 1440 resolution. So texture detail, npc number jump, draw distance. If this trailer came out in 2019/2020, no one would be saying this is impossible. 

So on ps5, i expect this to run 60.  On last gen you can pause and find  games on par texture wise.   On ps5 there are games with better character model details. But as an open world game, with those npc models, it would work with 60 fps. 

Whether they hit 30 fps or not is because theyve opted to leave it at 1440p native with ray tracing, which is a gpu hog combined.



KratosLives said:
LegitHyperbole said:

40 is an expectation on pro yes, but 60? Look at the details they are putting in, the crowds, the simulation stuff. Do you want it to look like Cyberpunk launch at 60 or in their eyes, I'm sure as they see it, the game they made looking well. Even at 40, they'd have to cut a lot. I'm not defending them but I've seen enough ambitious releases to know they made the right decision so long as the have a smooth, locked 30 that they are working with. I find the worst "30fps" are in game with a choice between 30 and 60 like the devs don't care. Let's see in a 84 hours. If it's smooth, great. If it's enough to screw the camera I'll eat my words... hell, everyone remembers Vice city on PS2, that was rough as they come but somehow they made it work at the time and after a while you barely noticed the whole game is like Tommy being under the influence of something. 

I'm being serious here, but everything ive seen so far is what i expected on a ps4 made gta. We were denied a last gen title, but the spec jump on ps4 from ps3, is in line with what was made from gta5 on ps3 to the reveal gameplay of gta6. Minus the ray tracing and 1440 resolution. So texture detail, npc number jump, draw distance. If this trailer came out in 2019/2020, no one would be saying this is impossible. 

So on ps5, i expect this to run 60.  On last gen you can pause and find  games on par texture wise.   On ps5 there are games with better character model details. But as an open world game, with those npc models, it would work with 60 fps. 

Whether they hit 30 fps or not is because theyve opted to leave it at 1440p native with ray tracing, which is a gpu hog combined.

Nah, there's no way this game is running at 60fps with hundreds of npc on the screen at once all with physics simulation at this graphical fidelity and with that draw distance.

Besides the devs said they tried to get it running at 60fps but couldn't because of the cpu which the PS5 Pro shares with the base PS5.



pikashoe said:

GTA is a strange series. Despite every game being massively critically acclaimed none of them hold up particularly well. I admire a lot of things in the series, especially the ps2 entries, but I don't think amy of the games are particularly great.
Saying that, I am still looking forward to the new entry.

Well if we're talking open-world games in the early 2000's GTA was the go-to for most people playing on consoles. It's easy to look back on those games now and laugh but as a kid growing up with the PS2 there was nothing else like them. GTA was the game you tried to sneak past your parents to play.

San Andreas was especially fun. I remember just spending hours using cheat codes to manipulate the game world. I'm trying to think of games that let you cause chaos in an open-world setting like gta did back then. 

The only game that comes to mind is Morrowind but that was rpg and more of a PC centric game, but it was a lot more slower paced and gameplay was more punishing.



Eric2048 said:
pikashoe said:

GTA is a strange series. Despite every game being massively critically acclaimed none of them hold up particularly well. I admire a lot of things in the series, especially the ps2 entries, but I don't think amy of the games are particularly great.
Saying that, I am still looking forward to the new entry.

Well if we're talking open-world games in the early 2000's GTA was the go-to for most people playing on consoles. It's easy to look back on those games now and laugh but as a kid growing up with the PS2 there was nothing else like them. GTA was the game you tried to sneak past your parents to play.

San Andreas was especially fun. I remember just spending hours using cheat codes to manipulate the game world. I'm trying to think of games that let you cause chaos in an open-world setting like gta did back then. 

The only game that comes to mind is Morrowind but that was rpg and more of a PC centric game, but it was a lot more slower paced and gameplay was more punishing.

Ha yeah spawning tanks through cheat codes and shooting backwards for propulsion was awesome :)

GTA 3 was magical when it came out. I just parked on the top of the parking garage to watch the day/night cycle while listening to the radio.
San Andreas' map was unbelievably big at the time. 

RDR2 wasn't particularly great either, but a hell of a lot of fun to explore and cause chaos. (missions mostly sucked)