By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sales Discussion - Will Switch outsell DS? PS2? Or Neither? (March 2024 Update Poll)

 

Will Switch outsell DS and/or PS2? or neither?

Switch will outsell both the DS & PS2 81 63.78%
 
Switch will outsell the DS, but not PS2 24 18.90%
 
Switch won't outsell DS or PS2 22 17.32%
 
Total:127
Shtinamin_ said:

Switch shipped goes rather parallel with the amount sold. Personally, Ive been following the sold amount and adding the totals to the shipped numbers. And they have been very spot on with errors ranging from tens of thousands to 1.2M. But it has never sold more than shipped. (Though we might be seeing that this year)
Since Nintendo said the Switch shipped 139.36M units in Dec 31, 2023. The Switch as of Apr 29, 2024 data (which does not include March Circana or March worldwide, but does include Famitsu 7-21) the Switch sold an additional 2,395,216 units. So the Switch has shipped a minimum of 141,755,216 units. Not counting the Famitsu 7-21, the Switch has shipped a minimum of 141,619,662.

Let's make an assumption that Circana has Switch selling -20% what they sold in Mar 2023, giving us an estimate of 313,662 units. And worldwide would be just around 828,436 give or take a couple ten thousand.

Switch should have around 141.96M units shipped by Mar 31, 2024. I hope they announce it has surpasses 142M in their annual report.


Nintendo will either put they FY at either 10M or 12M (both are very possible outcomes, 10M would be rather easy for them unless their holiday is lackluster). Ill use 12M because I believe that would be achievable.
So by March 31, 2025 Nintendo will have shipped 153M Switch units. They will only need to sell 7M units to surpass the supposed and unreliable PS2 number provided by Jim Ryan.
I personally think it will sell 162.36M by the time the Switch is removed from the shelves. Meaning by March 31, 2025 the Switch would have to sell an additional 9.36M which can be achieved in 2027 (6M in FY2026, and 3.36M in FY 2027 or something along those lines).

I have my prediction at 160M for now as the hard line for it will reach that.

165M would be amazing!

Wow, someone actually who did the math! Would u mind sharing your predictions by quarter and region breakdown through Q1 2025 if possible?



Around the Network

It will take some time but I think eventually Switch will outsell them both. Switch has it over the PS2 in a way by being a console multiple people per household often own. The hybrid console feature also gives it extra value/appeal.

And as far as the DS, its library has even surpassed that console's library at this point. Plus, even when Switch 2 comes out, the original Switch will likely continue to sell for a least a couple more years on account of its (relatively) lower pricepoint and established library. 



 

"We hold these truths to be self-evident - all men and women created by the, go-you know.. you know the thing!" - Joe Biden

CheddarPlease said:
Shtinamin_ said:

Switch shipped goes rather parallel with the amount sold. Personally, Ive been following the sold amount and adding the totals to the shipped numbers. And they have been very spot on with errors ranging from tens of thousands to 1.2M. But it has never sold more than shipped. (Though we might be seeing that this year)
Since Nintendo said the Switch shipped 139.36M units in Dec 31, 2023. The Switch as of Apr 29, 2024 data (which does not include March Circana or March worldwide, but does include Famitsu 7-21) the Switch sold an additional 2,395,216 units. So the Switch has shipped a minimum of 141,755,216 units. Not counting the Famitsu 7-21, the Switch has shipped a minimum of 141,619,662.

Let's make an assumption that Circana has Switch selling -20% what they sold in Mar 2023, giving us an estimate of 313,662 units. And worldwide would be just around 828,436 give or take a couple ten thousand.

Switch should have around 141.96M units shipped by Mar 31, 2024. I hope they announce it has surpasses 142M in their annual report.


Nintendo will either put they FY at either 10M or 12M (both are very possible outcomes, 10M would be rather easy for them unless their holiday is lackluster). Ill use 12M because I believe that would be achievable.
So by March 31, 2025 Nintendo will have shipped 153M Switch units. They will only need to sell 7M units to surpass the supposed and unreliable PS2 number provided by Jim Ryan.
I personally think it will sell 162.36M by the time the Switch is removed from the shelves. Meaning by March 31, 2025 the Switch would have to sell an additional 9.36M which can be achieved in 2027 (6M in FY2026, and 3.36M in FY 2027 or something along those lines).

I have my prediction at 160M for now as the hard line for it will reach that.

165M would be amazing!

Wow, someone actually who did the math! Would u mind sharing your predictions by quarter and region breakdown through Q1 2025 if possible?

Sorry for the delay I figured that the Americas information would arrive on Wed May 1, hence why I waited. I'll probably update it once the Worldwide is released and when the official Nintendo report is out too.

And yes, I would love to.
if I ever say sells, it means that it sold, and Nintendo is replacing it with a shipped unit. 1 unit sold = 1 unit shipped

Q4 2023: As of now we are at 2,533,431 units sold (not including Worldwide March in which I will provide a shortened version of this by Friday). I assume though that this month of march will reach around 860k, giving the RotW ~100k (putting Q1 at 2.63M a -14% drop YoY) So that would put the Switch at ~141.99M. (RotW guestimate from last post might seem low, I had it at 28k, but now I'm thinking it'll be closer to 100k which I based off of the downhill from Jan RotW and Feb RotW). Nintendo will probably announce 142M with either 10M or 12M as their next FY goal on May 7th. (I'm going with 12M since it is around a -30% decrease YoY, it is -27%.)

Q1 2024: I'm gonna look at software that is being released. Nintendo releases Endless Ocean: Luminous, Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door (2024), Luigi's Mansion 2 HD. I think TTYD will be the huge summer hit. Sales in Japan are looking amazing, and we haven't seen the Golden Week sales yet. As of May 1st 2024, we have info on Japan April 7-21 sales at 135,554, and has 2 weeks left in April, so it is on par to match it's March sales (which are at 299k). I expect around 300k for Japan in April. April WW should be around 1M (Americas 380k, EU 230k, Japan 300k, RotW 130k). WW May should also be ~1M (Americas 400k, EU 240k, Japan 280k, RotW 130k). and June will be near 1M as well (Americas 380k, EU 220k, Japan 270k, RotW 90k. Meaning Q1 should ship around 3.05M. Putting the Switch at 145.04M (using the 141.99M from my guestimate of Q4).

Q2 2024: Here is were things get tricky. We dont know what games are coming out so we can really only go off of past Q2 numbers and speculate the YoY drop. Q2 2023 gave us 2.94M at a -9% decrease. Personally, I think this years will be a bit lower than that considering that we do not have any information for the second half of the year. I'll put the decline at -25%, giving us ~2.21M(rounded up). July will be the better selling month nearing 745k, August will slow up to 720k, and September will ramp up a bit at 740k. Bringing the Switch to 147.25M.

Q3 2024: We will do the same thing as Q2 guestimate. Q3 2023 gave us 6.9M at a -16% decrease. But before I set my decline, I think Nintendo will announce their successor on I will set this decline at around -30% giving us 4.83M. Until more information arrives this will be the hard floor. October will be the weakest month at 750k. November will bring us back up to 1.43M and December at 2.65M. Bringing the Switch to 152.08M.

Q4 2024: The successor has been released if rumors stay true. I believe it will launch near the same timeframe the Switch was given, near March 6th 2025. And we will start to see major declines ranging from -40% to -60%. The Switch families prices will have a permanent drop of a range from $50-$100. $50 seems to be the more likely scenario. I expect near a -30% decline overall this quarter reaching ~1.91M. January will be the highest at 820k, February at 640k, March at 450k (will be affected the most and will see a -50% YoY). Bringing the Switch to 153.99M. Just barely reaching their 12M mark. And will set their new goal to 25M (18M for the successor and 7M for the Switch, which is a -42% decrease YoY).

Q1 2025: I believe that with the end of March 31, 2025 they will stop producing Switch units but will continue to produce and ship Switch Lite and Switch OLED in order to keep SKU's low. Switch will still be receiving Nintendo published games and I expect a -50% YoY at ~1.53M. Bringing the Switch to 155.52M. Surpassing the Nintendo DS, becoming #2 All-Time. And for the future it will go on to reach its 7M goal by March 31, 2026 reaching 160.99M. And eventually ending sometime at 162.36M.

I will provide a "sparksnotes" verison once the Worldwide is released and the official Nintendo report is released. And I will make any necessary changes based on new information.

@CheddarPlease I hope this was what you were looking for. Any feedback is appreciated. :)



Lifetime Sales Predictions 

Switch: 160 million (was 120 million, then 140 million, then 150 million)

PS5: 130 million (was 124 million)

Xbox Series X/S: 54 million (was 60 million, then 57 million)

"The way to accomplish great things, is to be indefatigable and never rest till the thing is accomplished." - Joseph Smith Jr.

Lovely! I appreciate the thorough write-up, this is exactly what this forum needs more of :)

I will say, based on NA sales thus far, those figures do look a tad bit optimistic, but I haven't been too clued into the market as of late, so correct me if I'm wrong, but it does seem like NA has been selling only slightly ahead of Japan, and I'm not sure the likelihood that sales will pick up into the summer, but I do think it is well within the range of possibility

Last edited by CheddarPlease - on 02 May 2024

CheddarPlease said:

Lovely! I appreciate the thorough write-up, this is exactly what this forum needs more of :)

I will say, based on NA sales thus far, those figures do look a tad bit optimistic, but I haven't been too clued into the market as of late, so correct me if I'm wrong, but it does seem like NA has been selling only slightly ahead of Japan, and I'm not sure the likelihood that sales will pick up into the summer, but I do think it is well within the range of possibility

@CheddarPlease Thank you, I enjoyed doing this. So I'm glad you liked it.

NA sales have been getting lower but they have always been relatively close to Japan's numbers. Also I was using Americas, not NA. Americas includes North and South America, and South America and Mexico will become a bigger market in the next year and after. I would love to see a rundown for your 165M estimate. :)



Spark Notes version.

Sold is very parallel to shipped, so for simplicity sold=shipped.

Q4 2023: I predicted 2.63M, and was mistaken and it is in fact it was an underestimate, as far as the Worldwide March 2024 update, 2,718,604 units sold. Switch is at 142.08M for shipped. In 6 days, Nintendo releases their Fiscal Year Report, and I predict 12M as their hardware goal.

Q1 2024: Based on the constant lineup of games (at least one major Nintendo game a month) and Japan carrying the Switch, with their Golden Week sales too Q1 should ship around 3.05M. Putting the Switch at 145.13M.

Q2 2024: This is one of the weakest of the quarters for the past three years, and I expect that trend to continue. Q2 will ship 2.21M, bringing the Switch to 147.34M.

Q3 2024: I am being a bit pessimistic given that we have ZERO information regarding the lineup of games Nintendo has planned for the second half of 2024. Q3 will be around 4.83M, bringing the Switch to 152.17M. Japan will have surpassed Europe in sales.

Q4 2024: Successor is released in the last month, but will still take many sales away from the Switch. Nintendo should sell 1.91M units, bringing the Switch to 154.08M. Just barely reaching their 12M mark. And will set their new goal to 25M (18M for the successor and 7M for the Switch). Nintendo will announce that they have surpassed the Nintendo DS, making Switch the #2 All-Time best selling console.

Q1 2025: OG Switch consoles are no longer in production, but Switch Lite and Switch OLED are still raking in the dough, and will continue to be produced and shipped, especially with their new price cuts. Nintendo will sell 1.53M units, bringing the Switch to 155.61M.And for the future it will go on to reach its 7M goal by March 31, 2026 reaching 161.08M. And eventually ending sometime at 162.36M. And it may even sell more depending on how long they are willing to keep it.



Lifetime Sales Predictions 

Switch: 160 million (was 120 million, then 140 million, then 150 million)

PS5: 130 million (was 124 million)

Xbox Series X/S: 54 million (was 60 million, then 57 million)

"The way to accomplish great things, is to be indefatigable and never rest till the thing is accomplished." - Joseph Smith Jr.

Around the Network

Surprised so many believe it wont even outsell the DS with the successor not even announced. I'd say DS numbers is the absolute worst-case at this point. It will do it even without a price cut.



Shtinamin_ said:

@CheddarPlease Thank you, I enjoyed doing this. So I'm glad you liked it.

I would love to see a rundown for your 165M estimate. :)

@Shtinamin_ Here it is! (keep in mind I prefer rounding to quarters of a million to account for uncertainty)

I actually have mine at just over about 161m, though I prefer to ever-so-slightly sandbag my numbers to make sure I don't overshoot too far since my goal baseline is still 160m.

Q4 FY2023: my prediction originally was a conservative 2.25m, but in light of strong Japan sales I raised it to 2.50m, which I'm keeping for the sake of consistency, even if sales are showing slightly more atm. Total through March 31 should be at least 141.86m, with a roughly 35/30/25/10 split between AM/JP/EUR/Other. Nintendo will probably shoot for a 10-11m fiscal year for Switch alone, maybe 14m if they decide to tease Switch 2 by the end of the fiscal year, but I assume they will aim for a more conservative target as they did last year. If the sales target is above 11m for Switch 1, 160m would be close to a lock, but 10-11m means that chances would still be around 66-75%.

Q1 FY2024: As in your case, a strong release calendar should keep sales elevated, even with Switch 2 around the corner. In keeping with my more conservative estimates I project sales of 2.75m. Sales will remain strong in Japan, but weaker platform sales in NA and Europe will probably keep overall totals below 2023 levels. Sales in the US may increase during this time, but this is where I believe the greatest uncertainty lies. Total through June 31 is 144.61m

Q2 FY2024: As @RolStoppable has been predicting, I expect new games to be announced for this quarter, due to the tight release schedule in the summer implying Nintendo has additional releases to plug the gap. MP4 will probably be announced for H2 2024 during a summer direct IMO. Nonetheless, this would probably come in time for a Switch 2 unveil, which would probably result in a slight sales depression regardless of lineup. This is where estimate ranges begin to diverge (I could see as high as 2.5m this quarter). As my predictions are meant to be a least-case scenario for reaching 160m, I will go with a soft case of 2.25m, though I must reiterate that the announcement of a successor would probably do more to dampen sales than weak release calendar (which I do not believe will be the case). Total through September 31 is 146.86m.

Q3 FY2024: This will be the first quarter with extensive bundles and discounts due to Nintendo wanting to clear out stock before Switch 2. I agree with your prediction that base SKU will be discontinued and OLED model cut in price. I expect the base model to go down to $250m, with the Lite and OLED remaining unchanged besides for more aggressive bundling due to Nintendo's rapid discontinuation of the base model. Sales overall will depend on the presence of a strong holiday title, hopefully being MP4, which will dictate overall sales momentum, as will the extent of discounts and bundles. The range here is very high, between 4.5-6m depending on if the holiday is more similar to 3DS 2016, Switch 2023, or Wii 2010. Once again targeting the lower end, I predict sales of 4.75m. Total through September 31 is 151.61m. Calendar year 2023 shipments by territory would be ~4.35m for the Americas (with a large portion of that coming from holiday promotions), ~3.1m for Japan, with a slightly bigger but still practically nonexistent holiday bump a la 2023, ~2.6m for Europe, with poor sales only slightly compensated by holiday bundles, and ~2m for other territories, in line with previous year trends. Total breakdown by territory is 58.25m/36.5m/38.75m/18m

Q4 FY2024: Sales will continue to decline in the wake of Switch 2 release in ~Mar 2025, with sales slipping in March 2025 especially: 1.75m. Most interesting and critical projection is sales expectation for 2025. I predict 18m for Switch 2, on par with the Wii's initial sales trajectory, but less sure for the original Switch. As much as I would like to see 7m sales for this year, 3DS only managed 6m on the back of a new and popular model revision (2DSXL) and continued exclusives such as a Pokemon game revision that year, which Switch will lack due to Switch 2 being almost certainly being backward-compatible. Total through March 31, 2025 is 153.36m.

Outlook for FY 2025 will be just under 6m, with sales being tilted strongly towards holiday sales to clear inventory. Total through March 31, 2026 is 159.11m. However, while I predict sales in 2025 to be below your 6m target, I do believe that Nintendo will continue to sell the Switch through 2027. For context, the 3DS still sold an additional 3.5m post-2017. As such I predict Switch will sell an additional 2.5m before its discontinuation, for a final total of 161.61m. Final regional breakdown: 62m in North America, 39m in Japan, 41m in Europe, and 19.5m in other territories. 

Spoiler!
Keep in mind, these number are as conservative as they can get while still projecting for above 160m in sales. With your numbers through 2026, I would expect final sales of over 165m. Assuming the latter half of this year is stronger than it currently looks and that Switch continues to get software support even after its replacement a la the PS4, we could conceivably see a high-end breakdown like this:
2.75m Q4 FY2023 - 142.11m Total (16.5m for FY2023)
3.10m Q1 FY2024 - 145.21m Total 
2.50m Q2 FY2024 - 147.71m Total 
5.50m Q3 FY2024 - 153.21m Total 
2.00m Q4 FY2024 - 155.21m Total (13.1m for FY2024)
7.50m      FY2025 - 162.71m Total
3.00m   2026-End - 165.71m FINAL




Last edited by CheddarPlease - on 04 May 2024

CheddarPlease said:
Shtinamin_ said:

@CheddarPlease Thank you, I enjoyed doing this. So I'm glad you liked it.

I would love to see a rundown for your 165M estimate. :)

@Shtinamin_ Here it is! (keep in mind I prefer rounding to quarters of a million to account for uncertainty)

I actually have mine at just over about 161m, though I prefer to ever-so-slightly sandbag my numbers to make sure I don't overshoot too far since my goal baseline is still 160m.

Q4 FY2023: my prediction originally was a conservative 2.25m, but in light of strong Japan sales I raised it to 2.50m, which I'm keeping for the sake of consistency, even if sales are showing slightly more atm. Total through March 31 should be at least 141.86m, with a roughly 35/30/25/10 split between AM/JP/EUR/Other. Nintendo will probably shoot for a 10-11m fiscal year for Switch alone, maybe 14m if they decide to tease Switch 2 by the end of the fiscal year, but I assume they will aim for a more conservative target as they did last year. If the sales target is above 11m for Switch 1, 160m would be close to a lock, but 10-11m means that chances would still be around 66-75%.

Q1 FY2024: As in your case, a strong release calendar should keep sales elevated, even with Switch 2 around the corner. In keeping with my more conservative estimates I project sales of 2.75m. Sales will remain strong in Japan, but weaker platform sales in NA and Europe will probably keep overall totals below 2023 levels. Sales in the US may increase during this time, but this is where I believe the greatest uncertainty lies. Total through June 31 is 144.61m

Q2 FY2024: As @RolStoppable has been predicting, I expect new games to be announced for this quarter, due to the tight release schedule in the summer implying Nintendo has additional releases to plug the gap. MP4 will probably be announced for H2 2024 during a summer direct IMO. Nonetheless, this would probably come in time for a Switch 2 unveil, which would probably result in a slight sales depression regardless of lineup. This is where estimate ranges begin to diverge (I could see as high as 2.5m this quarter). As my predictions are meant to be a least-case scenario for reaching 160m, I will go with a soft case of 2.25m, though I must reiterate that the announcement of a successor would probably do more to dampen sales than weak release calendar (which I do not believe will be the case). Total through September 31 is 146.86m.

Q3 FY2024: This will be the first quarter with extensive bundles and discounts due to Nintendo wanting to clear out stock before Switch 2. I agree with your prediction that base SKU will be discontinued and OLED model cut in price. I expect the base model to go down to $250m, with the Lite and OLED remaining unchanged besides for more aggressive bundling due to Nintendo's rapid discontinuation of the base model. Sales overall will depend on the presence of a strong holiday title, hopefully being MP4, which will dictate overall sales momentum, as will the extent of discounts and bundles. The range here is very high, between 4.5-6m depending on if the holiday is more similar to 3DS 2016, Switch 2023, or Wii 2010. Once again targeting the lower end, I predict sales of 4.75m. Total through September 31 is 151.61m. Calendar year 2023 shipments by territory would be ~4.35m for the Americas (with a large portion of that coming from holiday promotions), ~3.1m for Japan, with a slightly bigger but still practically nonexistent holiday bump a la 2023, ~2.6m for Europe, with poor sales only slightly compensated by holiday bundles, and ~2m for other territories, in line with previous year trends. Total breakdown by territory is 58.25m/36.5m/38.75m/18m

Q4 FY2024: Sales will continue to decline in the wake of Switch 2 release in ~Mar 2025, with sales slipping in March 2025 especially: 1.75m. Most interesting and critical projection is sales expectation for 2025. I predict 18m for Switch 2, on par with the Wii's initial sales trajectory, but less sure for the original Switch. As much as I would like to see 7m sales for this year, 3DS only managed 6m on the back of a new and popular model revision (2DSXL) and continued exclusives such as a Pokemon game revision that year, which Switch will lack due to Switch 2 being almost certainly being backward-compatible. Total through March 31, 2025 is 153.36m.

Outlook for FY 2025 will be just under 6m, with sales being tilted strongly towards holiday sales to clear inventory. Total through March 31, 2026 is 159.11m. However, while I predict sales in 2025 to be below your 6m target, I do believe that Nintendo will continue to sell the Switch through 2027. For context, the 3DS still sold an additional 3.5m post-2017. As such I predict Switch will sell an additional 2.5m before its discontinuation, for a final total of 161.61m. Final regional breakdown: 62m in North America, 39m in Japan, 41m in Europe, and 19.5m in other territories. 

Spoiler!
Keep in mind, these number are as conservative as they can get while still projecting for above 160m in sales. With your numbers through 2026, I would expect final sales of over 165m. Assuming the latter half of this year is stronger than it currently looks and that Switch continues to get software support even after its replacement a la the PS4, we could conceivably see a high-end breakdown like this:
2.75m Q4 FY2023 - 142.11m Total (16.5m for FY2023)
3.10m Q1 FY2024 - 145.21m Total 
2.50m Q2 FY2024 - 147.71m Total 
5.50m Q3 FY2024 - 153.21m Total 
2.00m Q4 FY2024 - 155.21m Total (13.1m for FY2024)
7.50m      FY2025 - 162.71m Total
3.00m   2026-End - 165.71m FINAL



I love the final regional breakdown! The Q4 FY2023 needs to be reworked given that the sales have already gone passed your conservative prediction, unless you think that they won't shipped enough to replaced those that were sold in stores. And I believe that Japan sales will continue the trend of selling higher number of units than in Europe each month as it has been doing for a while now. Personally, I disagree with Europe numbers being higher than Japan's. May I ask why you think Europe's numbers will sell higher than Japan's? (at least for the Q4 2023, and I assume Q1 and Q2 2024

I will say that I totally forgot to account for the release of the successor to be included in the FY goal. So I will raise it to 15M (12M Switch, 3M Successor).

I do think it is interesting to think when they will announce the successor. So you think they will announce it in their June Nintendo Direct? Personally I think they can easily announce it in November this year and still have a huge turnaround, while not affecting sales as much.

I think that MP4 will be the Holiday game for the year, I choose the holiday because idk what they have planned, and it just feels good.
And yeah I didn't necessarily think about getting the base Switch out faster in order to stop production on it. Solid thinking! I have to go over it again and make an edit or two after the Year Report.

I do think that Legends Z-A will be a Switch title, and will release near February 2025. And I do think that the Successor will take a lot of sales away, it will only do so for the month of March. January is a solid selling month, especially with Japan's New Year deals.

I think that Japan's total might be a bit closer to Europe's by the time the Switch family is completely discontinued.

I think the 165M can be a reality, but I think Nintendo will want to abandon the Switch fast, about 2 years. And the software releases will essentially end by the time the successor releases, maybe add in one year just in case. And because I think that at the moment, the sales will mostly plummet after March 31, 2026. Like near 70%-80%. Hence why the ~1.28M more from my estimate of the numbers once March 31, 2026 happens.

I enjoyed reading your breakdown of your conservative and your truly expected estimations. The numbers on your truly expected are rather close to mine, the only difference is 2026 and onwards. I can't wait to see the report. Thank you!



Lifetime Sales Predictions 

Switch: 160 million (was 120 million, then 140 million, then 150 million)

PS5: 130 million (was 124 million)

Xbox Series X/S: 54 million (was 60 million, then 57 million)

"The way to accomplish great things, is to be indefatigable and never rest till the thing is accomplished." - Joseph Smith Jr.

Shadow1980 said:
RolStoppable said:

(...)

Switch is on pace to exceed Nintendo's projected 141.1m LTD mark by March 2024 and they'll likely forecast a figure of ~11m units for the fiscal year ending March 2025, because Switch's successor will hardly have an impact in the upcoming fiscal year. That's a decline of ~30% after FY23 declined by only ~15%. That will put Switch's LTD by March 2025 at 152m; the DS's lifetime figure stands at 154.02m. An additional mere 2m after an 11m year aren't a challenge, so I don't need to go into detail for each region. Try to run a shipment forecast for yourself and you should realize how hard it is to keep Switch below the DS in lifetime sales.

(...)

You and I clearly have different opinions on how fast the Switch will decline, and we just aren't going to see eye to eye on it. Hell, I probably am wrong regarding the DS, but I'm a stubborn old goat who'd still like to see a bit of vindication after the absolutely unnecessary abuse I got on this forum back in 2020-21. So let's leave it at that, shall we? Since we're just repeating ourselves every time a thread like this pops up, this will be the last time I discuss the matter until probably well after the Switch 2 releases and dust is starting to settle. Everybody already knows where I stand on the matter, and it's a waste of time to keep re-litigating it every couple of months.

(...)

I snipped both of our posts to keep the focus on the "passing the DS or not" question.

Switch stands at 141.32m LTD shipments by March 31st 2024. Nintendo forecasts 13.5m for the fiscal year ending March 2025 which is more than I expected (see above, 11m). If this projection is met, then the DS (154.02m) will be surpassed during the end of the current fiscal year.

Only the PS2 is left. With Nintendo's forecast coming in above my expectations, I raise my previously mentioned probability for Switch outselling the PS2 from 75% to 90%.



Legend11 correctly predicted that GTA IV will outsell Super Smash Bros. Brawl. I was wrong.

So given the Nintendo report today I'm upping my estimate from 162 to 165. I was expecting a March release for Switch 2. Now I'm thinking somewhere in the May-November 2025 timeframe.