I think it is rated just how it should have been. Should have launched at $40 like Ratchet and Clank.
Even though I am an Uncharted fan, this game brought very little value in comparison. Uncharted did everything better including graphics, gameplay, story length, online play, etc. One might think comparing the 2 games is not ideal since it's ND, but I disagree since they chose to copy ND's style but in doing so brought nothing new to the table and worse for the exact same price of $60.
I fail to see how they copied UC.
I am far too lazy to explain fully, because it is probably a waste of time if you can't see it already.
But I will say that I said they copied ND's style with Uncharted, not that they copied it.
Uncharted 2 was the push Weerasuriya needed to settle upon Ready at Dawn's shot at the big time - a big budget triple-A home console exclusive of its own after years spent making high quality handheld games in the God of War series.
"We're not trying to emulate things they've done moment to moment," he says. "We're trying to give people that similar sense of entertainment."