Actually not that easy to answer, if The Order does turn out as poor as some are fearing (I'm doubting its quality myself) then it could quickly crash and burn, Bloodborne on the other hand looks to be a guaranteed quality game and I definitely see this game pulling in some Souls fans from other systems and have decent legs, I think it can reach around 2.5 million lifetime or so. It all depends on how good The Order turns out.

^So true
Anyways I think The Order will sell better overall and Bloodborne will review better. It will probably reach a low to mid 90s Meta whereas The Order will be high 70s to mid 80s.

I'm getting both so the questions for me are: which one will I like more? Will I like them both even if I prefer one over the other?

Already have both games pre-ordered on PSN. I think The Order will sell better, and be the better game, but I hope both turn out to be good and profitable.

Bloodborne because it will be much bigger in Japan

Surprising; apart from the "Both!" choice, poll is dead even between the two.

I thought most users were biased against The Order.

Edit: The poll has changed; I was right.

The Order looks more friendly to casual gamers and the masses. I'm figuring it'll sell more.

Based on VGChartz I would say that The Order 1886 will get the highest sales while Bloodborne will bring most new gamers to PS4 from PC and Xbox.

Why would you pre-order digital games? That's really like telling the developer that they get you're money regardless if the game turns out to be good or not.

No problem pre-ordering games... i'm sorry, people need to get off their high horses with the whole pre-order stuff.

If someone wants something day 1, then they can pre-order and download it ready to play as soon as it becomes available. Simples. 

Why can we not support developers, is that a problem? Is it the fact that people might like the look of a game that other people may not? I'm sorry, there is no probelm with pre-ordering a game at all.

I'm going to pre-order the Order from Amazon, because it looks like a game I want to play... why would i want to not play it on day of release. Do you not go to the cinema or watch a movie or listen to music the day the item arrives/released... or perhaps you dont watch your favourite tv show when the latest episode is on TV... cause its better to wait and see what everyone else says right.... sorry it's BS. 

I dont need some game reviewer to tell me what games I will or wont like, I dont need other people to tell me what games I will or wont like, I and others are able to make decisions based on what we see/hear. If its a game I am concerned about, I wouldnt buy it day 1... but if its something I am excited for, then i will.

So lets drop the whole pre-ordering a game is wrong situation. People have been doing it for years (hey people purchased consoles day 1 what a bunch of idiots right - no they are not).