GC controller. Just because it has analog triggers. Which the Pro controller missed on.

The GameCube one! It's simply so great!

Definitely Gamecube controller! Playing Metroid Prime or Smash Bros Melee with that controller felt sooo good...

In my opinion, best and most comfortable controller i've ever used!

From a pure comfort perspective, the GC controller.
From a utilitarian perspective, the WiiU gamepad.

Gamecube only flaw is it doesn't do so well for 2D platforms in my opinion, I didn't expect for a few people so far to say N64.

Pro controller for me. hope they'll release next year a Pro 2 with analog. :D

missed the N64 and GC generation though, so i couldn't comment on it if it is great.

Hard choice, there's a lot to be said about any of them. All have their plusses, all have their minuses.

I'd choose the N64 controller. Everything is just exactly where I want it to be on that controller.

It was rarely used, but wiimote with wii motion plus and nunchuck was pretty darn cool for skyward sword. i wish more games used that control scheme as the default.

WiiU Gamepad for me. I've played them all...never really cared for the N64 controller. SNES is nice, Gamecube is awesome, Wiimote/Nunchuck is a beautiful thing. But really...I'm hoping that Nintendo continues to support this revolutionary new controller idea in the future, just as they have done with the Wiimote/nunchuck.

All hail the Virtual Boy controller! Such double D-pad goodness.

I voted for the GC controller, though. It was just so comfortable.