I really think this is their best option now, they're not going to get hardcore/casual-core type players this gen. Casuals are gone and Nintendo can't compete against the lifestyle functionality of a smartphone/tablet + 99 cent arcade style games. Wii Sports/Fit went out of style a while ago.
Make a "Nintendo Universe" game. It doesn't even matter if it's not 100% finished by this fall, design the game so that it has different areas (Mario World, Zelda World, Kid Icarus World, Pikmin World, etc.) ... new "worlds" come online over time as new toys get released. Create an animated TV SHOW to go with the toy line for Nickeldeon or Disney Network. Basic premise: It's Subspace Emissary or the Infinity Gaunlet for the Nintendo mascot universe, some evil force is trying to destory "Nintendo Universe" or something, Nintendo heroes have to team up.
The system MUST be cheap, they have to figure out a way to bring production costs down. Either axe the Wii U tablet screen entirely (saving at least $40-$50 production cost), but *keep* the NFC chip in a new Pro Controller. OR make a much smaller Wii U controller with a smaller/cheaper screen (3.5-4 inches). The tablet as is is too big and clunky for kids anyway.
Focus on making profit on the few "heavy hitter" Nintendo IP per year + release a steady flow of high profit margin toys. Get some third parties like Sega and Capcom to allow some characters in like Sonic and Megaman.
Take aim at Skylanders/Disney Infinity and turn to push them out of the market with a better quality product + TV show. The only downside is Skylanders/DI don't require a new system to play ... so Nintendo has to get their pricing right. $249.99 w/Nintendo Universe + 3 starter figures is OK, but $199.99 would be far more ideal.











