but how would you hold down and b while the pokeball is rocking back and forth with a touch screen? Or live with yourself for buying it!

1 - We´re talking about  physical media sales. That´s what Vgcharts tracks and the thread is clear about that.

2 - The demo disc of the PS was not a game

It doesn´t matter if you accept it or not, bundled games are and will always be valid games sold.

We should lock this thread.
This is becoming nothing more than another fanboy dumb, pointless discussion.

In conclusion, without bundling their games with almost every system or controller/accessory sold, Nintendo has 6 out of 15 best selling games.

....that is, if we dont include any of the last 4 GTAs, any of the last 4 CODs or any of the last 2 Battlefield games

Its a good place to get reliable hardware sales because of consistant reports to be able to adjust accordingly (at least every three months). Its a good place to find ssales from reliable trackers such as npd and famitsu/mediacrate. So hell, if you want to stop coming here thats fine with me but i wont and ill stick with reliable information

Uh.... becoming? Thats what it started as... starting with the title. As for your other points "retail only" okay sure... if you want to cherry pick data and insert whatever bullshit criteria to suit an agenda thats fine... but at least put an astrik on it and a disclaimer at the bottom

Holy shit this is incredible.

We had another thread for this, by Khuutra, that actually did the multiplats together too. It was a looooooong time ago now and I like the idea, I might take the reigns now that the generation is coming to an end and K is no longer around.

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=111169&page=1

Kinect Adventures is undertracked.

Also, GTAV > All non bundled games, EVER.

Really, Mario Kart and the Wheel????  REALLY!  What else did people use that wheel for?  The Wii Fit balance board?  What else did they use that for?  In fact, I would argue it becomes MORE impressive when you realize what people were willing to pay for said bundle.

Imagine if Uncharted 4 came out, but in order to get the uber-sweet graphics you needed a $40 dongle that attached to your PS4.  So now the game is $100.  If that game sold well, would you argue it was "bundled"?  If the game sold poorly, would you use that as your excuse? 

Even with the Wii itself, many people bought it JUST for Wii Sports.  Think about that.  They were willing to pay 250 dollars for the Wii Sports experince.  After all, many did let the system collect dust afterwards, or sold them off.

Another point, if bundling a game is guaranteed sales, why don't Sony and Microsoft use it?  Oh wait, they do.

The bottom line is, in the past, Nintendo has been a SW giant.  Sony and Microsoft have their share of amazing IPs too.  Another fact is that Wii U is not selling as well as Nintendo hoped, but there is still hope for them to turn it around (see PS3 late sales as an example).