GTA is excluded from the list. because it comes bundled with numerous bugs, glitches and pop ins.

Bundles don't count :p

Also, CoD comes bundled with an RC car, or action figures. BUNDLED. Doesn't count.

Seece said: Also, GTAV > All non bundled games, EVER.

Some people on here are too sensitive.  I don't think anyone can dispute that Rockstar had an amazing game with GTA5 (not just in terms of sales).  But not counting bundled games is absurd (see my last post).  

I do agree that the list should include multiplats that are the same  EXACT game released the same EXACT time (for example, COD and GTA5).  In that case, there would be some non-nintendo games in the top 15.  Otherwise, you are taking some of the much deserved kudos away from that developer.  I love Ninendo, but I think Activision and Rockstar deserve credit for their software giants too.

Also, sales do not necessarily equal quality.  Some of my favorite Nintendo games don't crack the top 15.  Some of my favorite games from Sony don't either.

Just another thread that needs locking and redone by somebody who can put their bias to the side, Carl you should definitely do it if you have the time. Be interesting to see the actual top 15.

Even with bundles GTAV is mammoth and top 5.

so, its 1 game.
if we count GTA4, and other 3 CoDs, would be 5 games.
Nintendo still have 10 in top 15.
Nintendo still dominates software.

Already had a talk with axumblade about this thread. He is a mod and approves my top 15 games by platform. You're a random dude, xbox afficionado, everybody knows that. If you're not happy:

-Get da fack out

And:

sayonara :D

double post

Inclined to think a DRGRUE alt

Your posts/threads are by far the worst, hurry up and get permabanned.

And non of this 'burns' me, I'm thinking you saw the front page thus the result is this thread

Yes there is, it's misleading. It'll get locked don't worry.

No it wouldn't, and that's certainly not how companies look at it either. This is a sku list, meaningless.

what Nintendo is not doooooooooooooOOooOoOoOoOmed??1