By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sales Discussion - October 2013 NPD Thread! 3DS: 452k, 360: 166k

phenom08 on 15 November 2013

@GMCMEN These are just home consoles lol. Mario/Zelda are surely still system sellers, see 3DS for proof.



Around the Network
Barozi on 15 November 2013

oVertrackinGChartz.

horrible numbers all around except 3DS hardware.



Kresnik on 15 November 2013

What a horrifically rubbish month. Good for 3DS hardware; horrible for everything else.

Was hoping we'd get some Blackgate numbers after I realised it released this month.



Read my Vita reviews here

Famitsu Japan Digital Sales Archive
Vita Media Create physical sales database
Vita vs. COMG Japan Sales Comparison

tbone51 on 15 November 2013
Lawlight said:
tbone51 said:

Woah Woah there buddy, ps4 most likely be the best selling home console by far but you dont kno if it will outsell 3DS lifetime. Dont make full accusations yet. Last time i checked 3DS is selling 13mil+ per year.


I know that it will sell less than the PS3.


you mke no sense at all. You compare pokemon XY to pokemon BW right?week by week comparison, yet 3ds is doing much better than ps3 was in the same timeframe but you wont count that? You make no sense at all



Kresnik on 15 November 2013

Compiling all the info into one post for my own sanity when I'm suggesting adjustments:

forest-spirit said:

360 did 166k.

 

Overtracked by 51k.
forest-spirit said:

Seems like Sonic ran into a wall, < 30k combined. Overtracked by 37k.

120k-125k for Beyond: Two Souls. Overtracked by 87k-92k.

I'm only counting Sonic as 47k combined, so only 17k overtracked.  Where did you get 37k from, may I ask?

Sh1nn said:
"Batman < 650k
PS3 + 360 = 98.2%
WiiU = 1.8%"

"Party U < Batman U, I'm not kidding.

TW101 LTD < 25k"

http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showpost.php?p=89941876&postcount=916
http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showpost.php?p=89941564&postcount=908

Using 650k as an upper limit, that means Batman sold at most 11,700.  So about 25k overtracked here (probably a little less).

That also means that Wii Party is possibly overtracked by about 3k.  Nothing too significant there actually.

Wonderful 101 tracking is off by about 6k as well.

Seece said:
PSV < 30k < Wii < 40k < 50k < Wii U < 60k < 100k < PS3 < 120k 

Dayum

Forest Spirit has kindly done the maths for me here :P

forest-spirit said:

Ze overtrackzies:

Wii U: 26k-36k

Wii: 12k-22k

Vita: 6k

PS3: 29k-49k

360: 51k

3DS: 11k

All in all, it's definitely a month of OvertrackingChartz.  The 3DS (and to a lesser extent Wii Party U) tracking is decent, though.



Read my Vita reviews here

Famitsu Japan Digital Sales Archive
Vita Media Create physical sales database
Vita vs. COMG Japan Sales Comparison

Around the Network
sales2099 on 15 November 2013

Surprised 360 still selling the way it is......kinda irritating MS still hasn't price dropped the higher end models.



Xbox: Best hardware, Game Pass best value, best BC, more 1st party genres and multiplayer titles. 

 

forest-spirit on 15 November 2013
Kresnik said:

 

forest-spirit said:

Seems like Sonic ran into a wall, < 30k combined. Overtracked by 37k.

120k-125k for Beyond: Two Souls. Overtracked by 87k-92k.

I'm only counting Sonic as 47k combined, so only 17k overtracked.  Where did you get 37k from, may I ask?

 


Oops, looked at the total instead of Week 4 for the Wii U version. >_>



tbone51 on 15 November 2013

Hey guys, pokemon isn't overtracked in the US by a million, its over by 600k (still alot). The numbers Boutros posted in the op are NoA number not US
here are US numbers http://www.vgchartz.com/game/71449/pokemon-xy/USA/

1.70mil Is wat pokemon XY sold in US while VGChartz tracked it at 2.28mil not 2.7mil

 

edit: Also There is a chance Europe is undertracked also Australia sold 100k first 2 days of sales and is listed in other which has 270k tracked here, so Other regions might be way undertracked. Pokemon XY is anywhere between 6mil -7.5mil sold WW including Digital sales



Boutros on 15 November 2013
tbone51 said:

Hey guys, pokemon isn't overtracked in the US by a million, its over by 600k (still alot). The numbers Boutros posted in the op are NoA number not US
here are US numbers http://www.vgchartz.com/game/71449/pokemon-xy/USA/

1.70mil Is wat pokemon XY sold in US while VGChartz tracked it at 2.28mil not 2.7mil

 

edit: Also There is a chance Europe is undertracked also Australia sold 100k first 2 days of sales and is listed in other which has 270k tracked here, so Other regions might be way undertracked. Pokemon XY is anywhere between 6mil -7.5mil sold WW including Digital sales

Huh no the numbers in the OP were for US. I don't take VGC NA numbers to compare with NPD US numbers...

It was simply adjusted down since yesterday.



tbone51 on 15 November 2013
Boutros said:
tbone51 said:

Hey guys, pokemon isn't overtracked in the US by a million, its over by 600k (still alot). The numbers Boutros posted in the op are NoA number not US
here are US numbers http://www.vgchartz.com/game/71449/pokemon-xy/USA/

1.70mil Is wat pokemon XY sold in US while VGChartz tracked it at 2.28mil not 2.7mil

 

edit: Also There is a chance Europe is undertracked also Australia sold 100k first 2 days of sales and is listed in other which has 270k tracked here, so Other regions might be way undertracked. Pokemon XY is anywhere between 6mil -7.5mil sold WW including Digital sales

Huh no the numbers in the OP were for US. I don't take VGC NA numbers to compare with NPD US numbers...

It was simply adjusted down since yesterday.


They did it real quick? thats a huge surprise!!! My bad, I thought it would be easy to mix up the two. I mean no Offense to you! You do a good job as always! Srry for doubting you

I still standby as wat i said about Europe+ Other region. I always knew US was overtrackedy by at least 500k!

Well... Carry on then...