Oh, how terrified I am of your sharpened pieces of metal.

I highly doubt many will agree with me but here goes.

Disagree

GTA IV is a boring dull game with lackluster plot and characters, it also falls short in variety of vehicles.

Bioshock is great, but a 96, I mean that's a little overrated for what it is.

Skyrim has no memorable quests or characters with a weak main plot, quests and dungeons are repetative, gameplay is average.

LittlebigPlanet is alright, but is just a decent sidescroller, not worthy of a 95 score.

Agree

Mass effect 2, I just really loved this game mainly for it's exciting gameplay and great character development.

Uncharted 2 is an amazing and thouroghly enjoyable experience

Haven't played

Super Mario Galaxy 1 and 2

Orange Box

Arkham City

I agree but I just have a odd felling with some games.

Grand Theft Auto IV 94-95 not 98.
Mass Effect 2 90-91 not 96
Elder Scrolls: Skyrim 92-93 not 96

The others I think it's ok.

i think The Last of Us will crack that barrier

Disagree with Skyrim and Uncharted. Batman may deserve to be in the top 10, but not necessarily in the spot it is.

I would take down ME2 and put Assassins Creed 2 somewhere on the list. Haven't played GTA4 yet (other than the first hour), but I don't think it deserves to be on the top of the list.

SMG1 and 2, Bioshock, Orange Box may be ok in top10, I disagree with the other 6. I can't tell about batman to be honest, I haven't played it.

Some are good games but they all seem overrated. I personally don't think Bioshock or Batman deserve a place anywhere near the top 10.

bioshock deserves 1 and not 2-10, that's right

The only games I strongly disagree with are littlebigplanet and grand theft auto 4. Even though littlebigplanet's concept is briliant, the actual platforming is just plain bad. It is a lot more fun making a map than playing through it and that's a big problem. And grand theft auto is the perfect example of whats wrong with this gen. They sacrificed gameplay and size for graphics and cinematics. 

There are a few other games on the list that I didn't really enjoy but I can see what they brought to the table that made them worthy of being on the list. (Mass Effect 2 and Uncharted 2).