The only games I strongly disagree with are littlebigplanet and grand theft auto 4. Even though littlebigplanet's concept is briliant, the actual platforming is just plain bad. It is a lot more fun making a map than playing through it and that's a big problem. And grand theft auto is the perfect example of whats wrong with this gen. They sacrificed gameplay and size for graphics and cinematics.
There are a few other games on the list that I didn't really enjoy but I can see what they brought to the table that made them worthy of being on the list. (Mass Effect 2 and Uncharted 2).







