It may be the best Gears game ever but I don't think it's the best game of all time. Depending on how the campaign goes it may creep into my top ten games.

It's my favorite pure TPS ever I think. I like Mass Effect 2 more overall though characters, story, some RPG elements. I consider neither the best game ever though. But for a TPS with muscley marine guys and the kind of characters I don't really like. This is amazing.

I Really love the game, but I wouldn't even say its the best game this year. Best Gears (maybe) and Best looking 360 game for sure.

''best game of all time'' *rolls eyes* ye alright...

toastyboy is back ;)
No, not the best game of all time, but the best Gears.
And I really like this franchise.

hahahaha, opinions are nice.

short answer: No, with a "if..."

long answer: Yes, with a "but..."

no, but thats probably because i prefer different type of games (RPGs and story based games) though ironically if i pick one that i consider my favorite game of all time is Shadow Of The Colossus.

so it might be the best game of all time to you.

Let him mark out haha its well deserved. I personally haven't had the chance to pick up the game but it looks epic, can't wait til i get my hands on it!

Well that puts it blatantly for sure lol, but I agree I can't picture this being the supposed best game ever, though it looks awesome and makes me a bit jealous of you fancy 360 owners >.>