It has merit. Some scenes are very well done, so well done that you kinda make a series of scenes in your imagination while you read it. Overall though, I didn't really dig it.

Looks like LOTR is killing.

Im not really surprised, but thought Potter would have gotten more votes due to the fan base on this site.

LOTR >> Harry Potter >>> [...] >>> Twilight

The Lord of the Rings by far.
And by far I mean very, very far.

4 and 5 are easily the worst in my opinion. Her attempts at writing her characters growing up were laughably bad. I found six and seven pretty enjoyable as long as I ignored the gaping plot holes (almost all of which were caused by her clearly having made shit up as she went along).

I think three is the strongest book.

Harry Potter. I just can't get into TLOTR.

Hahaha, interestingly enough, I consider 3 easily the worst of the worst.

LOTR. Read it twice (before the movies were announced when I was a kid, and in between the movies) and liked it.

I tried to read Harry Potter once to see what all the fuzz was about... just a regular story for kids for me, I had to stop after 100 pages. I didn't see the appeal.

I don't even know what Twilight is.

Books:
Harry Potter is the best series. LOTR didn't really captivate me the same way and Twilight is sometimes entertaining, but nothing more than average writing.

Movies:
LOTR is the best series for being cohesive and impressive all around. Harry Potter has ups and downs. Twilight is forgettable (only watched the first one).

For books I have read The Hobbit and The Fellowship of the Ring and I really enjoyed them, but I'd have to give a slight advantage to Harry Potter with reading 1-3.

For Movies, definitely Lord of the Rings. I can't wait for the new Hobbit series too.