It is an 8 for me.
The Wii U will be revolutionary, once again. Yet I wished they showed more games, some specs and a price.

7 out of 10, which is combining three metrics: post-show hype, presentation, and content. It does seem like they might strike that note of 3rd party parity which was essential for the new console, announced a bunch of neat free incentives. New console is a new console, hype incarnate, and they showed a bunch of new tech ideas that will keep people thinking

As a presentation it was mixed, very strong start but an ending that left everyone confused. Hopefully they'll fill out more information by the end of the day.

Content wise, few "new" games (though some of these were "new to nintendo," so they kinda count), some better looks at upcoming games (though why oh why did they skimp on Skyward), but a console itself counts on content.

It left me wanting more, which is good and bad at once. Bad because it shows poor presentation skills, but good because i'm interested in what they have to offer and what to know more about their products and services. WTH was up with that whole EA bit, anyway. What did that mean?

I'd say 4/10. I never thought I'd be so uninterested in a new console coming from Nintendo. Maybe it's because they didn't really show off many games for it, or because they didn't explain that giant controller with the screen very much. And no new Wii games!!! WTF Nintendo?

Sony wins by defaul with a 5/10.

Just a sad, sad E3 all around this year.

Spam!

9/10 for me. The best conference of the week, easily. Wiiu looks promising and the interactivity with the controller looks better than I could ever have imagined!

The 3DS stuff looks fairly awesome as well and really makes it seem like that's what they're pushing

But not much Wii stuff, and it seems as though they ran out of time, sadly. But I'm waiting for playtests now to see how it went. And lest we forget, there were 5 games at the end for Wii that weren't mentioned in the conference!

It was going well, then they screwed up everything by showing that the Wii U was a confirmation of all the bad rumors and topping it off by not showing any games for it except ports.

Also, too much talk and too little gameplay shown.

oops.

How many presenters do you want on stage at once? I think you need to keep it simple sometimes.

I'm a bit disappointed...

+ New Mario for 3DS
+ Mario Kart 3DS
+ Overall 3DS lineup was solid
+ WiiU's controller and the possibilities looked great

- "WiiU" (what a terrible name)
- Only a montage of a few multiplatform games (what about exclusives?)
- Wii is dead (in terms of software support) and this conference proves it
- They didn't even show live gameplay or a new trailer of Zelda (only this montage at the beginning)

Score: 6/10

I'm thinking about all my scores again, somehow every press conference disappointed me a bit or more.

I have been wondering about that myself, but I expect WiiU to support at least 2 tablets ..

So you expect them to release another basic controller (like the classic controller) that doesn't have screen on it for 4 player multiplayer action?