oh stop it you bitter bitter charizard fan!

Blue > Red.

You should see Simsala now, he's so underpowered it's sad.  He also contributes to why the later games are better.

I personally don't see how any Pokemon game could be different. You just throw balls and hit attack.

I knew this was a joke thread when I saw Gold>Silver......great joke thread smokedhostage.

almost as good as your "FF12 is the best FF eva!!" thread!

Only real loss is Arcanine, but the lack of Skarmory and especially Ninetales is not acceptable.

But since you get Lugia earlier, Silver is the definite version. (just saying definite, because everybody's doing it lol)

Gold better than Silver?

You mad.

Cool watery bird thingy > Turkey.

I agree with most of those, but Silver is totally better than Gold, and Yellow is the best of its gen solely cuz Pikachu could follow you around.

You're visibly upset.

Phoenix, Peacock thingie > giant whale bird thingie with HUEG hands.

Hostage, why have you sunk this low?

This is even lower than me.