Ok, My predictions are of a more "I have no idea" variety

Animal Crossing - This was my pic, though truth be told, I'm not sure it will reach DS levels, which could make things close.

Fable 2 - I expect it to be amazing. I also expect it to do between 3 and 4 million

Gears of War 2 - 6 mill minimum. It's the boxes new Halo, and the second iteration has a lot more hype than the first. May be a contender.

Little Big Planet - another up in the air. 2 mil min, but a max could be anything.

Resistance 2 - 3 to 4 sounds good I think. 

Wii Music - that's the big ? No one can really answer this one. Not a single person can predict it.

So yeah, no idea. Not a damn idea... I'm worthless.

It will sell to a very different and much less informed (about games) audience than GH or RB. Also a much bigger market.

@ faywong...I knew someone was going to get up in arms about the "exclusivity" of some of the titles. And you're right...but I'm just not sure what to put in the 360 spot then. And that may have angered more than just the pc gamers. Of course...that has more to do with Microsoft's business model (which is fit for an entirely different thread). One wonders if Gears (and the 360 itself) would sell more if Microsoft didn't port games over to the PC.

@ everyone....great analysis so far. If you put this question on any other site you'd just get the canned fanboy response...but that's what makes VGC so great. There's depth to the responses and solid numbers.

I'm a bit surprised, honestly, at the steam that Wii Music has. Obviously many must feel that Nintendo has the Midas touch when they put Wii in front of anything...regardless of its perceived quality. And I know that if these predictions turn out to be true there will be many angry gamers running these halls and being offended by said game's existence.

I'm very surprised at the LBP predictions. I mean out of all of the options I think it might sell the least. Oh well, we will wait and see.

Just for fun super_etecoon, ask which version of GH4 will sell the most? I honestly want to see the response to that.

I voted AC based on the strength of its sales on the DS. But it may turn out that all the Wii Music bashing is just a vocal minority, so it could be Wii Music too

I pretty much echo gobias's predictions, although would raise LBP to 2-5 mill and believe that AC has the potential to break 10 million. Wii music is more of an unknown, it could even sell as 'low' as 5 million, but 10 million range is more likely

Agreed. That's what I voted for.

Animal Crossing: City Folk?

only b/c it has the biggest market to go to

Animal Crossing:12m
Wii Music: 10m
Gow2: 7m
Resistance2: 4.5m
LBP: 4m
Fable2:3m

Yep. The poll does not make any sense though. You cannot compare sales between a game that has an "E" rating with one that is "M".

AC most likely, or Wii music.