all three were below par. but if i had to pick a winner among the 3
1. Tie Sony(PSN Games, UT/Haze Exclusives/Infamous/NC Soft Deal) / Nintendo (FPS Zapper, Online Play, Wii Kart, Wii Wheel, Wii Board + Wii Fit)
3. Microsoft (No major announcement, the lollipops were not funny)

 Its his opinion you know, he might not like shooters or even know who NCsoft is. Might hate portables and could give a rats ass about family guy. Mods my be completely foreign to him. Please realize different people like different things. Your opinion is not definitive in an way shape or fashion. He likes what he likes, and he owes you no explanation the same way you dont owe him one for liking what you like.

IMO they went like this:

Sony

Nintendo

MS

A ton of the stuff Sony showed for PS3 didnt really excite me one bit. But MGS4 did. Only one game yeah, but their PSP lineup was what I liked. Nintendo lost IMO because they showed some great stuff but ignored DS, Although Mario Kart online Galaxy looking amazing and 32 player MoH kinda makes me salivate. Had they announced their DS games at their conference instead of afterwards (HELLO THERE ADVANCE WARS 2 AND MARIO PARTY DS YAY!) I may have placed them even with Sony, but they didnt. They spent a ton of time on Youtube montages and sales charts that Im personally all to familiar with anyway.

MS did well also but hampered themselves by sticking to the 2007 lineup. Basically we got mega announcements out of Sony and Nintendo. Online 12 player Mario Kart early next year is insane and came out of nowhere. inFamous looked fantastic and was a total out of nowhere surprise. MS showed good looking stuff but no shockers at all unless Disney movies and Scene it gets you hot. Thats why they bring up the rear.

Lastly I was surprised to see Sony not even try a little to court that casual audience. As ridiculous as Scene it and Disney movies are, hell its an attempt. Sony doesnt seem to be interested. But I think the market is going to adopt more casual gamers whether they prepare themselves for it or not. 

 stfu and read my whole post before you start quoting me and getting condescending.

 you cared enough to call out my post saying it so i simply responded, take care.

From before you tried to teach me a lesson:

but thanks for the lesson on opinions. You should maybe look into a foot in mouth lesson sometime soon.

Well accprding to the killzone developers, it is a pre PRE alpha not a pre alpha.

For us gamers (~3% of Earth's population):

Sony
Nintendo
Microsoft

For the rest of the world:

Nintendo
Nintendo
Nintendo

 Way to cover! well done.

They were all underwhelming. (I have yet to watch any videos, though.) Here's my quick take on everything:

3. MS was the biggest snore. No price drop? You have got to be kidding me. Though one a couple weeks later will allow the news to not be drowned out by all the noise from the show. And I don't think Scene It will entice casual gamers to the 360. They should really bring that game to the Wii since it already has the proper controllers.

2. Moving right along to Nintendo, at least there was a surprise. WTF with the Wii Balance Board? It's definitely unique, but how many different controllers and attachments are there going to be for the system? Nintendo's bringing out their own wheel shell for Mario Kart Wii in 1st Q 2008. Oh and the Wii Zapper looks like crap. C-R-A-P! All in all, everything promised for this year is coming out, plus a few extras that won't excite too many. Then again, they can't even make enough system to satisfy current demand. So why do anything to drive it even higher? ;)

1. Sony probably had the best presentation by default. They got to announce the somewhat slimmer, lighter, yet it looks almost exactly the same, PSP. Not that it's a bad thing. A faster UMD Drive and longer battery life make this a PSP 1.1. And it's a decent price -- $200 with Daxter, Family Guy UMD, and 1 GB Mem. Stick. They pushed forward with their games, announced a few timed exclusives, and didn't really f&^% anything up. Which is a lot better than last year.