I hate to say it, but I gotta agree with Prime 4's critics: the game's alright, but definitely my overall least favorite entry in the Prime franchise. This entry may have the most impressive graphics (most detailed on the Switch 2, seriously!), excellent performance at high frame rates, better play controls, some pretty good music, and just enough of that all-important sense of isolation to fundamentally satisfy, but I dislike most of the "new" they tried to do. I dislike the MCU-ification of this franchise to the extent that it's present, the entire desert overworld concept, relative lack of inspired enemies, and excessively linear level design. All in all, Prime 4 to me feels like...I dunno, more or less what I would've expected from the next entry had it been released in 2010 instead of Other M. But this isn't 2010. I only truly enjoyed about 60% of my playthrough.
To me, the best entries in the Metroid franchise remain basically three generations of the same game: Metroid, Super Metroid, and Metroid Prime. Well okay, the original Metroid doesn't hold up well today, but what I mean by including it among the best entries is that it introduced the basic concept upon which Super Metroid was built (and also got me interested in the franchise...and in video games). Metroid Prime, in turn, really just turned the Super Metroid type experience into a 3D first-person experience, including even essentially the same opening. All deviations from this base formula have proven inferior in my mind; the difference is just one of degrees. I hate to be a boring purist because I'm not one of those when it comes to most game franchises, but I think what I really want out of this one really is just more of that. For me, this franchise is at its best when it's a heavily atmosphere-driven experience that centers on exploration. Prime 4 all in all just isn't quite eerie enough, it's not quite free enough for my preference, too much of it is too crowded, and it's got too much pointless filler content to feel like a real labor of love. I give it maybe a 70%. I definitely liked Metroid Dread better too.
At this point, I think I'm open to ideas like the next Metroid game being a 2D-HD conversion of Super Metroid or something. I don't think this franchise is ever truly gonna outdo that game.
Last edited by Jaicee - 6 hours ago