Chrkeller said:
Soundwave said:
Actually I don't think you realize making that arguement isn't really supporting your case. A Series S is only a 4 TFLOP machine, which by that token should be only a PS4 Pro tier machine, but it runs every PS5/XSX game ... which puts it into the PS5/XSX generation, which is exactly what I'm saying. So no, XBox Series S is an argument you don't even want to touch, lol. Just walking yourself straight into a logic pit you don't want to get into.
XBox Series S is not a PS4 Pro or XBox One X even though the teraflop compute level is similar on paper and far below the XBox Series X/PS5.
|
Nah it fits my argument perfectly. I'll spell it out so you can understand. I'll also drop it so we don't derail the thread.
Running the same games are significantly lower performance and fidelity means the hardware isn't equivalent.
(It is that simple)
Enjoy your drunken frog.
|
Equivalent hardware isn't required to be part of the same generation.
By that logic then a 3090 even is a different generation from the PS5 or a 2080, but no one seriously says that.
Or XBox Series S is a different generation from Playstation 5. No one seriously says that either.
Generational leap has to be something where the successive hardware runs the majority of its games that the other hardware that you're trying to claim is in a different generation cannot run. Like for example a Playstation 2 versus a Playstation 1. If a PS1 could run PS2 games at just moderately lower settings and resolution but otherwise it was running the same games, then you have a problem there, that is not a generational leap any longer. That distinction becomes entirely meaningless in that case.
That argument doesn't work anymore when the hardware you're trying to say "is last generation" is running many of the same games even at lower settings.
The Switch 2 will likely have a ton of PS5 ports for various reasons, more than the Switch 1 had in common with the PS4, but there's already a system that basically does this, Steam Deck will likely in a few years have something like 75, 80, 100 PS5/XSX only games that it runs. That automatically invalidates it as a "PS4 level hardware". If it's "PS4 level hardware" it shouldn't be running those games period, in any form other than like maybe 2 frames per second.
Going from Low PC settings to Medium/High PC settings (which is what most PS5 games run at) and changing the resolution is not a generational leap. Otherwise I'd have been jumping generations all the time back in the day because I'd change my PC settings all the time playing games like Mech Warrior II and Starcraft and Sim City 2000 back in the day, on no planet would we consider that a generational leap though. A generational leap was going from a NES to a Super NES or PS1 to PS2 or N64 to GameCube. If what generational leaps have become nowadays are just basically tweaking PC settings, well then the whole distinction of generations has become somewhat meaningless because that's not what it was intended to be.
Last edited by Soundwave - on 16 November 2023