I mean, it was a lot of ports, some new games that I'm not too excited about...6. You mileage will definitely vary and I could see higher than a 6 if you were a fan of more of the newer games shown.

The unification of handheld and home console businesses hasn't done a lot for the Switch this past year, at least when it comes with EPD releases. 

Splatoon is not my thing. Mehrio golf. If they at least showed Pokemon Snap, I wouldn't be so disappointed.

My personal take would be 2/10, The lame addition for smash really pissed me off. No more heroes and monster hunter look cool but we already knew that

Analysing it without my fellings, I gave 6/10. Hades physical edition is really not worthy content for a good direct. Too many old ports. Pyra don't adds nothing for the smash rooster. It's really lame no matter how you put it

There's a chance Pokemon Company will be doing their own thing around the 27th. 

I'd give it a 6.8/10, not in terms of game content though, I just don't think this direct was put together that well. When you take into account the amount of games we already know are releasing in the next few months (Super Mario 3D World + Bowser's Fury, Ghosts n Goblins: Resurrection, Bravely Default II in February, Monster Hunter Rise, Balan Wonderworld in March, Pokemon Snap in April, etc) it's already a really good first half and this Direct did a nice job at filling out some of the rest of the year and even further things to look forward to.

Good:

Mario Golf looks incredibly fun. Miitopia coming back is a nice surprise. Never heard of Famicom Detective Club but it's cool that it's something getting localized for the first time for those interested. Some good third party gets like Fall Guys, Ninja Gaiden Collection, Outer Wilds, etc. Release date for No More Heroes III, glad to see Hades getting a physical edition. Neon White looks really interesting, same with World's End Club. 

Bad:

I normally don't care about this but I do think this Direct was a bit over reliant on ports/remasters and such with not many new games, and then some of the new games they did show weren't really shown well. Knockout City looks like it could be fun but that trailer really didn't do it any favors. Star Wars Hunters might as well have not even been there. The Zelda announcements seemed a lil poorly done, like the Season Pass for Age of Calamity being 30 seconds and then Skyward Sword HD. 

I'm conflicted on Splatoon 3 because I love the franchise but in a way this feels too early and I would have much rather seen it saved for the Switch successor. 

Not great, but also not a bad direct either. I liked it. 

It was alright.

6/10 especially after a long time with no directs.

Splatoon 3 is huge and it started alright but in the end it ended abruptly without really showing something new that makes people excited.

Mario Gold was great because it started okay but they showed the speed mode and that looks fun and ended it with announcing a story mode.  Even if you don't like Gold I think many are interested in the game because of those additions.

The rest felt weak and typical Nintendo.  It is sad that I can play games on other consoles that I bought in 2007 digitally with better graphics/frames etc for free while we have to buy a game from 2011 again if we want to play it on switch that's probably going to be full priced. It would have been fine in a collection...oh well.

7/10
Splatoon 3 really carried it for me.

6 out of 10.

My highlights were Pyra/Mythra as a new DLC fighter for Smash Bros., something I've been asking for since I played Xenoblade 2 so I was VERY happy to see that. And Skyward Sword HD - Skyward Sword is still my favorite Zelda game of all time, and it USED to be my favorite game, period, until I played Persona 5. And the fact that it's now getting the HD remaster treatment makes me very ecstatic.
I also enjoyed the Mario Golf and Splatoon 3 announcements.

Everything else... Meh.
And honestly, for the first Nintendo Direct in nearly a year and a half, I was expecting a little more. I love Skyward Sword to death, but when I saw Aonuma pop up on the screen, I was hoping, praying, and crossing my fingers for Breath of the Wild 2. I was expecting that one BIG game to wow me, and while I'm fully aware that Splatoon 3 is that game for a lot of people, and I am happy to see it... It wasn't quite what I was looking for.
There was plenty of other stuff there that looks great like Monster Hunter and Triangle Strategy, but not really my cup of tea.

Overall, it wasn't terrible, but it wasn't great either. So yeah, 6/10.

It was okay, kinda wished they showed updates on current big projects instead of Splatoon 3 that releases next year.
Next direct will have Botw 2 tho