TruckOSaurus said: I was curious about this whole comments issue and figured I'd check some things out. I've had a look at YouTube comments for The Last of Us 2, FFVII:R, Resident Evil 3:Remake and Red Dead Redemption 2 and Half-life Alyx. TLOU2 is the only one featuring these meme-ing on IGN type comments. I thought it might be reserved for 10/10 games so that's why I checked RDR2 and HL:A but comments are mostly serious there. Same for FFVII:R and RE3:R. It's nothing conclusive because my survey was very fast but it does seem TLOU2 has been targeted for some reason. Even the comments that are not bashing Ellie's sexuality seem to be suggesting that IGN has been bought by either Sony or Naughty Dog : "This review has been approved by Naughty Dog and Sony" 10/10 - IGN “We were once considered respectable journalists in the game industry.” 10/10 IGN Mixed into that there's people trashing ND for their bad treatment of their developers. So, I do feel there's a crowd of people attacking the game because of its "agenda" and that it wouldn't have happened had the game featured Joel has the protagonist. It's sad to see how popular those comments are (even if it's mostly stupid teenagers upvoting). |
I'd just add the caveat that I kind of doubt it's mostly teenagers doing the up-voting. I mean considering how many of the comments reference wives. The 'it's just teenagers' assessment also just doesn't make a lot of sense in that I think we kinda know that younger people tend to be more progressive than older people.
There's also a reason why I choose the term misogyny to describe the situation here more than homophobia. Take another look at the samples I highlighted earlier. You'll find it's much more common for heterosexual women to get lumped into these critiques of Ellie than it is for gay men to. (Hence all the references to wives and their boyfriends and such.)
Last edited by Jaicee - on 16 June 2020