Some of those aren't new ip. Half that list were considered to be huge disappointments.
"Some of those aren't new ip." *looks at OP*
Star Wars Force Unleashed (Spin off of old series)
Forza (Released on Original Xbox)
Red Dead Redemption (Red Dead Revolver on PS2)
Call of Duty (Launched Previous Gen)
Battlefield Bad Company (Spinoff of old series)
Halo Wars (Spinoff of older series)
Metal Gear Solid Revengeance (Spin off of old series)
Duke Nukem (Reboot)
Fallout (Sequel to game from the 90's)
Killzone (Released on PS2)
"Half that list were considered to be huge dissapointments" HAZE
But you really think many of these games are "massive disappointments"? Of the 60 listed I think maybe 5 could match that criteria imo.
The Order 1886
No Man Sky
Super Lucky's Tale
And while No Man Sky was disappointing at launch, it isn't anymore.
I'm just talking a out your list. His one has weird mistakes and is a LOT less comprehensive than yours.
Mario and rabbids, 2 dragon quests, final fantasy, dirt, middle earth, mad max. Which brings your list of new ips to 35.
Massive disappointments might have been an exaggeration, but a large portion of your list was considered disappointing to a degree.
Sea of thieves
Super luckys tale
No man's sky
The evil within
All of these have a meta of 80 or less. Which generally considered a little disappointing at least. A lot scored in the low 70s or worse.
I cut out 28, which brings your list of currently released new ips, to around 14.