Who do you think should win GOTY? 

I'm calling Witcher 3. That game has bar none set standards for not only RPG's but for  what next gen expansions should look like.

Xenoblade isn't actually out yet so you may want to hold off. :/

It's going to be a massively split vote this year. There are a lot of great games that appeal to people with different tastes. It's certainly not going to be a The Last of Us situation. Fallout, Witcher, Metal Gear, and Bloodborne are all going to take home a bunch of trophies. Perhaps even Tomb Raider, as well. Splatoon will win some and Halo will win some. Can't think of any others off the top of my head.

There will be a lot of different GOTY winners, which means a lot of people whining and complaining about the opinions of others. I can't wait.

I just want to see Splatoon win the Best Shooter category, just because of the flamewars it would cause. And because I don't want to see Battlefront win it, with all the cut content from BFII.

This

It's The Witcher 3 for me, and by a huge margin. Fallout 4 can't compete here, TW3 is in a class of its own.

It would be a travesty if Fallout 4 or MGSV won game of the year, so for me it has to be between Bloodborne and The Witcher 3. I've played both and got bored with one, so I'll go with Bloodborne.

Probably Witcher 3, press loved how it redefined (according to them) open-world RPGs.

My personal GOTY is Pillars of Eternity, although it's not really up there with Planescape: Torment or BG2.

The wait really wasn't necessary. The GOTY already dropped in July.

Im just going to be honest. I forgot about that game and my hype for starfox has slightly gone down. Thats pretty tough to do since Star Fox is my favorite Nintendo franchise.