There's no point in the comparison since one is a compilation of old games vs a new game.

Almost definitely Uncharted. Bigger install base and it's just an absolute bargain to get 3 awesome games for the price of 1.

If the Uncharted bundle lasts through the holidays, then Uncharted.

I think both will struggle under the release of other big AAA titles, especially X1 with Halo 5.

Uncharted has the best chance of doing well due to new PS owners buying the game, it releasing before most major games, having the Uncharted 4mp, and it being a refresher before Uncharted as a franchise comes to an end.

In addition, I think Sony will bundle the game to increase the anticipation for uncharted 4.

Also, one is a platform only exclusive and the other is timed.

I would say Tomb Raider because Remasters dont sell that well. Both MCC and TLOUR only sold 2m where as a freah new game could end up selling past 3m especially a game like TR.

Then no one should be surprised when the Uncharted collection outsells Tomb Raider. lol

Sure, this is the only variable in this equation...

What has changed to warrant a thread bump? Or did you want to get more attention for your thread?

The Tomb Raider bundle would need a significant price cut to be able make difference especially since it's one of 6 MS holiday bundles and I believe not even available at every retailer, so I'll stick with Uncharted for now, looks like a pretty clear case at the moment.

Uncharted launches this Friday.